Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Pittsburgh
Valet Parking is available after 6 pm located on Liberty Avenue. Parking validation is available in the Gateway 4 garage after 4 pm on weekdays and 11 am Saturday and Sunday.
We were celebrating a birthday and don’t think we would go to the expense in the future to celebrate another occasion. It was pleasant.
Excellent restaurant, excellent service, excellent food. We visited for my wife's birthday and everything was great. Our waitress (Tracy) was the absolute best, very personable, very knowledgeable of the menu, and offered recommendations for wines. The food was excellent although my steak was ever so slightly overdone, it was still delicious. The menu is al a carte and the prices are expensive but you won't be disappointed in the end.
Unfortunately the 2 of the filet mignons at our table were overcooked. The staff removed the charge which is appreciated but the evening became less special because of that. We will still be back. Because we know this was an exception.
Good special occasion spot. And Great food. Is this enough words yet? Words words words words words. Fifty yet? Omg no. Words words words words words words. Great drinks!
Enjoyed our lunch. Background music was a little high but no big deal. Thanks
This was the first time dining at Eddie Merlot's and the food was absolutely amazing. The only thing we ran into was two of the appetizer plates were dirty when we were first seated. We were told it never happens but my husband and I both had dirty plates. Other than that, they replaced them and as mentioned the food was amazing and the dining experience overall was a great fine dining experience.
From start to finish our experience was exceptional. Our servers Jonathan and John went above and beyond during the entire time we were there. Both were very helpful guiding us through the menu and answering our questions. We enjoyed the conversation with Jonathan as well,as we found out we both knew some of the same people. Spoke with Tom one of the managers as well and again enjoyed our conversation with him. If all of the staff is like these 2 then congratulations
Lovely restaurant, excellent service, quality food.
Wonderful evening. Great staff!
Celebrated our anniversary there and had an amazing night. Wonderful staff and delicious food.
Disappointing. Service was slow and we were not given the attention of a restaurant at this level. We waited for menus, we had to ask for bread, twice. Calamari had raw batter and was flavorless. Steaks were very good, but it seemed as sides sat in a warmer for 30 minutes waiting for steaks. Will not go back.
The decor and service are over the top. They have a varied menu selection which ranges in price and quantity of food. My dinner was delicious, the filet melted in your mouth.
My husband and I recently had dinner at Eddie Merlots and it did not disappoint. The food was excellent, our server Jonathan was exceptional and the overall atmosphere was top notch. I highly recommend.
Gordon and the staff were great, even though Gordon was not informed that we were celebrating my wife's birthday, he still came through.
Ordered three apps all three were poor. Tuna was indelible and how they sent it out with all the strings making it literally inedible made me believe they don’t care at all. Next was crispy sweet and spicy shrimp. It was neither sweet nor spicy and was one big glob of soft shrimp. Last was potstickers. They were ok. Lacking flavor. We decided after the chefs could care less in the food they sent out for the apps that were clearly poor that the meal was over Too bad was looking forward to it and was really poor Service was solid though
I am a well done steak eater. It was done perfectly and still not dry! Get together with business co-worker and we talked for hours and never felt rushed.
Great atmosphere. Amazing food and great staff. Choice is menu was nice and prices was great.
Our experience started out wonderful with our server Bobby who made great recommendations and knew the menu from top to bottom. Every course from appetizers to soup and salad to our entrees and sides and to finish dessert were amazing!!! I personally had the Bone in Filet and it was great along with the Wedge Salad. The atmosphere was very exquisite and we had an enjoyable time celebrating my Mother in Laws birthday. I highly recommend this for a special event or a fun night out you cant go wrong as both the food and service were over the top. Thank You
We enjoyed the meal, but two things:
The hostess tried to seat us at a table near the entrance and server station when there were plenty of great tables available otherwise. Ugh! Why?
We were held hostage waiting to pay the check. Again, ugh!
Had the 30 day aged ribeye. Best steak I ever had. Lobster tail was perfect and we also had filet mignon. Armando was an exceptional server.
First time here and it was fabulous! I had the bison steak and it was fantastic!! O
Great restaurant and wonderful service... would definitely recommend, and definitely will be going back.
Always a go to place for an excellent meal where you can have a great business conversation.
