Caribbean Fish Market
But we are more than just Food …Fabulous food is only one aspect of your dining experience!
Chef's selection of fresh oysters
Caribbean lobster tail, shrimp, fresh catch, mussels, calamari & saffron arborio rice
Service and food was excellent. Needs a more kid friendly menu. And the drinks were water down. But the service was friendly and environment was clean
Loved the wahoo with rice noodles, and the watermelon & arugula salad was also really good. Our server, Dulce, was very helpful, efficient & friendly.
This has been a mainstay on St Thomas for quite a few yearsand is one of the best restaurants on the east end of the island. I have been to most of the top restaurants because I spend at least a month here every year and I would say this restaurant is in the top three. And definitely ahead of the competition as far as price value and ambience. They did an amazing job restoring this after the hurricane and it’s better than it has ever been before. We dined with friends and the food was absolutely perfect, the service was excellent, and they do have a very good wine selection if you’re into that, But hey when you’re down here you really should be drinking rum it goes with the climate.
Delicious food, romantic ambiance, superb service.
My husband and I chose this restaurant for a nice night out on our anniversary trip. We ordered the wahoo and grouper and within a couple minutes of ordering the food was brought out and wasn’t hot. We ate the meal and the food tasted ok. Our server asked if we would need a cab after our meal and he had it there before we had even finished our drinks. We were looking for fine dining not reheated fast food so we were disappointed by the rushed experience.
Best lobster we have ever eaten. Would recommend to anyone.
Great food, servers were lovely. Best dining experience we have has on ST Thomas- big shout out to our server Genieve
Outstanding food quality and presentation! Awesome menu- great variety in all categories: appetizers, main course, sides, desserts. Great value for the food quality, service and atmosphere! Our waiter “ Ambassador” was also outstanding. We enjoyed everything about Caribbean Fish Market very much and will definitely go back every time we are in St Thomas!
Great time and delicious food but our waitress was incredibly rude and miserable. I actually felt bad asking her for anything! But the restaurant was beautiful and the ambience great.
Great place for a good sea food meal. The creme brulee was remarkable.
The food is outstanding. We had our third dinner last night and we were seated inside and it was a little noisy. But the food was outstanding and the drinks are a generous portion.
Great food. I recommend the crabmeat stuffed lobster!
Awesome food and beautiful restaurant and view of the beach
Our server had no knowledge of food and was on her phone while our drinks were empty. The stuffed lobster was 125 which was an unnecessary 2.5 lbs of lobster with no flavor. Completely ruined our night. This was the worse 185 spent without even having drinks.
Really good meal and experience. Service was very attentive and professional. Menu has many great options. We enjoyed the Wedge salad -- very different with the caribbean shrimp, along with the Wahoo and Grouper... everything was better than expected and look forward to returning.
We were very happy with everything. We had stuffed lobster and it was outstanding.
Every aspect was amazing - from host stand to service and food quality.
We arrived 30 minutes early - grabbed a drink at the bar after checking in with the host stand and within 10 minutes our table was ready.
Sat in the courtyard area and had Samuel as our server - Samuel and his second bartender working that night were both extremely attentive and checked on us several times throughout the night.
Specialty cocktails were perfect - apps and entrees were all delicious.
We capped the night back in the bar area where Samuel made us chocolate martinis which were a perfect night cap.
Highly recommend - thanks to the entire team for a great night
Our family of 5 went to dinner while vacationing on St Thomas. The food was pretty good but the service of our server and the manager left a bad taste in our mouths! Due to the auto-gratuity, our server was no where to be found. We had to chase someone down for drink refills or any other needs during our meal. When we brought this matter to the manager, he just brushed it off like we were bothering him! The level of service did not go along with a $320 meal for 5! We will never return!!
The server was Ambassador.
He made the evening special. Jonathan
Ambience, service and food was outstanding. Caribbean Fish Market came highly recommended by a couple friends. My experience was awesome. Staff was superb. Will most definitely recommend to others. Definitely intend on dining at Caribbean Fish Market again.
Nothing special for us. Average food. Sorry
I love the food and I’m a repeat customer. On this particular day the service was not good at all. It took 40 mins for the waitress to come to us. She claimed it wasn’t her table but she was not very attentive after either. Kept forgetting that we asked for something and took forever to get it to us.
Brunch was wonderful. We shrimp and grits super yummy 😋
Incredible. We were too late for the Caribbean stuffed lobster 😪 But we got lobster tails with crab cakes instead. No complaints whatsoever. A wonderful dinner, wonderful ambiance, and our server was great!!
Loved this place! Our waiter was amazing , great food & ambience
Food was terrific. The tuna nacho appetizer was the best thing I’ve eaten on this entire trip. Bring your bug spray if you get an outside table though for your ankles. A few mosquito bites are well worth the great food bites.
I can't believe this place has so many good reviews as their is no table that is not under a ceiling fan on super high. We are talking about 1,000 cfm fans just 6 to 8 fett above your table. No way is this anything other than a glorified beach bar. Will never recommend nor consider this as a "dinning" option.
We came for the first time last Sunday evening, for an early dinner. We were very pleased, the reviews were correct! We had the locally caught Crab crusted Grouper, and fresh salad. Both dishes were excellent — well prepared and well presented, nice portions and well served. We also had a bottle of French white wine, also very good, at an OK price. This restaurant is on the expensive side, but you will not be disappointed with your meal. Do make reservations, it fills up quickly. One suggestion, use or bring bug spray, the “noseeems’ are fierce at dusk to evening! Don’t pass up this restaurant near Red Hook, in St Thomas!
Both had stuffed lobster. Lobster was tough and stuffing wasn’t great. Service was excellent. Food not so much. Not worth the price.
This is a special place. Off the beaten path with great ambiance. Service was also great food quality was also very good. My wife’s dish (Hot Pot) was outstanding, my Grouper was very good but not as good as my Grouper at French Quarter Bistro. I would defiantly go here again.
Beautiful view, excellent service and great food! Absolutely one of my favorites
If you go for dinner, request the waiter Mr. Big Life! He was amazing and made our dining experience even better than expected!
Went here for the brunch, stayed for the beach. Granted the food is absolutely delicious, but nothing beat's that view. I'll always visit here from now on when I'm on the island. Try it you won't be disappointed.
Two adult couples for dinner at 7pm on a Thursday. We were seated outside near the bar where the music was exceptionally loud (we couldn't even talk to each other). Upon a request to move, they turned down the music to a tolerable level since they didn't have any tables available away from the bar. Food was very good (as always). Service was good.
Food was very tasty, had the chicken and fillet steak. Restaurant is right on the beach so amazing location but attached to the bar so it was noisy.
Excellent Service. The Chilean Sea Bass was fantastic, as was the fresh catch Grouper with stuffed Crabmeat. Had a table for two outside. Great ambience, Romantic, yet still good for larger groups.
Great place to eat at. Great staff.
Ambiance was nice, cute place. Highly overrated on the food, we ordered the Tuesday special - seafood paella and it tasted like the rice had been cooked a day ago and was mushy like baby food, along with old tasting seafood - had to send it back. The rest of the food was ok, but didn’t have much flavor. This place has good reviews and maybe it’s other food, but overall prices do not match the quality of the food. Our server would disappear at times and not be around, but she was very apologetic and offered many things in place so we did appreciate that.
Amazing service and food. The food came as ordered and our server was attentive and engaging.
Caribbean Fish Market is rated 4.5 stars by 817 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.