Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Pittsburgh

Received an $8 credit for a $12 side. Seems fair. Frozen in the middle first croquet. Cold in the second. Stopped eating my steak and waited for assistance. I like to eat my steak with my sides and this was already 4 minutes after the entree arrived. Which being cut table side for 4 minutes, means they were never even started. 10 minutes later the waitress is available. Not her fault. Her support staff failed her. Not once did anyone even make eye contact let alone ask how things are, since the waitress is detained preparing a bananas foster tableside across the room. Of course the loud inappropriately dressed corporate tab was attended to very well by the support staff. There's a reason the reservation was available.

Great Service and great food

Came here for Christmas luncheon. Had very attentive waiter. Place is definitely upscale. Had cup of French Onion soup coupled with Ocean Cobb salad. Was given homemade baked bread to go with my lunch. Everything was excellent! They do have limited vegan and vegetarian options and they do catering. They have a full service bar on one side and a view of Liberty Ave on the restaurant side.

This is a great place for a special occasion or if you have a businessman's luncheon. Met the manager who made me feel at home. Definitely a must return!

The food and the atmosphere was fantastic.

Service was amazing. Food was amazing. It was a great night out with some girlfriends

Great place

It’s hard to find a good steak and it’s always a disappointment when it’s not cooked right after you do.

The quality of meat is excellent and I’ve never had a missed cooked steak three times now’

Eddie Merlot’s is my go to place to make a reservation valet my truck and have a good time with whoever came with me’

Great experience

Food great.
Service very good.
Nice location. Very clean inside.
Only problem was the parking, valet was advertised and checked in then when we arrived there was no valet, my vehicle didn't fit in the 6ft parking garage they validate at so we had to walk a bit AND pay $25. Very displeased with that. Other than that very good.
AMAZING selection of steaks

Very loud in bar area. Food and service were excellent.

The service is hit - miss . Starts out good but goes downhill fast . It seems to lose the connection with the server after the order is taken . Not consistently good for the price you pay . Experience is just Ok because of service, but the food is good and the place is beautiful.

As always the food and service was wonderful. Love the place.

Great service from top notch waitstaff. Sizable appetizer portions. Wagyu strip was awesome. Bison filet perfectly prepared and delicious.

Sat in the side dinning room dark,cold, the center dinning room has great ambiance but was Istuck in a back corner

Good, not great.

Poor service. Took over 20 minutes before we were seen by a waiter, and we were seated 15 minutes late after showing up 10 minutes early. Too expensive. Dress code not taken seriously.

Excellent service, food was very good. Enjoyed the evening

Consistently excellent food as always.

I took my son for a celebratory lunch, we both thought it was awesome.

Celebrated our daughter’s successful defense of her PhD dissertation. The staff was so welcoming and helped make the perfect evening. Food and drink was spectacular! What a fun evening! Loved it!

Best fine dining in Pittsburgh.

We were celebrating a birthday and don’t think we would go to the expense in the future to celebrate another occasion. It was pleasant.

Excellent restaurant, excellent service, excellent food. We visited for my wife's birthday and everything was great. Our waitress (Tracy) was the absolute best, very personable, very knowledgeable of the menu, and offered recommendations for wines. The food was excellent although my steak was ever so slightly overdone, it was still delicious. The menu is al a carte and the prices are expensive but you won't be disappointed in the end.

Great service by Armando. Friendly and professional. Food always great.

Unfortunately the 2 of the filet mignons at our table were overcooked. The staff removed the charge which is appreciated but the evening became less special because of that. We will still be back. Because we know this was an exception.

Good special occasion spot. And Great food. Is this enough words yet? Words words words words words. Fifty yet? Omg no. Words words words words words words. Great drinks!

Enjoyed our lunch. Background music was a little high but no big deal. Thanks

This was the first time dining at Eddie Merlot's and the food was absolutely amazing. The only thing we ran into was two of the appetizer plates were dirty when we were first seated. We were told it never happens but my husband and I both had dirty plates. Other than that, they replaced them and as mentioned the food was amazing and the dining experience overall was a great fine dining experience.

From start to finish our experience was exceptional. Our servers Jonathan and John went above and beyond during the entire time we were there. Both were very helpful guiding us through the menu and answering our questions. We enjoyed the conversation with Jonathan as well,as we found out we both knew some of the same people. Spoke with Tom one of the managers as well and again enjoyed our conversation with him. If all of the staff is like these 2 then congratulations

Lovely restaurant, excellent service, quality food.

Wonderful evening. Great staff!

Celebrated our anniversary there and had an amazing night. Wonderful staff and delicious food.

Disappointing. Service was slow and we were not given the attention of a restaurant at this level. We waited for menus, we had to ask for bread, twice. Calamari had raw batter and was flavorless. Steaks were very good, but it seemed as sides sat in a warmer for 30 minutes waiting for steaks. Will not go back.

The decor and service are over the top. They have a varied menu selection which ranges in price and quantity of food. My dinner was delicious, the filet melted in your mouth.

My husband and I recently had dinner at Eddie Merlots and it did not disappoint. The food was excellent, our server Jonathan was exceptional and the overall atmosphere was top notch. I highly recommend.

Gordon and the staff were great, even though Gordon was not informed that we were celebrating my wife's birthday, he still came through.

Ordered three apps all three were poor. Tuna was indelible and how they sent it out with all the strings making it literally inedible made me believe they don’t care at all. Next was crispy sweet and spicy shrimp. It was neither sweet nor spicy and was one big glob of soft shrimp. Last was potstickers. They were ok. Lacking flavor. We decided after the chefs could care less in the food they sent out for the apps that were clearly poor that the meal was over Too bad was looking forward to it and was really poor Service was solid though

I am a well done steak eater. It was done perfectly and still not dry! Get together with business co-worker and we talked for hours and never felt rushed.

Fabulous!!

Great atmosphere. Amazing food and great staff. Choice is menu was nice and prices was great.