Skip to Main Content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York / Tri-State Area
  4. Long Island / Hamptons
  5. Carle Place

Cafe Formaggio

4.3
4.3
112 Reviews
$30 and under
Italian

Cafe Formaggio’s owners and friendly staff invite you, your friends and family members to step inside, settle in with a glass of wine and simply savor the luscious scents of authentic Italian cuisine.

From the intoxicating aroma of plum tomato, basil and rich Italian cheeses, to the smoky goodness of thin crust personal pizzas, Cafe Formaggio offers a meal to please just about everyone.

Think of Cafe Formaggio after a morning of nearby shopping and enjoy lunch. Or, pre-order for the office and your meals will be ready when you arrive. Plan ahead for special occasions and treat your party to a delicious celebration, supervised by our courteous servers.

And please, check our special events page to find out about our weekly specials and upcoming events.

Permanently Closed

This restaurant is permanently closed.

0 Photos

No photos have been uploaded for this restaurant yet.

Menu

Soups

$7; combine any of our homemade soups with your choice of any small salad for $14

  • Pasta Fagioli

    • Vegetable Minestrone

      • Escarole and Beans

        • Tortellini in Brodo

          • Stracciatella Romano

            Wraps or Paninis

            $14; all served with a side salad. Your choice of any of the following:

            • Padrino

              Broccoli rabe, grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers

              • Femmina

                Oven-roasted Portobello mushrooms, broccoli rabe, roasted peppers, grilled vegetables and fresh mozzarella

                • Lemon Basil

                  Grilled chicken, mesclun greens, tomatoes, avocado, and shredded mozzarella in a lemon basil dressing

                  • Emmelyn

                    Grilled chicken, Portobello mushrooms, Gorgonzola cheese, roasted peppers in a balsamic vinaigrette

                    • Perfecto

                      fried chicken cutlet with fresh roasted peppers, melted mozzarella, red onions with italian herb mayonnaise

                      • Buono

                        Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and sundried tomatoes with garlic

                        Tuscan Heroes

                        Crispy brick oven crust with light dough inside. All tuscan heroes come with french fries

                        • Shrimp Monalisa$14.00

                          jumbo fried shrimp with a marsala mushroom wine sauce with melted mozzarella

                          • Chicken Club$13.00

                            Fried or grilled chicken cutlet with lettuce, tomato and italian herb mayonnaise

                            • Chicken Pillardo$13.00

                              grilled chicken cutlet with sauteed broccoli rabe, garlic and oil and melted mozzarella

                              • Short Rib$13.00

                                slow cooked braised beef with sauteed onions and homemade spicy horseradish sauce topped with fresh mozzarella

                                • Traditional Parmigiana

                                  • Meatball, Chicken$13.00
                                  • Veal, Shrimp$14.00

                                Bite Size Offerings

                                • Short Rib Sliders$13.00

                                  slow cooked braised beef with sauteed onions and homemade spicy horseradish sauce topped with fresh mozzarella on fresh baked garlic rolls

                                  • Steak Tid Bits$16.00

                                    Sliced Skirt Steak served over toasted garlic bread topped with fresh mozzarella

                                    Brick Oven Pizza

                                    Thin crust grilled pulled pizza dough - 12 inches

                                    • Margherita$11.00

                                      A plum tomato basil sauce with homemade fresh mozzarella, diced fresh tomatoes, topped with fresh basil

                                      • Grandma$12.00

                                        Homemade fresh mozzarella cheese spotted with a flavorful herbed san marzano plum tomato sauce and fresh garlic

                                        • Buffalo Chicken Margherita$14.00

                                          Fresh sauteed spicy chicken in a spicy bleu cheese barbecue sauce

                                          • Chicken Caesar Pizza$15.00

                                            romaine lettuce with caesar salad dressing topped with grilled or fried chicken over a thin crust pizza

                                            • Crispino$14.00

                                              Broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella, fresh Italian sausage with a san marzano plum tomato sauce

                                              Pasta

                                              • Gnocchi Calatafini$13.00

                                                Filetto di pomodoro sauce sauteed with Sicilian eggplant, with a ricotta salata garnish

                                                • Cavatelli con Cime$14.00

                                                  Broccoli rabe, crumbled sweet Italian sausage and sundried tomatoes served in a garlic and oil brodino

                                                  • Rigatoni Fiorentina$14.00

                                                    Fresh grilled chicken strips, spinach and melted mozzarella, sauteed in a creamy pink sauce

                                                    • Rigatoni alla Vodka$12.00

                                                      Imported prosciutto sauteed in a creamy pink vodka sauce

                                                      • Rigatoni Filetto Pomodoro

                                                        • With Meatballs$14.00
                                                      • Penne Madiera$14.00

