Cold Storage Seafood
Had a reservation for 7:45 and my table was not ready until 8:10 so my date and I sat at the bar and ate.
Entrees took about 30 to 40 minutes to come out. A person ordered a to go order next to us about 8 minutes after we ordered and they got their orders before us.
The bar tenders gave us a free shot to make up for the long wait time for the food which was really cool! :-)
Completely underwhelmed. Went for our anniversary. The server barely spoke to us. Never made any recommendations. Ordered the crab knuckles. Taste was there, value was not. Smallest portion of fries ever.
My boyfriend and I loved Cold Storage. The $1 oysters were fresh and delicious, the Japanese pancakes were fluffy and flavorful, and my crab omelet was the best omelet I've ever eaten. I would go back every weekend for brunch if I could.
Great service but the food was subpar. Not what I was expecting.
Perfect spot for a late lunch on a Sunday :) our server Kelly was great and answered all of our questions in detail. We got the whitefish dip, salmon belly, poke, whitefish sandwich, half a dozen oysters ($1 each for their Sunday happy hour!), and the scallop ceviche. Everything was wonderful - I probably wouldn’t order the ceviche again, just because it was creamier than I was expecting and not as light and refreshing. It sort of seemed like a variation of the whitefish dip. We still ate it though!
Food was below average and the mussels came from a box.
Great food and superb service. $$$$$
We enjoyed ourselves immensely, great food, service and ambiance. Thank you!
Came in for oysters, apps, and desserts. I believe the oysters here are a bit expensive compared to the other locations in West Loop, where here they offer them by an oyster, which can add up very quickly (Swift & Sons had them at better pricing). Regadless it was great that they offered about 8 different types of oysters to choose from. The calamari was little lacking in flavor, so we squeezed a bunch of lemon on top. They dont have afterdinner cocktails neither, it was only available in Swift & Sons. Being that said we were better off at Swift & Sons. Our server was very attentive and pleasant, gave us the time we needed and space too.
Best fish and chips in Chicago? Probably. Better than most I’ve tried in the UK.
Overpriced and not that great. I love sea food but would not go back again to this place. Spent $140 and left hungry and underwhelmed by food
Very fast lunch service which was great as time was limited. Food was delicious.
Pleasantly surprise by this diamond among the other restaurants in the Fulton District! Very fresh seafood, with a lot of variety from oysters and clams to sardines and the chef's special of Halibut. The Salmon Poke bowl was a hit as well as the fish and chips! I am personally glad that the other four restaurants we considered didn't have a table for five at 5:15 pm on a Saturday, as we would have overlooked this gem of restaurant!!! I look forward to stopping by on my way home one night soon for Happy Hour!!
Came for oysters happy hour and had a great time! Ended up ordering a lot more food and loved every bite.
Sad to say this will be my last time at Cold Storage. This place has been a go to for Monday lunches for me and my husband, maybe 10-12 visits total? Last visit we were not in love with the new menu changes and tonight was a worse experience. We waited 15 mins to be acknowledged by our server, and another 15 mins for drinks. Dollar oysters were all bad. My co worker and I ordered Six and we only ate 2. No one made a mention when they were cleared. We tried to order more oysters from their menu but they were out of several of the selections. The other favorite I have always order (fresh fish prepared a la pancha) was sold down to 1 fish option only. This all happened at 5:30 at night. We were so disappointed by our experience we went to Swift and Sons for dinner. It was a better experience.
Menu was pretty meh.
Had dinner in Cold Storage and the server and management was outstanding. There was an issue with a few folks sitting next to us that were making a scene, so much so I had to ask to be moved. When we were moving these people made incredibly rude comments to us. The management moved us to a nice booth in their fine dining restaurant and made our experience wonderful. Thanks team it was awesome.
We loved the food, the ambiance and especially our server.
Wife and I stopped in for dinner before a show at the UC. Food and service were fantastic. Be ready to open up your wallet though. All in all I highly recommend.
Great for a romantic late night, could get a booth with well behaved kids, and a great spot to mingle with your besties over delicious cocktails, and sweet and briny seafood towers!
Loved having a lil late night valentines dinner here with my partner.
We ordered the John Hancock seafood tower for 2 and a couple other dishes. The seafood was fresh and the food tasted good but the tower didn’t come with clams as the menu said it would. Our server didn’t mention anything about being out of clams so I assumed we had everything. I realized after our meal that we were missing a key item. The food was good but can’t help feeling gypped.
Food was below average at best, not impressed with the quality whatsoever.
The food was awful. The fish was virtually uncooked.
We dined during restaurant week and overall in terms of food & service we had a lovely experience. However, I have to mention that we were all a bit shocked by the fact that they do not offer free refills on iced tea and on top of that, each tea was $3.50. I have worked in the food industry for a very long time, and I personally think this was a bit much, when iced tea (like soda) cost next to nothing to have on hand and pour. Secondly, the stools in the bar were the most uncomfortable stools I have ever sat in. The bars for your feet were either too low or too high to use comfortably, and by the end of the meal your butt hurt so bad you couldn't wait to get up and leave.
Came here for Restaurant Week lunch...was easily the best meal we had all week! Food was incredibly fresh and everything was absolutely delicious!
I enjoyed the food and ambience was nice. I would have gave the food more stars if the desert was a bit more unique. It's kind of weird to go from rocking seafood to a cookie ice cream sandwich. Mimosa was strong and boozy...liked it! As far as staff, very welcoming @ the door. No place to sit while I wait for a table?? The waiters' runner was the hardest working person there. I would have given him the entire tip. Waiter barely looked in our direction. What a shame...I won't return.
Everything was perfect! We came for lunch during restaurant week and everything was very prompt and delicious. It was a great deal, the 3 courses were each outstanding, and we left full and happy.
This place was awesome! The food was delish, very fresh. Presentation was spot on and the service was great!
Great menu and you can even order off Swift and Son's menu too.
Freshest Seafood in Chicago, Oyster selection always on point, fun casual atmosphere
It was great! A little pricey for the catch of the day.
Stopped here for Restaurant Week, and was not disappointed. Lunch was $24 & worth way more than I paid! Highly recommended!
Great cocktails and seafood options. Friendly staff. Less formal than Swift & Sons - great alternative and can eat off the Swift menu
Third visit — we love the Tins! Great wine (Sancerre), oysters and tins. One of our favorite spots in Chicago if you are a seafood lover!
Amazing seafood selections and great service. Highly recommend!
Fabulously fresh food, great service (thank you, Oscar), and a casual comfortable setting. We had oysters on the half shell, scallop ceviche that was outstanding, and salmon collar-very different for us but again, delicious.
Very small space, only 3 booths everything else are high top tables with backless stools. No place to put you coa on these backless stools. The mussels on the website and what was on the menu had two different descriptions. It was a highly recommended item that was not very good.
Food and service were outstanding!!
Great food and service!