Homemade Key Lime Pie
There's Nothing Like the Real Thing. Always Made Right by Us, Completely Homemade and incredibly delicious
Corn & Crab Chowder
The food was fabulous. We highly recommend the Lobster roll (add the extra lobster with an up charge if you are hungry), lobster bisque or corn crab chowder (we each had one) and the small Caesar salad brought the flavors together nicely. Don’t leave without getting a gelato. We raved about the salted caramel and amaretto gelatos. The owner and staff were very friendly and informative about the area as were the friendly customers. One couple made a point stopped in to have wine and the soups because they remembered that they were so good from their last visit.
Greatest crab cake ever!
Delicious lobster, pizza & key lime pie
The lobster roll with double meat was very good. So was the Caesar salad that came with the roll. Very friendly service. They have a big pizza oven, do we plan on going back to try the pizza next.
If you want to experience a small neighborhood-type restaurant, Cafe Heavenly is the place to go. I found it hard to find a parking place. We ordered at the counter and were served at our table. There are only a few tables. The food was okay but nothing special - we ordered pizza and a lobster roll. They have a large gelato area, so I assume that is a large part of their business.
I went specifically to try the lobster roll as I love lobster rolls. It was excellent, I selected the hot with butter. I waited outside on the Deck on Flagler Avenue near the bridge. It came pretty quick and was pretty large. It tasted great and I was instantly sad that I didn’t double the meat for $6. Will return. The restaurant is not fine dining by far, it is as advertised a cafe. A very small roadside cafe with indoor and outside seating. Not really sure why I made a reservation on open table as it wasn’t needed. Excellent food in a neat small simple location.
Loud and crowded local favorite for many reasons. I ordered like a soup and salad combo (not on menu) but they got creative. And they gave me a sample of the other soups as a cool, and very yummy, surprise. I ate outside on a beautiful day, got great service out side and also got some gelato --- they sure make it easy to fall in love with this place!!
Quite expensive experience. Go with your coupons.
Great lobster rolls!
My husband and I split a lobster roll and a grilled meatball sandwich for an early lunch. The lobster roll at $25 was not cheap but was the best we ever had — lots of large chunks of lobster and no filling. Grilled meatball sandwich had plenty of melted mozzarella. Delicious!
I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. They have a total of 4 tables, therefore making a reservation didn't matter. I'm not even sure WHY they are on Open Table. The atmosphere is unkempt, inexperienced staff and horrendous food. This place is not up to OpenTable standards.
Absolutely awesome lobster roll with even better service! Thanks!
Great lobster rolls! Tasty gelato. Good wine pours!
Lobster rolls awesome, crab cakes needs some work , cake was more like a patty melt, where was the lump meat??? Staff was awesome
The food is amazing, but this is basically a store front take out restaurant with a few tables, so don't expect this to be your typical open table experience. That being said, the employees are super helpful, very friendly and accommodating. Samples of their excellent food are readily offered. The lobster roll and soups we're outstanding; great pizza and gelato too!
After having been here the day before, for breakfast, I decided to return for lunch in order to try their lobster bisque and hot lobster roll. They were both good, as was the sangria I ordered to wash them down. I also got a small dish of mango gelato for dessert, which was good as well.
The 3-3-3 breakfast special is a great deal, and don't let the menu fool you.....altho it mentions only scrambled eggs and bacon for the special, they will cook the eggs anyway you like them and you can substitute sausage patties in place of the bacon. The service is terrific --- fast, friendly, and very accommodating.
A must go place in NSB. It's small, but everything I've tried tasted fabulous. The owner John has a great sense of humor and keeps the place feeling down to earth, warm and welcoming. Great service.
Fabulous Maine Lobster rolls! Lobster cooked perfect, just touch of Mayo, fresh rolls.
Best lobster rolls south of Maine!! I get the lobster sliders, just enough for me!
My husband gets the roll & for $5 extra you get another big scoop of lobster meat!
So if you are craving Maine lobster go to Cafe' Heavenly!
The food was excellent. Authentic lobster roll with abundant real Maine lobster, amazing lobster bisque and the best homemade pistachio gelato I have ever enjoyed.
Cafe Heavenly has the BEST Lobster rolls south of MAINE. Absolutely fabulous, just the right amount of Mayo, homemade bun overflowing with fresh, tender lobster meat! For $5 extra you get another scoop of pure lobster meat! Ian not say enough about this quaint little restaurant. Great friendly service, beer or wine and pet friendly!! They gave my dog, CoCo a cup of ice cream! She loved the surprise!
Really wasn't a need to make reservation. Had the award winning clam chowder
Cafe Heavenly is one of our favorite places to eat. Love their crab cakes, gelato, Lobster Roll, soup, and their wood fired pizza....The Athens Greece Pizza is our favorite.
Love their daily special, especially the Friday night one... Buy one pizza get one 1/2 off.
They are trying different things, such as very good steak, grilled asparagus, mushrooms.... Not sure it will be successful. The atmosphere, lack of presentation, and small round tables make it difficult to enjoy an expensive meal.
We enjoy eating out side and the atmosphere is so relaxed it is one of our favorite places to eat.
Cafe Heavenly does offer delivery in partnership with Chow Now and Uber Eats. Cafe Heavenly also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (386) 427-7475.
Cafe Heavenly is rated 4.2 stars by 23 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.