Carnegie Diner & Café – 828 8th Ave, New York, NY

Bewertungen für Carnegie Diner & Café – 828 8th Ave, New York, NY von Gästen, die dieses Restaurant besucht haben. Basierend auf den neusten Bewertungen.

1. E

   Edward VIP

   Raum New York19 Bewertungen

   3.0

   Vor 1 Tag besucht

   1. Gesamt 3
   2. Essen 3
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 3

   To me, one of the signs of a good restaurant is if they honor your reservation. We reserved a booth for a 6:00 PM reservation. It was a cold and rainy night and due to a knee injury, I needed to use a cane. When we arrived we were cold, wet and exhausted. To 2 seniors, finally reaching our destination was like winning the lottery. Unfortunately, there was no booth available but they offered us a table nearest the front door. The host said we could wait for a booth but we needed to sit, so we took the table. Unfortunately, because we were near the front door, all the people waiting for tables were standing on top of us. It was not very comfortable. The waitress was very pleasant and sweet. The Greek salad was excellent but the spinach pie was cold. I realize that this is a diner but if you are going to operate a restaurant and accept reservations and the day before,reconfirm the reservation, honor them.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

2. M

   Marie

   Glasgow3 Bewertungen

   3.0

   Vor 3 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 3
   2. Essen 4
   3. Service 2
   4. Ambiente 3

   Mixed experience. No cutlery when food served. No drinks order taken. Food orders came out wrong twice. Hard to get waiters attention despite management being on the floor at the entrance. Food was very good when arrived. Portions size big!
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

3. C

   Cecilia VIP

   Raum New York50 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Vor 3 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 3

   Excellent service and food. Great for a quick meal before or after a show. Our waiter was so lovely. Prices are great compared to other places and there was even a happy hour. Will definitely go back.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

4. K

   Karen VIP

   Raum New York8 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Vor 3 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   Great place to eat pre-theater. Food was good and service was great.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

5. R

   Ronald VIP

   Raum New York34 Bewertungen

   4.0

   Vor 3 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 4
   2. Essen 4
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 3

   A good, solid casual choice for pre-theatre dining. Enormous portions.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

6. N

   Natalie VIP

   Miami100 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Vor 5 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   So many menu options! Fun atmosphere with a really big space and great service.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

7. K

   Kelli VIP

   Philadelphia22 Bewertungen

   1.0

   Vor 7 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 1
   2. Essen 2
   3. Service 1
   4. Ambiente 1

   our waitress just couldn’t be bothered to take care of us. I had to order a coke zero 4 times because she kept forgetting. Then when she finally brought it, she gave me diet coke and didn’t even say because they don’t have coke zero! I don’t drink diet so it would have been nice of her to mention it wasn’t coke zero. When the check came she charged us for items we didn’t even order. So many options in NYC, you can skip this one!!
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

8. O

   Onnalee

   Minneapolis2 Bewertungen

   4.0

   Vor 7 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 4
   2. Essen 4
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 4

   Service and food were great! Ordered dessert to go! Tiramisu was incredible!!
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

9. L

   Lawrence

   Omaha1 Bewertung

   5.0

   Vor 7 Tagen besucht

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   Awesome place! Good food. Good service. New York all the way
   

   • 

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

10. L

    Lisa VIP

    Raum New York149 Bewertungen

    5.0

    Besucht am 2. Mai 2025

    1. Gesamt 5
    2. Essen 5
    3. Service 5
    4. Ambiente 4

    Classic NYC diner in a very convenient location. Staff is terrific and friendly. Food is fresh and delicious. A fun place to dine.
    

    War diese Bewertung hilfreich?