Carmine's- Atlantis Paradise Island
Resort guests can enjoy the lively atmosphere, family-style dining experience, and classic Italian cuisine of Atlantis Paradise Island’s recreation of this ever-popular New York institution. Select from an array of fine Italian wines, including a private label magnum, and dine on sumptuous platters of classic Italian recipes such as chicken scarpariello, shrimp scampi, fried calamari, and veal saltimbocca. All platters are served in abundant portions to share with family and friends. Diners are forewarned to leave room for dessert – the Titanic, an ice cream laden chocolate torte, is sure to leave entire families satisfied and smiling
The portions are out of control. Go with a minimum of 4-6 people.
Mother’s Day dinner.
The staff was very nice. The food was good. Best dinner we had on our vacation.
Came early and they were able to sit me outside.Always a great meal at Carmines!
Food was really good. Stuffed artichoke, pasta bolognese both great
Wonderful experience. Carmine’s is always our go to when traveling. NYC, Vegas, Nassau. Always first class. The meals are huge and meant to be shared. Ceasar salad is the best ever.
This is not the same quality of food as the Camines in New York. Our food was watery and tasted microwaved. I would not recommend this place especially for the cost.
Carmine's was great. Only thing, they forgot it was my grandbaby's birthday so that was a bummer.
Family style. Very big plates easy to over order. Food does come out quickly and is hot. Staff was very friendly and helpful.
It was rly amazing!!! plus they have gluten free pasta which is great for those w allergies and intolerance
Hostess could be more friendly at the time of receiving customers
Vacation Very enjoyable experience. Casual but still special
Great service. A lot of food. Good drinks. SHARE dinners. Loved chicken Parmesan!
Ravioli served 3 kids!
So disappointed in this New York favorite. The service was. In existent. We waited 40 minutes for an espresso and our drinks. I asked repeatedly for olive oil and fresh bread. I had to get up from the table and go to the food station to get it myself. My girlfriend asked for a plate of grilled or sautéed vegetables. While the portion was enormous, the food was average. We didn’t take any home ...donated it to the kitchen staff.
I wouldn’t go back again....
Best spaghetti and meatballs I’ve ever had
Amazing service, they let us still sit with four extra people even after we showed up late! Very kind. Such yummy wine, such yummy food! Had a very fun night with the friends and fam all thanks to Carmines!
Great food as always. Dine every year on vacation. Server was good but not around enough for 2nd drinks, forgotten anchovies for ceasar salad. Table clearing and food delivery excellent
We have been to the NYC Carmines and the food is always great so while on Paradise Island we thought we would check it out even though we were staying at and all-inclusive resort 10 minutes away. Well it was definitely worth the price and the walk! The Chicken Scapariello was the best we have ever eaten!
Food is good but pricey. The service was just okay. Since the gratuity is part of the price the wait staff have no need to go the extra mile. Also, the ladies washroom was horrible.
Loved it! Great food, excellent service and we booked a second reservation for the same trip.
Go Hungry !!!
The meals are huge! One meal will definitely feed 4 people.
Wife’s birthday celebration
This is perfect for families!!! Best deal at Atlantis ! The portions could feed 8-10 easy! For example we had Lasagna and Caesar said with bread for $100! It’s like home cooking at its finest 😀
I don't really have any positive things to say about this location or the food.
Great food, huge portions as it’s family style. It is expensive but in line with all restaurants in the Bahamas.
Awesome service and food !
Very accommodating with young children !!!
Very great experience
Our entree arrived in under two minutes before we even had our salad
Very good service. Meals are family style with huge portions so only order 1-2 dishes per table. We had spaghetti with meatballs and a salad and it was plenty for 4 adults. We didn’t finish either dish. The unlimited baskets of excellent bread probably had something to do with that. One of the best meals and values at Atlantis.
BEST dining experience at Atlantis. Laid back, friendly service and OUTSTANDING food! 10/10 all around! N
Although we’ve been to Atlantis multiple times, we were pleasantly surprised by our first experience at Carmine’s. The portions are huge- the 4 of us (3 men, 1 woman) ordered a salad and 2 entrees and could not finish it. The lasagna was very good. Veal parmigiana good but could have been hotter. The service was excellent. We were seated inside where the noise level was high and asked to be moved to an outdoor table- which we were easily accommodated. Overall a great experience, good food, outstanding value.
Large portions small taste
We were pleasantly surprised, given that we are NY’ers and this is a NYC chain. The fra-diavolo sauce was amazing (* spicy). The pasta (angel hair linguini)was perfect too. Note - most meat and shrimp dishes allow you to add pasta for $15. The staff was very cheery and pleasant to deal with. All in a great night. IMPORTANT - lay off the bread and don’t order too much! The servings are ENORMOUS. Each dish serves 3-4 people.
Very disappointed. Treated rudely by waitstsff but laughed that off. They are obviously not happy, but didn’t ruin my night. Food was mediocre at best. Salad terrible, rigatoni Bolognese came out luke warm. Chicken parm smothered in cheese, and texture was rubbery. Brocolli with garlic was very good, would recommend that. Cannolis inedible, seriously funny we all spit our first and only bite out into our napkins. I do like the atmosphere but food needs improvement. If you’re eating at Atlantis you can do better. We had a great experience at Cafe Matisse in Nassau the following night for authentic Italian and outstanding service. There are better options on property. Don’t really like the family style options. $37 for a plate of noodles with sauce is silly. Look elsewhere on property. Olives or Nobu are much better.
excellent service. big portions. personable waitstaff.
Nothing like the NYC restaurant experience and the service was terrible.
Came highly recommended so we booked a reservation. The waiters came multiple different ties to take drink and food orders all the while never communicating with each other. Our food was never out in and they hat kept asking what did you order.