                                                        Fresh grilled chicken strips and cubed homemade mozzarella, sauteed in a Madeira wine plum tomato sauce

                                                        • Cavatelli Tre Funghi$14.00

                                                          Portobello, shitake and button mushrooms with fresh grilled chicken and caramelized onions in a light brown marsala wine sauce

                                                          • Linguine con Vongole$14.00

                                                            Manila clams served in your choice of a marinara plum tomato sauce or garlic and oil brodino

                                                            • Capellini Stella di Mare$16.00

                                                              Shrimp, scallops and calamari served in your choice of a marinara plum tomato sauce or fra diavolo sauce

                                                              • Pappardelle Ragu$14.00

                                                                Fresh homemade pasta topped with old-fashioned ragu sauce mixed with slow cooked beef brasciole

                                                                • Ravioli Gratinate$13.00

                                                                  Homemade cheese-filled ravioli served in your choice of a meat sauce or tomato sauce and topped with melted mozzarella

                                                                  • Whole Wheat Penne Primavera$13.00

                                                                    Assorted seasonal vegetables in your choice of a light garlic and oil or plum tomato sauce

                                                                    • Gnocchi Cotti$14.00

                                                                      Our signature creamy roasted pepper basil pesto with breaded chicken and sundried tomatoes

                                                                      Entrees

                                                                      • Gamberoni Risotto$16.00

                                                                        grilled marinated basil shrimp over a vegetable risotto in a scampi sauce

                                                                        • Marinated Skirt Steak$19.00

                                                                          Tender choice skirt steak, grilled to perfection, served over a bed of garlic-mashed potatoes

                                                                          • Chicken Carolina$16.00

                                                                            fresh battered breast of chicken topped with imported prosciutto, broccoli and mozzarella cheese in a garlic, white wine sauce

                                                                            • Chicken Scarpariello$16.00

                                                                              Chicken breast, sausage, potatoes and peppers in a white wine, garlic sauce

                                                                              • Chicken Pillardo$16.00

                                                                                topped with sauteed broccoli rabe and fresh mozzarella

                                                                                • Oreganata Style$16.00

                                                                                  St. Peter Fish, or shrimp baked with seasoned breadcrumbs

                                                                                  • St. Peter Fish Limoncello$16.00

                                                                                    pan seared and served over a limoncello liqueur risotto mixed with spinach and mushrooms

                                                                                    • Parmigiana Style$15.00

                                                                                      Your choice of chicken, eggplant or meatball

                                                                                      • Chicken Francese$15.00

                                                                                        • Chicken Marsala$15.00

                                                                                          • Eggplant Rollatini$15.00

                                                                                            • Shrimp Mona Lisa$17.00

                                                                                              • Veal Parmigiana with Spaghetti$18.00

                                                                                                For menu edits, please contact SinglePlatform at (866) 237-4564.

                                                                                                What 112 people are saying

                                                                                                Overall ratings and reviews

                                                                                                4.3
                                                                                                4.3 based on recent ratings
                                                                                                • 4.4Food
                                                                                                • 4.3Service
                                                                                                • 4.1Ambience
                                                                                                • 4.0Value

                                                                                                NoiseModerate

                                                                                                92% of people would recommend it to a friend

                                                                                                Sort by

                                                                                                Filters

                                                                                                1. PS

                                                                                                  PeterS

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  86 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  86 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on March 14, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  The food was excellent. Nice ambiance and Valet parking.

                                                                                                2. E

                                                                                                  Elenamarcuse

                                                                                                  Tampa

                                                                                                  21 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  21 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on March 8, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  We’ve been dining at Cafe Formaggio for a few years now. The restaurant was recommended to us by friends when I mentioned that one of my grandchildren was gluten free and we were hard put in finding an appropriate place to eat out with her. My friends had a similar problem until they discovered this restaurant, one of the only ones I know of that has a separate, extensive menu dedicated to gluten free choices, including appetizers and desserts. In addition to that, the regular menu’s offerings are wonderful and all the choices we have made have been delicious and plentiful. The decor and ambiance in the restaurant are charming and the service excellent. We rate Cafe Formaggio 5 stars. A favorite of ours.

