Croton Reservoir Tavern
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Proof of vaccination required to dine indoors
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sat 11:30AM - 2:00PM 2:15PM - 8:45PM
Repas délicieux! Meilleur fish and chips ever!! Je recommande fortement!
Terrible. Couldn’t accommodate our reservation. When they did bring us a table set up from the back (literally) the waiter said he would do his best to try to find water glasses. The place was completely overrun and clearly had no help. We ended up leaving before our drinks ever came. Disappointing.
Unfortunately the night we went, they only had 3 people in the kitchen so, although we ordered pretty quickly after being sat, our food still hadn't come out after an hour and 30 minutes. After we asked our poor server who was trying her best, she said they hadn't even started it. We ended up cancelling our order and leaving hungry.
They put us outside, inside looked good. Wait staff is hurting, manager said 3 of 75 ppl came back. Felt for the staff but service was pretty bad.
Amazing and attentive server. Cocktails and food were delicious. Will come back, definitely for our annual holiday trip next year.
Waited 2 hours for our meal and the burgers were still undercooked. To make up for it they comped an ice tea. Several other tables had a similar experience and when they complained the manager became agitated
Service was slow in the beginning, yet the server was apologetic and kind. Food was yummy, yet unexpectedly pricey.
It's a nice enough pub. Service was good considering it was packed solid. I really didn't like having to climb up to get to the banquet. Steak sandwich was very good - but the fries were disgusting. Totally inedible. Somehow the main floor bathroom got locked and I had to ask five waitstaff to get it unlocked as I have knee problems and couldn't do the stairs to the downstairs rest rooms. And $14 for an Irish Coffee is just crazy.
The food and service were outstanding. Very cute NYC restaurant.
Casual business meeting. Space was very accommodating and service was excellent. Although a limited lunch menu, the selections were very good.
The macaroni and cheese was delicious. We wanted outside but it wasn’t heated so we came in. It wasn’t jammed but still quite noisy. I’d go back.
Thanksgiving flavors were good but the food could have been served hotter. The wait staff was attentive and friendly. The table was right by a draught which was unfortunate for this time of year.
Very average in all ways. I had the steak sandwich which I really did not love. My dining partner had the pork chops which were much much better… And the bang bang cauliflower was very good… I wouldn’t rush to come back here as I found it very average in all ways . This place will do in a pinch but don’t rush to get there
We had to wait 30 mins to be seated, so I don’t feel like te reservation was honored. Food and drinks were great, and staff friendly, but the wait for the table defeats the purpose of making a reservation jn the first place, and impact the experience.
The entrance door handle was broken the day we walked in. The bathrooms need renovation.
But I must say that the food is very good and they have very good service. The handhelds were good, and yummy fries.
wonderfull staff and great bartenders. Food was very good and was out fast. we were attending an event at MSG and it worked out perfect
The food came out quick and the service was outstanding. Will be back again.
Thanks for the feedback and positive review! Looking forward to hosting you again!
Food and staff always great. Would have preferred the music to be a little lower.
Were happy to hear you enjoyed our food and service! Thanks for the positive review.
It was the perfect ambience that I was looking for. Not too expensive, but nice tables and lighting. The service was excellent.
Wonderful chicken sandwich. Wonderful French fries. Ambiance was corporate cocktail hour- two teams seemed to be
Ate outside. Great food. Wonderful service.
The service was excellent! Beautiful bar. We had a Pulsd deal, and it was handled super smoothly. Great night! French dip was tasty!
Our family of six met for lunch in the outdoor space. The Bridge & Tunnel tots were a major hit. Menu needs a few more gluten free options.
Exactly what we were looking for, relaxing place, not stuffy, good food, pre theater
The courtyard is amazing for outdoor dining and when we went on the early side, we had it to ourselves. Portions remain amazing and despite being out of sight due to being outdoors, service was A+ I think the happy hour menu is expanded? Or new to me, but a great range of options
Seated promptly outside. Host was attentive ... he saw my note that we wanted to sit outside but iphone Opentable wouldn't let me do it. Waited quite a while for our food. Shishito peppers were too salty and cold, french fries were cold, mussels were tasty, but too many onions. Not sure if we would go back.
Both the manager and our server were first rate. They were friendly and welcoming. The food was much tastier than the word "tavern" might suggest. I'd love to go back!
It was such a nice time for a casual after work gathering!
It was super noisy, and the table is weirdly wide, so I was far apart from my companion and we couldn't really hear each other. The food was okay - too salty though. I appreciated the references to Croton reservoir history.
Great service. Drinks and Food were great.
Wonderful experience, would recommend it to New Yorkers or visitors
Nice place. Attentive but not pushy staff. Drinks were very good. House sangria was excellent. Shishido peppers - yummy. Salads were large and filling. Large enough and spaced out so it felt very safe - not right on top of each other. Nice beer selection.
Our waiter was great and efficient. He let us move away from the noisy happy hour group who were at the bar. The food and drinks were delivered in a timely fashion and at the right temperature.
the staff is wonderful and super accommodating. the food is very nice Pub style, great wings and cold beer as well as some very nice craft cocktails.
Came with my boss and CEO, service was FANTASTIC and my mahi Mahi sandwich was amazing
Always great for a well crafted cocktail
It has good food, good services and very clean. The staff is super friendly and take care of you. I highly recommend
We received an excellent service
Hostess was very kind and helpful
Croton Reservoir Tavern offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 997-6835.
Croton Reservoir Tavern is rated 4.4 stars by 911 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.