Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Indianapolis
Book your next event with us
Many restaurants have great food, but put that together with very friendly and personable servers and management and low noise level (really, we could hear each other) , and reasonable prices, and you have a winner named Eddie Merlot!!! We truly enjoyed the evening!!!
A very nice dinning experience..everytime! Atmosphere was nice with what seemed to be good people; guest and staff. Dan, the GM, was great with introducing himself and following thru with a minor concerned I had. It all worked out. See you again soon.
Eddie’s is a favorite special occasion restaurant. The food and service is always good. This time everything seemed extra special. Our server was training a new server and he did a great job. I’m confident the service would have still been great even If he had been on his own!
10th Anniversary. Lindsey was our server and she was awesome! Can’t wait to go back for my birthday celebration.
My wife and I had a wonderful experience. The atmosphere is very nice and inviting. Staff was tremendous. There were a couple of groups there that made it a bit load as they had to talk over each other. Food is always spectacular. We certainly recommend it for an anniversary.
Thank you Alicia, for making our Anniversary dinner truly special.
It is a very nice atmosphere. Staff seemed good. But overall, I think the food is better at Flemings's.
The best food and service around.
Steak was common, my Daughters was fine and my wife’s king crab was just OK The service was fine the drinks were fine just the food could’ve been a little better
We take friends to Eddie Merlot’s regularly. We wouldn’t do that unless we were confident that they would have a great experience.
Food was uninspiring at best. The crablegs were small, stringy and impossible to crack open. At this price, they should be pre-split and full of meat.
Steak was ok.
Good food and service. I always enjoy myself when I go to Eddie’s. The only thing that I didn’t like was their old fashion which is hard to make correctly. Everything else was on point.
Excellent meal with superb service. Even got a special dessert for our anniversary.
Kim was exceptional!
The halibut was very dry. I would not order this again. The server was outstanding, but she did recommend the halibut over the salmon. The ambiance is superb and the amenities could not be better.
The valet and waitress was great but I noticed that the manager visited everyone’s table and asked how was the meal accept ours, we were a table of 8 African Americans. When leaving the waitress and valet were the only people who asked us again about our experience and stated come again even tough the manager was behind the desk when we were leaving out. Pretty interesting.
This was our 51st anniversary and the place, people and food was awesome which made the evening perfect. My husband has been very sick and his diet has changed but the food portion were just the right amount since we could share the side dishes. Our host explained everything and she never knew of my husband condition she was so nice and a blessing.
Thank You Jenny Mixon
Celebrated my birthday and the staff and management went above and beyond to make my day special. Thank you.
Our server, Thomas, was excellent!
Food was great as always!!
Great food and service. Just looking around the room, you knew you were going to get what you wanted and expected.
Exceptional service and hospitality! The GM, waiter, and bartender made us feel at home.
Very nice evening
Excellent service staff and manager checked on our experience a couple of times, A++
Excellent meal. Excellent service. Loved the Devour Indy menu.
Celebrated my wife's birthday. Everything was great about the experience. Our server, Alicia, took care of all our requests and was very attentive without hovering over us. Would recommend without reservation.
Kim is an amazing server! Her recommendations were spot on! When we come back we will definitely request her.
Service was slow and confusing. Soup was brought out 1st, than appetizers, than bread than meal. Server told us dessert was on him even though dessert was part of meal selection. Appetizer and soup delicious. Main entree was mediocre.
All the food was excellent. The Devour Indy menu was great. We added peppercorn sauce to the filet mignon, which made it incredible. The cedar plank salmon with a barbecue glaze was also incredible.
Best choice of steaks in Indianapolis. Where else can you find Wagyu steak in Indiana that’s not a special.
Very nice birthday dinner with my family! Enjoyed drinks, apps, dinner and wonderful carrot cake!
Awesome as always. Steaks were delicious and so tender!
Very accommodating staff
Excellent experience. Eddie, the store manager was very accommodating.
Fantastic was usual. Our waiter Thomas was stroller. Always a great experience at Eddie Merlot's.
We normally eat downtown at the steak houses, we decided to try something new. The place was nice, server was nice, appetizers were good, salads were good. Our steaks on the other hand were bland, I ordered mine medium and my husband the same, our friend ordered his medium rare. My husband and I got served a medium rare steak we sent it back and had it cooked longer the manager brings it out I decided to keep mine, my husband had to send it back because it looked the same as the first time it came out but when he cut into it again he said it’s still not done enough, the manager asked “how do you want the inside to look”? They took the steak back and when it came back it was more medium well one side of the steak was brown and the other side pink which means the steak was not evenly cooked or the warm pink center would’ve been there not a slightly pink side and a brown side. The manager did give us free desert to try to make up for it.
Had the crab dinner not very good. The way it was plated was very poor and unappetizing.
I really enjoyed the ambiance. My food was okay. It was not as hot as I would have liked but overall okay. I will attempt another time and give it a shot as it could have been simply my food selection.
Food and wine were perfect! And the service was exceptional. Would highly recommend!
Consistently outstanding food. The crab cake appetizer is amazing. The wine selection is too notch. Prime steaks, Wagyu, and bison all available. Melt in your mouth sea bass, and perfectly cooked steaks is the norm. Don't leave without tasting the unbelievable carrot cake!
Eddie Merlot's is my favorite restaurant! The food is excellent! Our server, Kim, is one of the best ever. I highly recommend this restaurant!