                                                                                                3. CL

                                                                                                  CLIFFORDO

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  9 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  9 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on March 6, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  WE HAD A PARTY OF 8 FOR LUNCH THOUGH THE PLACE WAS'NT BUSY SERVICE WAS GREAT FOOD WAS EXCELLENT AND WE WERE ABLE TO TALK AND NOT RUSHED OUT.BEEN HERE BEFORE FOR XMAS EVE DINNER AND OTHER OCASIONS ALWAYS GREAT QUALITY OF FOOD AND GREAT SERVICE

                                                                                                4. k

                                                                                                  kathys

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on March 3, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience4

                                                                                                  Great service . Food delicious. Very loud

                                                                                                5. JJ

                                                                                                  JoJo

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  7 reviews

                                                                                                  1.0

                                                                                                  7 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on March 3, 2020

                                                                                                  overall1food1service1ambience2

                                                                                                  I have Celiac and have enjoyed my gluten free dinner here a few times. This time I was glutened and spent the Celine Dion concert in the bathroom, sick as a dog. $170 for a ticket to the bathroom. I don't know if different owner or management but service was terrible and the other diners with me didn't enjoy their non GF dinner. I only ate half my veal marsala because it wasn't good. Thank God I only ate half or I would be in bed for a week instead of 3 days. We were the first group in to be safe from cross contamination but didn't help. Don't advertise separate kitchen areas if not safe for those like me with Celiac Disease. This is not a trend for me, it is my life.

                                                                                                6. OT

                                                                                                  OpenTable Diner

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  2.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on February 29, 2020

                                                                                                  overall2food2service2ambience5

                                                                                                  While the salad and appetizer were great the filet of sole was gray aka frozen. The shrimp were mini rocks and completely tasteless. The risotto was far from creamy

                                                                                                7. BC

                                                                                                  BruceC

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  4 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  4 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 25, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Always a great Gluten Free meal. The best GF selection.

                                                                                                8. CS

                                                                                                  CatherineS

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  2 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  2 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 21, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  My friend treated me to a birthday lunch this Friday -- a lovely, relaxing afternoon there. Although it was the height of the lunch rush hour, we never felt hurried or rushed. Our waiter Lenny was a gem - not only is he a seasoned waiter but so warm and personable too. We felt like we knew him for years. The food was both delicious, abundant and clearly made with finesse. I enjoyed the lemon basil chicken panini and my friend had a scrumptious cavatelli dish with shrimp. Of course I had a birthday glass of Pinot Grigio. We both had coffees and shared one of their amazing desserts. Lunching there was a fantastic way to kick off the weekend.

                                                                                                9. CM

                                                                                                  ChristineM

                                                                                                  Atlantic City

                                                                                                  6 reviews

                                                                                                  2.0

                                                                                                  6 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 17, 2020

                                                                                                  overall2food3service1ambience3

                                                                                                  Used to eat here frequently but haven't been in a while. Shouldn't have bothered going back. Food was decent, except for overly salted vegetables. Service was awful. Waited half an hour for waitress to even come over to our table. Appetizer came right away, but then waited another 45 minutes for food to arrive. I had ordered cavatelli with sausage and broccoli rabe. When food was delivered, the runner said, "We were out of cavatelli, so we gave you penne instead. I hope that's OK." Well... I guess so. Not much I can do about it at this point. I'm certainly not going to wait another hour for another meal to be prepared. Really should have complained at the time, but couldn't imagine waiting around any more for our waitress to try to find a manager. Won't be back.

                                                                                                10. RO

                                                                                                  ROSCIBS105

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  33 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  33 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 15, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food3service2ambience3

                                                                                                  We were here on Feb 15. Still a set menu for Valentines Day. We had a reservation for 4 but they put 2 round tables of 2 together. Service was mediocre but waiter explained 2 kitchen staff had quit so they were shorthanded. We were patient but despite requests for more bread and butter it fell on deaf ears. Waiter tried to play everything off with humor but after a while it got old. Ive been here before and food and service was excellent. I’ll chalk it up to bad timing with holiday

                                                                                                11. M

                                                                                                  Metsfan86

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  30 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  4.0

                                                                                                  30 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 15, 2020

                                                                                                  overall4food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Good food as always

                                                                                                12. G

                                                                                                  Gardenlady

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  9 reviews

                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  9 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 15, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food4service2ambience1

                                                                                                  I will never make a reservation here for Valentine's Day again. It was way too crowded, frenetic and noisy and the staff, due to the fact that the restaurant was so busy, were overwhelmed. I went with 3 female friends and we had to sit at two round tables set up next to each other. Although we weren't looking to have a romantic evening, it was not a nice quiet, relaxing evening. I had a phone message the day before advising that we could only have 2 hrs since so many people were booked. I'd say way overbooked. Although no one rushed us--in fact we were ignored most of the time, which was very annoying. One friend's dinner came out lukewarm and had to be sent back. Her vegetables were mushy as well. Another friend said her St. Peter's fish was under seasoned and underwhelming. Another friend and I were happy with our dinners--eggplant parm and spaghetti--all of which came much later than people sitting near us who had come after we did at 7:00. No one came to see how our meal was and we were never offered parmesan cheese. We had to ask for it. I've eaten here many times and always had a wonderful experience, even more reason for our disappointment. When we left after 9:00 there was still quite a large group of people waiting to come in. Wonder how long they had been waiting?

