Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Pittsburgh

5 star all the way! Atmosphere, Food and Service excellent!

Food and Service were excellent!

Food was absolutely amazing !!

Birthday dinner.

Loud guy next table over disturbed the ambience. Other than that & the COVID barriers the food, staff & cleanliness are 5star.

Exceptional service & exceptional food. The COVID19 protocols in place were excellent, making me feel safe while dining out. Would highly recommend.

I took my husband here for his Birthday and we LOVED it! From the atmosphere, to the food and service! Everything was exceptional, we will be back for sure!!

This was our first time dining at Eddie Merlots and it was incredible! Treyvon was an amazing server and went above and beyond. We ordered the surf and turf and we were blown away. When the shutdown is over we will definitely be back!

Our server was fantastic and he did not rush us at all. The food was fantastic and the drinks were great. The desserts were wonderful as well. Would definitely recommend.

Social distancing and staff mitigation procedures for Covid-19 were in full force. Felt extremely comfortable. Lamb chops were excellent. General Manager actually served part of our meal and insured that everything was satisfactory (as it always is). It is the only indoor dining venue we have patronized throughout the pandemic.

Food was great & service was spectacular! Steaks were perfectly seasoned & the sides were so good. Great wine selections too.

Even with the pandemicgoing on, I felt very comfortable. Tables were spaced out and love the addition of the servers wearing gloves and masks.
Food was excellent and our server was amazing and tentative. Will be back again.

John C. was a fantastic server.
The GM, David and the Exec Chef Jeff were also great when visiting the table.

Great service... even better food!

Great food, atmosphere and service!

Food, service, and atmosphere were impeccable. An excellent night out!

Great food and great service. Trevon provided excellence service.

The atmosphere was great. The food was perfect and my date was the best part!!

Food was average either over cooked (steak) or under cooked (shrimp app). Only redemption was the carrot cake. Second average meal and only reason returned was having a gift card. Unfortunately I will not be returning.

I was deciding between Ditkas and Eddie Merlot’s. Unfortunately Eddies won. It took 3 tries on 2 steaks (bison and filet)and still failed miserably! The lobsters were Luke warm at best and the butter for them , just melted, not hot. If it weren’t for our server Cindy and Tom the amazing manager it would have been a complete fail! Thanks for saving my birthday,Michele and Fred

excellent steak and seafood dishes. The service was excellent

Incredible as always. Food was delicious. Service was impeccable.

Jonathon was an awesome waiter! Food was delicious as well!
We can’t wait to go back next month!

Exceptional food and service. Could not have asked for more. Thank you for an unforgettable evening.

The food was unbelievable. Best steak I’ve ever had. It was our anniversary and the wait staff surprised us with a complimentary dessert and a card signed by the wait staff. Great evening. Felt very safe.

Great food. Best filet I’ve ever had. Service was outstanding.

We've been to Eddie Merlot's a number of times and always had a good experience. Not so much this time. My wife ordered her steak medium well. It came rare. By the time they cooked like it should have been, I was almost finished with mine. No comp offered. Can't wait until the Carleton opens back up.

Everything we ordered tasted amazing. Everyone’s steaks at the table were slightly under cooked than what was ordered so if we went back I was clarify what medium done is for our liking.

So happy to be back..safe environment and my server Jonathan really took care of us. The meal...exquisite!

Consistently excellent dinner! Our favorite place

Excelente food, very good service.
Felt very comfortable with COVID risks it’s a big place with big gaps between tables.
Highly recommended!

Food was very good. Just came to have a quick dinner and it was exactly that. Seemed like
Our server was in training and she did a fine job !

My wife and I were out for a celebration. As part of that celebration, my wife had made a separate request to celebrate my birthday and new job. Unfortunately, the staff ruined the surprise (not once, but twice) by advising us that we were here for a birthday when we checked in and then again when we were seated the hostess stated we were there to celebrate a birthday and new job. My wife informed the hostess it was supposed to be a surprise. She apologized but then even after that, the birthday and new job were not celebrated.
Once we sat down, the service was poor. On numerous occasions, we had to wait long periods of time to order new drinks. My wife ordered a glass of wine with her meal and the server forgot to bring it. He caught his mistake later and brought the drink after dinner. He did apologize and said the glass of wine was on him, which was appreciated. However at that point, we had our share of bad service. My wife and I left disappointed and as a result, we will not be back.

The service was outstanding as was the food this is a fantastic place for an evening out. I would highly recommend it.

Great place! Food , service, ambiance are always excellent!!

We Celebrated our 25th anniversary. The food and cocktails were great and the service was outstanding. Highly recommend.

When talking about the full experience, Merlots has to come to mind! Our service was Mike and he was nothing more than Excellent, truly made us feel special. Allowed you know he loved his job, was attentive to the highest degree. I would go back be request him again. This man deserves to be praised because he doing work that we overlook in our society every day! The food was just incredible from our appetizers, the barbecue shrimp wrapped in bacon to the prime rib streak!! Everyone was awesome!! Great drinks, would highly recommend the Kentucky Mule!!

Amazing, will definitely come back. Our server John was great

Tuna steak was great

Mike in the bar area was amazing! Very knowledgeable, helpful with food and wine. Can’t say enough great things about the service and food. We will absolutely be back