Just went to dinner with a friend. Hadn’t been there for a while due to the death of my husband. It was one of his favorite places. Dinner and service was good.
Not a lot of flavor. I have had much better. seems like steak was cooked earlier then reheated
Kelly was a very professional, knowledgeable waitress.. our dining experience was one we will never forget.. Thank you!
The restaurant is lovely and it is a great lunch place for a special occasion . Beautiful atmosphere and quiet enough to be able to talk with friends . Our waiter would not check in for at least about 20 to 30 minutes . When my food arrived it was cold and completely over done .
None of the steaks we ordered were prepared correctly. Our client that was with us had recently had an organ transplant and required a well done steak for health reasons . His steak and another guest requested well but both came extremely rare . When we sent the steaks back it appeared they were not cooked again or attended too they came back rare and cold again . We tried to find our waiter but he did not return for at least 15 minutes . At their point we were just trading around steaks that were edible for our client . The steaks were good quality but just not prepared properly
Absolutely terrible customer service
The table side dessert was fun and the staff member was engaging
We have dined several times at this location without ever experiencing a problem. This past visit was disappointing due to the steaks being delivered incorrectly and not to the specifications. The main reason for our visit was a birthday celebration and that person had to wait the longest for their meal to be delivered. Once the new steak was served it tasted like it was char broiled. Definitely different than the other steaks on the table. The manager took the 2 wrong steaks off of the bill to make it right with us. That was appreciated, however it was not how we imagined our food experience to be. In addition, the creamed spinach was inedible due to the amount of salt it was made with. We were also not thrilled with the use of cumin on the candied walnuts for our dessert. I have never written a comment before, but thought it was worth mentioning. This review reads like there is an emotional investment because we do take dining out seriously and save up money to do so, especially for a special occasion. It will be a while if we ever decide to go back to Eddie Merlot's Pittsburgh.
Great dinner as always.
My daughter and I were running late due to a business meeting, and technically got there when the kitchen would ordinarily be closing. It was my daughter’s birthday. Armando who waited on us was simply fantastic. He made us feel like the time was no problem at all, didn’t rush us and made us feel very welcome throughout our dinner. He is a credit to Eddie Merlot’s.
The filet mignon and the bison filet were excellent. We found our new favorite steak restaurant. The creme brûlée was the best in memory. The atmosphere was elegantly tasteful.
We plan to return.
Excellent service from Gordon. Food never disappoints! Love it here.
Amazing dinner, the food was perfectly cooked and the steak melted in your mouth! Was a perfect experience and can’t wait to come back!
As always the service was great and food was even better!
It was a night out with my wife for our anniversary 23 years!!
Food was good but we were not impressed by the steak. It was prepared medium which we ordered and that was fine.
Our steak was cold along with our baked potato.
Probably wouldn’t return because we like our steak searing hot when it comes out to the table.
Best NY steak with peppercorn sauce I have had - and I have eaten a lot of NY steaks in my time. Amazing flavor and great service. Wine recommendation was on point as well.
I have been expanding my pallet and this experience pushed my taste buds to a new level. The preparation of the fried oysters were second to none. The way the pickled cucumber and onion balanced the brininess of the oysters created the perfect balanced bite.
Took my hubby there for a date . We have never been there before and thought we would try it out. Spinach salad had limp spinach and stems. Looks like they just opened a bag and dumped it on the plate. I complained and they brought me a newer salad. I asked for anything other than mashed potatoes with my meal and they served mashed potatoes and didn't ever notice. I didn't complain just didn't eat them. Coffee was served with whipped cream in one dish and another beneath it with chocolate chips however I wasn't aware that is what they were and didn't explore the dish until I was three cups in. Would have been nice if the server would have told me or unstacked the souffle cups. I thought it was sugar. Other than that the food was good. Steaks were perfectly prepared.. Carrot cake was really good too. The waitress gave us a piece to take home. We never saw a manager
Gordon was very attentive and knew the menu and cuts of meat perfectly! Our filet was fabulous and Ceasar Salad was awesome! We shared a meal and were not the bit hungry after our meal!
Kudos to the bartender also for the perfect very dry vodka martini!
My main complaint at Eddie Merlot's is that they bring the second course before we have finished the first. There is no excuse for this.