Caribbean Fish Market
But we are more than just Food …Fabulous food is only one aspect of your dining experience!
Two adult couples for dinner at 7pm on a Thursday. We were seated outside near the bar where the music was exceptionally loud (we couldn't even talk to each other). Upon a request to move, they turned down the music to a tolerable level since they didn't have any tables available away from the bar. Food was very good (as always). Service was good.
Excellent Service. The Chilean Sea Bass was fantastic, as was the fresh catch Grouper with stuffed Crabmeat. Had a table for two outside. Great ambience, Romantic, yet still good for larger groups.
Great place to eat at. Great staff.
Ambiance was nice, cute place. Highly overrated on the food, we ordered the Tuesday special - seafood paella and it tasted like the rice had been cooked a day ago and was mushy like baby food, along with old tasting seafood - had to send it back. The rest of the food was ok, but didn’t have much flavor. This place has good reviews and maybe it’s other food, but overall prices do not match the quality of the food. Our server would disappear at times and not be around, but she was very apologetic and offered many things in place so we did appreciate that.
Amazing service and food. The food came as ordered and our server was attentive and engaging.
Great food, service, views and ambiance. We are definitely going back before we go back home.
Food was on point. Kiki was amazing! Highly recommend
The ambience inside and the view outside is definitely worth it. Additionally, the food and cocktails were amazing! Portion sizes are small for cost but that's expected for this type of establishment.
Good and service was excellent I will definitely return
Food and drinks were great!!! Restaurant was very nice and my Server was amazing!
We loved this place so much that we ate here twice!! The atmosphere is amazing…right on the water, tiki torches, all fresco dining, fabulous food. We highly recommend! Our favorite on the island!!
Get the lobster, you will NOT regret it. Food and service were on point. Fantastic view with delicious food. It was so good we are going back again. Well done CFM, excellent job.
We thoroughly enjoyed the food and service. Our waiter Admiral was absolutely phenomenal 👏🏾. You have to go when on the island.
Absolutely Fantastic dinner and service
We ordered Brussel sprouts, drunken mussels, the hot pot and wahoo. The only thing with flavor was the Brussel sprouts. Everything else was extremely bland.
This place passes itself off as higher end, the atmosphere and prices are kinda. The best service I had all week on the island! I can say that about it. However, I had the Lobster tail my husband had the grouper, both were incredibly underwhelming for the price. Please don’t take this wrong I have no problem paying for good food, but there is nothing good to say. The lobster was slightly over cooked, the grouper was dry, presentation was weak. There is nothing I can say bad about the meal, it was just eh. We sat outside there was some bugs out, the server offered us bug spray so that’s good. My opinion, save your money and go somewhere more local.
Amazing place with incredible food! Our favorite dinner in St Thomas during our 5 night trip! For those of you going, I suggest preparing with bug spray if you are a mosquito magnet like me. It was still worth it but I walked away with about 15 bites! 🦟
Food was ok. Not worth the price. Small menu and they didn’t have everything on the menu available which was disappointing.
Lobster overcooked @$90 ruins the night! Blu cheese dressing on wedge tasted like ricotta cheese. No sauce for calamari. Tasted frozen.
Brunch was great! The crab cakes Benedict specially. And our server, “the Ambassador”. Also the price was appropriate, and the mimosas were tasty.
Excellent food and service!
Portion compared to the price was worth it. Mash potatoes were over salty. Penna Shrimp pasta was very soupy
The drinks, service and ambiance are great. One of our plates (lobster tail) was delicious but overpriced and small, another plate (hot pot) was under-seasoned. Overall I would maybe try again or just hit the bar because the ambiance was great.
Service was great and the food was good but expectations were set pretty high.
Very nice atmosphere and the food and service was great! Look forward to returning!
Food was pretty good. 1 dish needed additional cooking time and another was dry. Overall we had several entrees for sampling.
This place is a must if visiting St Thomas. Service was good, ambiance was great but the food Elias exceptional! We wanted to lick the plate (jk)
The appetizers were brought within 5 minutes after we order and the were cold. I told the waiter and he got upset (go figure). Finally someone else can me to the table to assist. When we did get hot appetizers they certainly didn’t meet expectations. Crab cakes and lobster beignets were terrible. We order the lobster tail as an entree it turned out okay. The price was way beyond the product.
Great atmosphere - right on the beach - and great food and drinks. Service was wonderful. Highly recommend! We'll be back for sure!
The food was excellent. Our server, Carla, was excellent. There was no soap in the women’s bathroom. We’d put on mosquito spray while waiting for our table so we wanted to wash our hands. I asked the bartender for some dish soap. “Give me a second” he started washing glasses. I ask the concierge: “ask that guy walking out of the kitchen”! I stand outside the kitchen and finally a female server walks by and asked what I needed. I tell her there’s no soap. She brings some dish soap and gave me some. I shared it with my sister and we washed our hands. When we are leaving the washroom a server is coming in and we tell her. She goes I and that’s where my story ends. Who knows who she served with unwashed hands.
Definitely recommend! Ask about the rum cake...so yummy! Good service and waiter was friendly!
We had a very nice dinner. Our server Kevin was attentive and prompt. The watermelon/arugula salad was quite refreshing. My husband had the grouper and I had the lemon chicken: both yummy. Did I mention the coconut cake? With housemate chocolate ice cream, it was a great way to top off a spectacular dinner. Well done!!
We were seated at our table. We waited at least 15 minutes and no one came to at least give us some water. I got up and went
To the hostess station. She said “I have no idea who your server is”. So on my way back to the table I asked a passing server to please bring us some water which she did. I then asked her to find out who our server was and she said she didn’t know but would take our order. We ordered snd then overheard another server telling the guests about the specials that evening. I was disappointed after the fact about that.
There was a mosquito infestation and guests were batting them off their table and food.
Our meal was good but overall experience was horrid. The hostess had a bad attitude as well.
Doubt we would return.
The food was delicious, from the apps to the entrees. Our server was there when we needed her too, and even called us a cab to get back to our resort.
Only downside was the mosquitos at night, which unfortunately got so bad at one point us and a few other tables had to go to the front desk to put Off on.
Waited for over 15 mins for a server to great us. 46$ wahoo was very over cooked and my pear and Brie pizza was lackluster at best. The music was extremely loud and was impossible to have a conversation with my husband on our anniversary dinner. Overall the worst dining experience on the island!
This place delivered the total package of a dining experience, the ambiance and location were unbelievable. The food and service matched on every level. What an amazing experience for our last dinner on this trip!
Fantastic meal!! The beachfront setting and outdoor seating along with the incredible food made for such a great evening!!
Caribbean Fish Market is rated 4.5 stars by 780 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.