The servers are always nice, great ambiance, and good value!
My chicken sandwich was good but much too bulky to even stuff into your mouth. Not to be ordered on a business meal when conversation is essential.
We were looking for an outdoor dining space that had an appealing and varied menu. Everly fit the bill. Food was great, so was the service and the venue met our COVID-Friendly objective.
Nice outside ambience. Comfortable seating. Had the chicken, eggs, and waffle with honey. Eggs were done perfectly. Fried chicken and the waffle were pretty dry.
Decaf Latte with Almond milk was fair.
Nice ambiance and decor, but the food was mediocre. Both avocado toast and the breakfast bagel were ok but not great. The service was very attentive and courteous.
Celery salad with salmon or chicken is great and the cuban sandwich is also good. We enjoyed the drinks and food - service was a little slow but they were busy. also possibly short staffed?
We love it here and will return soon.
Fish fry was excellent. I'd pass on the roasted carrot appetizer.
Excellent food and service. I had the squash curry with pulled chicken and it was delicious. I would recommend it. Also, I appreciated the fact that Everly has outdoor dining, a safer way for social distancing and open air..
Favorite restaurant in the city! Fresh, bold, unique flavors and warm hospitality.
I’m so happy I found this place. Everything was great. Bravo.
Everything was phenomenal! I'm going to be dreaming about that food for a while!
It was great! The food was wonderful. Our drinks did sit on the end of the bar for awhile and were brought to us as our food was also arriving. That was disappointing.
The food here is amazing! I recommend the grain bowl and the butternut squash curry dish!
Wonderful outside dining at Everly. I especially like the way staff worked together to create delicious food and a lovely dining experience. Kudos.
OMG! I can’t say enough good things about this place!! We are major foodies (or rather “food snobs”, as my husband likes to rob in,) so the bar is generally high, but we were on a 5 hour trip from WI to IL, the kids were exhausted and this place seemed to have decent reviews. So we booked a table 20 minutes prior to showing up. And from the moment we walked through the door and were greeted by the manager, to being seated on their lovely outdoor patio, to being welcomed by our waitress - it was all uphill and beyond! The food and the presentations is amazing, service - very personable and caring! I wish you guys were closer to Chicago, but you bet, I’ll be back next time we’re in Madison! Thanks for having us!!
We've been to Everly many times and are always happy with everything we order. The food and service were great, and their COVID precautions made us feel very comfortable. The prices are a little high for the portions, but the flavor makes it worth it. We'll be back again and again!
Delicious food and even better service. We enjoyed brunch on the patio with our pup!
Great! I'll be there next time.
The Salmon was delicious! Great service, good food, good value!
We chose to dine outside where they have converted part of the parking lot - it was nicely done. The weather turned cool (7PM) but a light fleece was just right. Food and server were great!
Food was good, as always. I love that you can reserve a table on the patio.
still one of my favorite places but have only been on the patio. was hard to hear each other - just across the table inside. May be better with more folks to help absorb the noise. will return
Wonderful food, attentive staff, a real treat every time.
Great service from reservation to sitting us down to paying up. Food was also good. The new pasta dish is delicious. The salmon can be cooked just a little less. It was too firm in my mind. The ambience was good except for the evening mosquitoes. Not sure if they can do something about that.
They honored our outside reservation. The seating outside is not comfortable but it is outside. The food was good. We had the squash curry and the buttermilk chicken sandwich.
Great food and great atmosphere. Will absolutely be back for brunch again.
Loved the new celery and lemon vinegrette salad; and the cuban sandwich my partner got was very good too.
Thanks for being innovative with cooking.
A couple of years ago we used to get the baked (fried) chicken and it was very good. Wish you would have this back on the menu again, rather than the curry chicken.
I love Everly, everything about this place is great! Atmosphere is chill and cool, and the staff is also really friendly. Great outdoor seating (wonderful, especially in the midst of a pandemic). Making the customers happy is their main priority. Food is great, and for their prices it’s 100% worth it.
Quick, efficient service and great food! Try the calamari fries
We arrived very early. The service and food were great as always.
Great way to celebrate moving to a new apartment for our son’s senior year of college.
The perfect place for dinner and drinks with a friend. We sat on the patio and were fortunate to have lovely weather. Jordan was our server and hit that sweet spot of giving excellent service while also giving us the amount of time we needed. Drinks and food were delightful. This was my first time at Everly, but won't be my last.
I’ve been wanting to try this restaurant ever since it opened. Finally decided to do one of our first outings after covid here. The food was very good. However, the service was quite poor. I know everywhere is short staffed and I am completely understanding to that. However, we only saw our waitress when we ordered drinks and when we placed our order for food. Another waiter brought out our entrees. Never once did anyone ask if we needed anything or how our food was. After we finished our meals we waited another 30 min before I waved down another staff member to ask if we could have more water and get our bill. After we paid, our waitress finally came back to our table to ask if we needed anything.
Again, I understand everywhere is short staffed. However, I think it would be best to have less reservations if you can’t handle the amount of customers.
We came for drinks and dessert and it was very pleasant! Very few restaurants have their desserts on the menu, which motivated us to come to Everly.
So great and many options for those with food sensitivities!
The first issue was there was a problem with our table, there was a leak above and it took awhile to get someone’s attention to solve this issue.
Our service person was not attentive to serving us. We were always waiting for her for to take our order to return to see if our food tasted great or correct.
When it came to ending the service, she automatically gave us the bill. Didn’t offer us dessert or if we wanted separate checks. And when we asked for separate checks she split the bill. I was charged for something I didn’t order. Not good, she ended with half the tip I would normally give. Be attentive to your customers needs!
The food was great! Service was a little lacking- we had to ask for water refills, etc… but food was delicious!
First time at Everly. I will definitely be a return customer.
Everly is an attractive dining venue offering a varied and tasty menu. The food is well prepared and presented. The portions are on the small side but pricing is reasonably aligned with this choice. This restaurant will go on our list as one to re-visit.
Authentic neighborhood restaurant, airy and appealing. Every dish was distinctive and flavorful. Portion sizes were reasonable and well priced, not too big, just right to encourage more than one course. I am a foodfightinc fan, and Everly holds its own among many fine choices. I look forward to our next meal there.
Everly offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (608) 416-5242.
Everly is rated 4.6 stars by 540 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.