- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
onions, radishes, cilantro (to share)
We went for our anniversary. The food is incredible but.... there were too many cooks in the kitchen so to speak. The staff is large and does not seem to communicate very well. It felt like our server changed with each course. We will be back but not with the pre fix menu.
Outstanding menu, delicious
Cosme is one of my favorite restaurants in NYC. They do an incredible job making you feel like a million bucks. We sat right away as soon as we checked in. I miss their bar, but there’s nothing we can do about that at the moment.
This time at Cosme they offered a 4 course pre fixe menu. About 4-5 options per course were available. The menu was broken down to a seafood, vegetable, entree, and dessert course. I had an order of guacamole and the “uni infladita” which was a nice 2/3 bite start to dinner. The “forest mushrooms and grits with truffle” which was creamy and incredible. The short rib entree which was very filling, beautifully presented, and full of flavor. For dessert I had the hazelnut and pear option which was a great unique combination.
Service was 10/10! I was supplied with a steady stream of cocktails, the entire staff is incredibly friendly, and they politely police guests to wear their face masks. Our server was cool and sincerely thanked us for the gratuity we left. We will be back!
Great food & service.
The (Mexican) music was very loud and we had trouble having a conversation. Please lower the volume.
Incredible Mexican cuisine with a pleasurable presentation.
Cosme nailed indoor dining during covid. The tables are well spaced apart, with every other two-top blocked so there is space. But it still somehow felt lively and normal.
Did dinner and the wine pairing and thought the food was absolutely fantastic. The red shishito and dungeoness crab appetizer was great, the heirloom grits were also delicious and the tamarind lamb breast is one of the best things I’ve eaten in a very long time. The only thing I didn’t love was the membrillo con queso which was way too heavy. With that said, we were there for an anniversary and the staff brought a dessert on the house that involved merengue which was one of the best desserts I’ve ever had.
The pairings were also spot to on. All in all great service, great experience and a picture of how indoor dining and be done right.
Delicious. Wish they had more gluten free options
Top! Great Sea Bass
Really good place for dinner: good wine, service and food.
This place is supposed to be good? No wonder they don’t put their prices on the online menu. Cosme is a glorified Taco Bell Cantina
Es un excelente lugar, una excelente selección de platillos, aunque las entradas son muy pequeñas, sin embargo los postres son sobresalientes.
Los cócteles muy buenos, con nombres muy ingeniosos que hacen honor al folclor mexicano.
Amazing food in a good atmosphere
Food outstanding but very slow to get our drink from the bar.
Found this place to be more trendy and a bit pretentious rather than great food and ambiance. Service was the best part but we found the experience underwhelming. Disappointed. Won’t be returning. (Tables for two are too long to even talk give the the noise level)
Went to Cosme years ago and wasn't thrilled. Went back for a recent brunch because the restaurant keeps appearing on critics' "best" lists. Surprise -- brunch was excellent. Background music was much too loud for quiet conversation, but my wife and I will try Cosme again for dinner someday. Maybe it will redeem itself.
Service was very slow this time. Like crazy slow.
I was blown away by Cosme honestly. I thought I was going to a high end fru fru where the servings meant I was going to grab a burger before heading home not.The total opposite happened and I loved everything from the appetizers to the main course. I cannot give a bigger recommendation than that.
Price points weren’t bad either. Will be coming back for sure.
Amazing food. Perfect for special occasions. Truly elevated Mexican cuisine!
Fantastic all around. The food was phenomenal, service spectacular and ambiance was special. Will definitely go back.
Great food, original small dishes, pricey. A bit noisy.
Food was meh for the price. Didn’t charge us for the pork we thought was just fat. Didn’t make up for the time wasted and had to go find another restaurant to actually have dinner. Couldn’t pay me to eat here again
I didn’t like the Paloma coctel it was poorly made
Great experience , unique food , world class . Will be back for sure.
Wonderful Mexican modern food.
Was amazing !!Great food and ambient !!
El lugar es muy bonito. La atención fue muy buena. La comida estuvo bueno, pero es demasiado costoso.
The food portions were small, not tasty, and definitely not worth the price (which was high). We had to go get food elsewhere after we left.
We went there for brunch with some friends and everything was delicious! They gave us a small cake as a an anniversary gift! Amazing service!
Friends in town
Decayó tremendamente. Fuimos cuando recién abrió y fue increíble. Hoy desde el ambiente hasta el menú perdieron esencia y puntos fuertes. Una lástima.
La mejor cena que he tenido,
Exquisitos sabores en cada platillo.
Una delicia cada cosa en la porción adecuada.
Waitress got 2 of the 4 items in our order all mixed up. First, she brought me a wrong appetizer I never ordered. When we told her that wasn’t ours, she agreed and said “keep it, I’ll bring your Arctic Char dish. Then my entree was missing the main ingredient, chicken, when I brought this up to a different server because our original waitress was busy, he walked away to ascertain, came back and said I ordered it without chicken, which is ridiculous. When I insisted that I wouldn’t order a chicken dish and ask for the chicken to be left out, he told someone who I guess was the manager, who then didn’t come to our table first to explain what he was doing, but went to the kitchen and came back later with a small bowl full of shredded chicken and set it in the table and said “I gave you extra” I guess he expected me to assemble the dish myself at my table. I don’t understand why he didn’t just take the dish away and have the chef prepare it again or add the chicken. I guess I paid to prepare my own food.
Extremely overpriced. Enjoyed it time there but not sure I am going back there.
Tiny plates of food, and no real flavor? So expensive and a let down!
The waitstaff was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and how much our group should order since we were looking to share a bunch of dishes. All of the recommendations came without hesitation and spanned the breadth of the menu. The food and drinks were excellent - do not skip the duck carnitas! - and I cannot wait to go back
Overrated, overpriced, tiny portions. You couldn’t fill my margarita glass more than halfway? In 40 years of dining in NYC... Cosme was the single worst experience. Complete rip-off!!! There’s no way this place survives.
Not enough options or diversity in the menu.
Food and service were top notch!
I have been to Cosme several times. I had a booking for last evening for at 8:30pm and was hosting clients. I was running late and tried to call the restaurant to alert them to the delay. I called 4 times but one one ever answered the phone. When we finally arrived it was just at over the 15 minute grace period that the hostess was so readily to say was their seating policy. I advised that I attempted to call to alert them of the delay and pointed to the phone that was on the podium. I asked, was there any reason why no one was answering the phone or if their phones were not working. I just received a shrug and a reply of 'I don't know'. We were told we would have to wait 30 minutes for a table to open up. We decided to wait at the bar. We had 2 rounds of drinks and the manager came over to say it would still be longer but would not give a specific time. We waited close to an hour before we were sat. Whilst we were offered a round of drinks and seats at the communal table, I declined. Being in the hospitality industry I have to say that Cosme has lots to work on in terms of customer service and training their staff. If I were Enrique Olvera, I would be very concerned to have my name attached to a place that pales in comparison to delivering a great experience like Pujol does. Once we sat, the food was amazing as always and the service fine. I am going think twice to recommending this restaurant to anyone.
Cosme is rated 4.4 stars by 2944 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.