Caribbean Fish Market
But we are more than just Food …Fabulous food is only one aspect of your dining experience!
Great food. Excellent service and a spectacular setting on the beach. Make a reservation and ask for a table outside. Best part was the great attitude of everyone working there. Pleasant, attentive, and helpful.
Definitely one of the best on the island.
Awful. The food wasn’t great and the service was mediocre. Considering the price point and reviews we expected a lot better.
Will not be returning.
A very nice dinner date night! A little confusion at the hostess table, but once seated, we had a lovely outside table, a nice attentive waiter (Liz), and a wonderful dinner. Started with conch fritters and house salad. Salad was so fresh with a lemon vinaigrette and large enough to share. The fritters were perfectly lightly fried. We had the sesame seed wahoo and crab crusted grouper for dinner. The wahoo dish was an Asian style with rice noodles and was a large portion and sooo yummy. The crusted grouper was like having a crab cake and fresh grouper all in one and was served with mashed potatoes. All the desserts looked tempting and had the key lime pie which was served with a cinnamon like sorbet. Interesting combo and it worked! We would definitely recommend to our friends and will return to Caribbean Fish Market. Oh, and kudos to our waiter for offering to call us a cab - so sweet! Thanks for a nice evening!
Beautiful area on the beach, wonderful menu, exceptionally friendly service.
The food was delicious! Some of the best seafood our whole trip. Our server was excellent and the drink I had was also yummy!
This is the second time we have been here and again everything is excellent! The food here is amazing. You have to go if you are here. Highly recommend!
Amazing staff, beautiful atmosphere and food was awesome! Highly recommend
We were seated in the back room where the seats were uncomfortable and the noise level deafening. Our waiter forgot about us and twice we asked the hostess to locate our waiter, to no avail. The calamari appetizer was chewy and bland. The wait for the check was interminable. Even though our entrees were excellent, our overall experience at this restaurant was pretty awful. Not recommended for anyone over 40.
What a great view of the beach. The food was great, I never had lobster with a cream sauce but I liked it alot. I recommend sit outside and make reservations a few days in advance. We were there at 6 PM and it was just right.
The food was excellent as was the service. Our waiter Big Life was friendly and attentive!
Beautiful setting quickly faded with service rising to lackluster at best and almost rude at worst. We tried the paella special which we found to be anything but special. The deserts were tasty though, and when we finally got the waiter to open our wine it was decent as well. I had high expectations based on the recommendations of a local, but wouldn’t recommend it.
It was our first anniversary dinner. Great seafood!! Beautiful location and amazing sunset views!
Excellent food in a delightful setting. Highly recommended.
Excellent brunch and wonderful service!
We dined the day before Easter to celebrate two birthdays. Service was friendly, food came out so quickly and was delicious! A wonderful experience overall!
Host was rude and service was lacking
Outstanding , first time I teared up from eating a great meal. It’s worst whatever you need to do to dine there.
We dine on the beach and WOW it was everything I dreamed of.
Excellent dinner. Very nice place, but had a busy feel.
Server obviously had too many tables, but food was worth it.
Our waiter was a little out there. He spilled the pitcher of water right next to me when pouring our glasses, joked about it and never cleaned it up. We never got one of the appetizers we ordered and the grouper was good, but not $40 good.
The food and service were outstanding! The view of the beach was perfect!!
Power went out unfortunately.
Grant was awesome
Excellent brunch location and incredible view. The food and service is consistently amazing.
Beautiful location! Busier than expected. Host accommodated us early which we appreciated. But we were placed beside a very large,very loud group so our experience was not as relaxing and enjoyable as we hoped. The service was great. The food came out very quickly. The food was delicious. Overall I’m glad we went.
Great restaurant with great seafood! Fast & efficient service and outside tables with bay views. Will repeat. Bring your own hand sanitizer though, it was scarce there.
Delicious food, beautiful atmosphere, great service!
Great place for a date night or special occasion. The food and service was excellent!
Everything was ok, not amazing. The restaurant itself has a beautiful location and atmosphere. The food just seemed ok. Mussels had a very bland sauce. Pasta sausage was a bit watery and taste just wasn’t there. Hot pot was good but felt like something was missing like veggies?
We made a reservation and looked forward to a nice experience. Food was pretty good but we were completely rushed through. Entree was brought out before salad. Upon bringing this up to waitstaff, he questioned, “do you still want it?”
4 of us for dinner after a sunset cruise and the service and food were excellent. Shared a conch fritter which was great and then two of us shared surf and turf and 2 had crab stuffed grouper which were both fabulous.
Great dinner—perfect setting, delicious lobster, and good service.
Celebrating a friend’s birthday the food was great the dessert was on point and we had a wonderful time over all thanks 💚
Lobster was salty and tough. Literally gave me 2 fork fulls of mash potatoes. Not worth it
We went to Caribbean Fish Market on our St. Thomas trip in March, 2021. It was excellent! We had reservations and as soon as we arrived, we were seated. Even with the restaurant at full capacity, the server immediately greeted us, went over the specials, and took our drink orders. The food portions were extremely large, even by American standards. I would have been embarrassed to eat so much food except that the food was so good I didn't want to leave anything on the plate! Dessert was decadent - definitely get the ice cream! The atmosphere offered a nice balanced vibe of both "you're on an island" casual and "get fancy bc you're on vacation" ambiance. My daughters & I wore sundresses and my husband wore a button down with khaki shorts and it was exactly the correct attire. After dinner, we walked on the beach for a bit. When we were ready to leave, there were taxis waiting to take us home. From start to finish, it was an excellent experience that I would recommend!
Always go back on Tuesdays for Paella night. One of the good places on island. Great service from the Ambassador;-)
Excellent in all respects.....good night at Carib Fish Mkt
Very unique place to dine ! The wait for seating is not long and the food is very tasty! Definitely put this restaurant on your list!
Hands down the best seafood I’ve ever had! The service was phenomenal and the views are amazing
Caribbean Fish Market is rated 4.5 stars by 540 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.