Amazing food and amazing atmosphere. The decor really impressed me, no uncomfortable wooden chairs in sight. Staff were very helpful with suggestions and there was always somebody nearby to help you if you need anything. Would love to come here again.

Excellent!!!

Our group of 4 were totally impressed with Earl's last evening. The decor the furniture, the service, reasonable pricing of both drinks & menu! It is sad though that it was our first time @ Earl's & now they are faced with a covis shutdown. Hopefully its short & we will return to Earl's.

Love their food. Will definitely recommend and visit again.

Always consistent, always delicious, always great service. I’ve been going to Earls since they only had one location in Edmonton when I was 6 years old and it never disappoints. There’s a great variety of dishes and they’ve changed their menu over the years to keep up with the times but still have stayed true to their roots. So glad to have locations in Ontario.

Very fast and polite service. We enjoyed. Great food to top it off.

Overall all was good for us. The food was nice but not a very wide selection

Steak was warm at best they forgot my wife’s truffle butter

Excellent food and service. Lots of selection. Fast service.

The hostess at the door was rude and unpleasant to talk to.

This new location has it all. Great variety on the menu and quality in every choice you make. Service is fantastic. Timely and helpful. The dividers between the tables don't make you feel confined but deliver the safety we all need...helps keep the noise between tables down too

Our server, Nicolina... amazing server with an amazing name.

Nice not rushed . Food pretty good as well

Mask not being worn when people leaving or going to
Washroom

Our evening at Earl's Sherway Gardens was wonderful. My husband and I were celebrating our 26th wedding anniversary. Eating at Earl's is our tradition as we know we will get good value and service there. I had made a couple of requests beforehand and each one was executed perfectly. Our server, Andrea, was delightful and efficient. Our appetizer was a crab cake. It was delicious. We each ordered the filet mignon and it was cooked to perfection. We plan to return again soon.

Such an amazing experience. Wonderful food and amazing service. My wife has an allergy and the manager came out straight away to let us know that the food she wanted was safe. Would absolutely recommend Earls Sherway to everyone.

The service was too slow. Took too long bringing drinks & food. When we got our food it took the waiter 20 mins to bring our cutlery, which by then our food got cold. Waiting for the bill took another 30 mins

Awesome loved it

We loved our experience overall our server was amazing but the welcoming host was definitely having a bad day and tried to take it out on us twice while I avoided that plus be super nice to her. I just wanted to enjoy our Sunday dinner and we did.
Thank you

This was my fifth time to Earls Sherway, what made this dinning visit more special is two staff members that earned my respect. Richie, is an amazing host, he cares for his customers and her serves you with a smile and respect. He is attentive, friendly, quick and does multitasks.... I feel that the atmosphere is always pleasant and service is on point and above. This was my Third time dealing with Richie, and i may not have the words to describe my thanks to him, but I nominate him for one of best servers and staff at Earls Sherway. I really enjoy seeing him and being served by him.
To add to this enjoyable day that we had, to the second time I met Ariel, She is polite, pleasant and accommodating, she cares for the customer and does try best to make anyone feel comfortable and welcomed.
What did amaze me, that both of them worked well together and they both multitask, yet to ensure that all customers are served in a timely manner and with happy smile.
The food was good as usual and the atmosphere was excellent. just to clarify, our visit was on Friday Dec 24th.
Thank you Ariel and Richie.

It was amazing dinning at Earl's for our annual family holiday dinner.
Our server Kevin was kind, polite professional and neatly dressed.

Food was good. Service was excellent

Great spot! Great service, great food- did not disappoint. Will be coming back here lots.

Nice environment, good service, and good food. Earl's was a good choice for a staff dinner before Christmas.

Great service, quick check in process with reservation; seated almost immediately upon entry. Server arrived quickly to our table and took our drink order. Great menu options, sometimes there are just too many choices….but that’s a good thing. Server mixed up my order( brought me a poke bowl instead of the Earth bowl) but it was quickly rectified and I was credited for the mix up. Overall great venue for party of 3.

Great service, great food. Reminded me of being out west where hospitality is still present.

The waitress did not enter one of the orders from our table. Two people got their food and the other person had to wait another 25-30 minutes to get their lunch. The manager did apologize and took the charge off the bill for that meal, which was good. But the waitress never apologized and avoided coming to our table.

Food was mediocre. Service was okay. Server messed up our bill 3 times.

So it was date night for me and hubby in a long time. I thought Earls would be nice since I’ve attended the Square One location and the food was good. Well Sherway was awful.

1- our seat was close to where all the cashiers go(which is not a problem) but they would gather there talking to each other. It gave me and hubby no privacy as they were just inches away from us. They could overhear our conversation so we would just stop talking when they gathered again.

2- the food was soooooo salty. No taste except salty. The drinks was nice but that’s about it. $200 gone for a failed date night.

While sitting at the table I could see Joey cross the street. I was wishing we were there instead. I will not be going here again.

I love coming to Earl’s for their happy hour, the food and drinks are priced so well. This was my first time at the Sherway location and I was no disappointed. Our servers were great.

It was my second time visiting this restaurant and we extremely happy with the food and service, we will definitely be coming back

We were treated royally by all staff- and there were lots of staff on hand! Our salads were excellent, wait staff were attentive and we were not rushed.

Everything was amazing! The service was great, even through the lunch rush. It was my friends first time to Earls and I made them a believer! One of my favourite chain restaurants of all time and this new location doesn't disappoint!

My overall experience at Earl's was fantastic: the food, service and ambience were excellent - would highly recommend Earl's Sherway!

A Reunion after a couple of years! Ambiance lovely, associates so friendly and efficient and food was delicious…wine a little expensive!!!

Good experience. A bit pricey for items but food was good. Service was great.

4 Ladies went for lunch. We sat in a high booth👍🏼We had excellent food and great service very nice decor bright big windows

We found the service a little slow. We waited for a while before someone took our drink order. The staff was very friendly.

As always it is super busy on Sunday afternoons due to their great happy hour. Food was excellent as always and the winter sangria is delicious. Service was somewhat uneven due to our server being more interested in chatting with her friends at the bar than serving her section but when a management type stepped in, things quickly returned to the usual level of good service.

The food was not good compared to the last time I was there.

I was there for dinner with three other friends last Saturday. Two of us ordered the blackened chicken and we both found it not flavourful. We both agreed that the food felt rushed as the whole place was busy and they weren't taking any more reservations. We felt the food wasn't seasoned enough. The jerk was just poured on it. My other two friends ordered the salmon. They said it was good albeit a tad salty. We also ordered 4 drinks called Moscow Mule which weren't enjoyable either. We had them taken back and not billed to our invoices. Disappointing dinner for the price we paid for each meal. I have always had a good experience dining at Earls but not this time. I would still recommend the restaurant to my friends and family. They just have to do better.