Carmelo's Coat of Arms
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
beef & pork, tomato sauce, house-made ricotta
Pan-Seared Filet Mignon
Anson Mills polenta, blueberry gastrique
Fabulous food and service as per usual. Love, love, love the new outside seating area. The only recommendation I have for improvement is to put up some additional fencing to block the parking lot security light when it comes on.
Carmelo never disappoints! The blueberry filet was the best it’s been (and it’s already good).
Such a fun night only issue was all the fruit flies.
Food done to expectation. Serving size was just right.
Always great food and great service at this restaurant!
ALWAYS a fabulous meal at Carmelo's CoA! Staff is friendly, courteous and professional.
Despite doing a great job of socially distancing the tables, there were a group (?) of about 8-10 maskless people at the bar area standing around with drinks talking. Yes, they could all be vaccinated, as are we, but it made us nervous, so we left.
We've never been disappointed when we've dined there... still would highly encourage people to enjoy Carmelo's.
A small, charming restaurant in historic Lewiston, Ny. The decor is homey, the staff very knowledgeable about their menu, and quickly make you feel right at home. The chef/owner is committed to bringing the freshest ingredients to the table. I highly recommend any of the homemade pasta dishes. You will not only enjoy your first visit, but your future ones as well.
Perfect pasta and great service!
We ate outside and listened to some lovely jazz. We were celebrating my wife's birthday and she was very happy with everything.
Carmelo's has excellent food and service, it is a small restaurant and depending on who is seated at a table near you, you might find it a bit noisy. That issue aside, it is the location we regularly got to for celebration dinners.
Best place in Lewiston to eat dinner, we make a point to eat there every time we visit
Loved everything about Carmelo’s. Great food and service in a beautiful room.
Pleasant evening at Carmelo‘s compromised outdoor dining.
Food of very good quality
Innovative food sourced locally.
We choose Carmelo’s for our wedding anniversary dinner every year. Carmelo never disappoints!
Amazing experience as usual! Diane and crew made Kathy’s birthday special. Thank you so much!!!
Such a nice quaint restaurant. Food is always delicious. Pasta is made in house. Local ingredients. Very personable wait staff. Will come again and would definitely recommend
Wonderful meal. Excellently done. Highly recommend it
Service was attentive, friendly, and considerate. Helped us enjoy our special night. Went out of way to accommodate special request in appetizer. Happily took our photo. Offered complimentary dessert for special occasion.
Carmelos was lovely for Date Night. The food was delicious and the homemade pasta especially was fantastic. We will definately be back
Great. Food and and service were great. Wish the wine list was as good as the food.
Fantastic food quick and timely service
Menu limited and dinners all different
Wine on bitter side
Service very slow
A local gem close to Niagara Falls, but a million miles from the grime and deterioration of that city. Lewiston is a charming small town with lots of shops, restaurants, and parks. Carmelo's has a relatively small menu, but there's a nice variety, and service on a busy summer night was excellent.
Really great and fresh food. Calamari salad exceptional. Pasta also very, very good. Best meal we had in Niagara Falls area, easily.
Food was poor. Salty, insipid, flavorless dishes including con vodka sauce, calamari, etc.....
A good selection of starters, freshly made pastas and innovative sauces, fish and meat menu items. The quality, portions and presentation of the dishes is always the same whenever we’ve dined at Carmelo’s… first rate. The staff are friendly and helpful. A cozy ambience. Love dining here!
Dining at Carmelos is never a disappointment. It's one of very few restaurants that we totally trust the quality, freshness and cleanliness. So hard to say that with most other restaurants that we frequent.
Alicia is the best. Very accommodating and the nicest person I've ever met. She deserves a raise. Thank you for such a wonderful evening.
Best Italian food I’ve had in a long time
Carmelo’s offered a wonderful dining experience. The meatball appetizer was excellent and the fresh pasta was among the best I’ve had. We will be back!
The filet mignon was amazing, as was the starter meatballs. The orecchiette was good, but not great. It was a busy evening, but the service was not great. Very friendly staff though. I highly recommend for a nice evening out, if visiting.
Pasta and everything is fresh and in-house. Best restaurant in western New York.
We had an amazing experience. Out sightseeing, came upon this restaurant and were blown away by the inventive menu. Everything that we ordered had a pleasant surprise to it, and we also got to meet the chef at the end of our evening. They also paid special attention to our son with a severe food allergy and made sure we had a safe and enjoyable meal. The ambiance was fantastic, and our server was wonderful. All-around our favorite dinner of the trip!
We were visiting Niagara Falls, and we found this as a recommendation on Open Table. Our waitress was so friendly and engaging. We both had different homemade pasta dishes that were so fresh and tasty. The strawberry crostata was divine! Definitely recommend this quaint family owned Italian restaurant!
As usual, Carmelo's was excellent in every way. Best meatballs in WNY. Everything was the best of them best.
Always a treat for us to dine at Carmelo’s, where we experience the same high level of service and quality of food!
You can order delivery directly from Carmelo's Coat of Arms using the Order Online button. Carmelo's Coat of Arms also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (716) 754-2311.
Carmelo's Coat of Arms is rated 4.8 stars by 596 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.