Calamari & Shrimp
Fried Calamari – Shrimp – Zucchini – Arrabbiata
Tomato Sauce - Burrata - Basil
Potato Dumpling – Fresh Tomato - Basil – Homemade Stracciatella Cheese
Bland and flavorless.
Excellent everything, from the hostess, waiters, attention, atmosphere, food tester and presentation.
Brunch sandwiches were great, the pasta sciliano with the eggplant tasted burnt, but my wife didn't want to return it. Our server was attentive and pleasant.
Always great. And nothing better than Max’s stories !
Food was great, however our waiter took forever to get to us. Hope to get better service next time.
Best food and apppies ever. The dessert are awesome too.
Their VIP Program is not the value they advertise. They sell gift cards at Costco that are a far better deal but even those cannot be used at Happy Hour. Neither can the VIP card and it can't be used in conjunction with the Costco Gift card. Every other Naples restaurant that joins with Costco considers the gift cards the same as a cash payment.
Fabulous food. Drink and friendships renewed.
We celebrated 2 birthday and it was just wonderful! The food.. service and energy.
All wonderful ❤️
Antônio was a fabulous waiter. Great food!
The service was great and the food was delicious. There’s a great variety of items to choose from on the menu
The old fashioned drink was not good, service was slow, restaurant was too hot and restrooms were not clean. Appetizers were good, lamb & bolognese were not good, not much taste to either of them. Not worth the money.
Antonio was our server and we had one of the best meals we’ve ever had in Naples. The food was delicious, the wine and cocktails were awesome, and the service was truly the best part.
One of our favorites. This time we had Risotto with sea food and it was delicious. Even the regular house salad is plentiful, fresh and with a light lemon vinaigrette dressing.
Amazing food per usual. One of our favorites!
This restaurant is one of the best in Naples. From the service to the food it was all excellent.
Food was excellent but I wasn’t a big fan of the modern, somewhat sterile decor.
The pasta is HOMEMADE and you can tell! It was light, but still carried the flavor of the bolognese sauce well. Their wine list was fantastic. We also had the beef carpaccio and it was served wonderfully - with arugala and shaved parmesan and mushrooms and truffles - and a lemon to squeeze over it all. We were left very satisfied!
Great evening for a birthday celebration. The food and the ambience were fabulous.
Receptionist was crass. When asked if we could have a booth, she just yelled "No".
The music was too loud and not suited to dining.
The ambiance was more like a diner than a fine restaurant.
The server was good and the food was prepared well.
We will not return.
Was not happy with my selection. Lobster was over cooked. The pasta was not linguine. The margaritas and cannolis were fabulous
We had a very enjoyable evening and our waiter was excellent.
One of the best places on 5th ave to grab lunch! Fair pricing, awesome wait staff, and was much easier to get a table than I expected.
Calamari appetizer was delicious but not hot. Main course not served for almost an hour. Food was good. Server was pleasant and knowledgeable but wait for our entrees was unacceptable.
Food was good, service was good. Bathrooms were filthy.... big turn off
Nice place but service needs help. Food was fair not great.
Overall good time.
We had a late reservation, it was quite but we still had amazing service and food too.
Great experience! Such a cute Italian restaurant. Meatballs, lasagna, and veal chop was amazing!!
First, we have been here many times in the past. We were seated quickly and we anticipated a lovely night for Mother’s Day. However, it took 15 min before we were even recognized. We asked for bread which never came. We ordered a bottle of red wine which clearly was corked. When we said there was an issue we were told the manager was going to come over. He came about 15 min later. By then we were ready to leave. We still had no service (35 min total) by then. We began to speak with the manager who was very rude and insulting stating that we, the customers were “impatient”. At that point there was nothing left to do but leave. We had a great time at la trattoria a restaurant a few doors down. Will not go back to cafe Milano.
I arrived and hostess said there weee no outside table even though I requested one. Seated inside under a music speaker above. So moved me to next table but then after asking to lower music. She did not so my guests also complained as we couldn’t hear ourselves talk. Thought for Mother’s Day maybe some softer music.
Service was far from being good, not enough attention to guests. Seems that they were simply tired. We had to ignore question regarding tips, as it seems obvious that such service does deserve any tips. Very bad experience
The food and ambiance were excellent. The server, however, while polite and efficient was a bit too talkative to the point of stating out loud the amount of the check in front of two guests. Overall he did a good job but this last was not appropriate. Would recommend the restaurant to others.
The food was amazing! We will definitely be back next time we are in town.
Service at the bar was great before we sat down. Service at the table was slow and inattentive. Took away from the time we had.
great place for italian on 5th ave in Naples!!
Our meal from start to finish was outstanding. We started with the octopus for an appetizer. It was probably the best octopus we've ever had, it was so tender .
Our meal , I had the skirt steak my wife the tuna. Both dishes done perfectly. Our waiter was very knowledgeable and attentive. Very enjoyable dinner , highly recommend .
My wife ordered the Margherita Pizza. It was basically a cheese pizza with a ton of cheese and 2 pieces of basil. The sauce had a good flavor but there was too much mozzarella cheese on it. We probably shouldn't have ordered it because it did say mozzarella. At other restaurants when ordering Margherita Pizza it's usually fresh burrata cheese or fresh mozzarella in small quantities.
Caffe Milano does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Caffe Milano also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (239) 692-8480.
Caffe Milano is rated 4.5 stars by 1907 OpenTable diners.
Caffe Milano does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://caffemilano.localgiftcards.com/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.