                                                                                                13. JK

                                                                                                  JeffreyK

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  6 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  6 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 15, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food3service3ambience4

                                                                                                  Just don’t go on a holiday. Food and service not up to their normal standards

                                                                                                14. CM

                                                                                                  CarolynM

                                                                                                  Las Vegas

                                                                                                  12 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  12 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 14, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  As crowded as Valentine’s Day was ,Dan the manager keep everything moving smoothly

                                                                                                15. N

                                                                                                  Ny18

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  39 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  4.0

                                                                                                  39 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 14, 2020

                                                                                                  overall4food4service4ambience4

                                                                                                  Food very good risotto shrimp was excellent as well as baked clams. always a good experience even on a holiday.

                                                                                                16. OT

                                                                                                  OpenTable Diner

                                                                                                  Orlando

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on February 14, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience3

                                                                                                  Wonderful all around. Frank is amazing

                                                                                                17. MA

                                                                                                  MichelleA

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  3 reviews

                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  3 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 14, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food3service5ambience3

                                                                                                  Tomatoes and mozz app. Tomatoes were hard in the middle. No flavor. Had to ask for salt and pepper, server was very good. Service awesome as usual. Not thrilled with the menu. Def need raw oysters on Valentines day. Will def be back again. First issue ever. Had an early res.

                                                                                                18. JV

                                                                                                  JenniferV

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on February 14, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Food was absolutely amazing!!! Great flavor. Beat Italian food I’ve had in a long time

                                                                                                19. C

                                                                                                  Cotton

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  4 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  4 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 13, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  I was looking for a lunch time restaurant in that area to meet a friend 'half way' between our homes. I was a little nervous reading the various reviews, but decided to book Cafe Formaggio anyway. I was very pleasantly surprised. The restaurant wasn't too crowded at the time, so our Servers were very attentive, very friendly and accommodating They were able to adjust a menu item upon request. Price was extremely reasonable for the amount of food served. Would definitely go again and recommend to others.

                                                                                                20. b

                                                                                                  bigjoe68

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  16 reviews

                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  16 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 8, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food3service3ambience3

                                                                                                  ordered a Portobello mushroom/mozzarellIa/ tomato tower....arrived without the Portobello mushroom. Waited for a new one to be made. It was a Saturday night so rather noisey. On the pricey side

                                                                                                21. VO

                                                                                                  ValeryO

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  21 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  21 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 8, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service3ambience5

                                                                                                  As usual an excellent meal! Brought 3 friends who've never been there before and not a complaint about the food as expected!!!

                                                                                                22. S

                                                                                                  Scarredforlife

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  5 reviews

                                                                                                  1.0

                                                                                                  5 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 7, 2020

                                                                                                  overall1food1service1ambience5

                                                                                                  This is supposed to be a gf restaurant. My daughter got extremely sick from cross contamination. Very scary. 3 other people that went there on the same night ended up in the emergency room. I called restaurant and spoke to a manager named Lenny. He was very nice and extremely concerned about the situation. He offered to have us back and to treat us to a meal. It sounds wonderful but for my 8 year old with celiac it is terrifying. I am not sure we will return, I will have to see ...

                                                                                                23. N

                                                                                                  Nonni

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  23 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  23 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 6, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Food is so very good.. I have celiac and the gluten free choices are fantastic.

                                                                                                24. m

                                                                                                  michaelv

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  14 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  14 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 1, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food2service1ambience2

                                                                                                  Food was not good and the service was slow and inattentive. When we asked a server to somehow rectify a bad tasting salad it was totally ignored. The waiter who took our order was nowhere to be found to help us. Also, much too noisy

                                                                                                25. o

                                                                                                  oneoeleven

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  34 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  34 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on February 1, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Always great food !

                                                                                                26. PS

                                                                                                  PatS

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  12 reviews

                                                                                                  1.0

                                                                                                  12 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on January 31, 2020

                                                                                                  overall1food1service1ambience2

                                                                                                  service was lacking big time server was horrible food was not the same as we expect from Cafe Formaggio as we always loved in the past 2 out of 6 dinners were not exceptable Bread was burnt cheese was never brought to table for which we asked Drinks were not made correctly

                                                                                                27. D

                                                                                                  Dunnreview

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  14 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  14 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on January 28, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Food and service was excellent

                                                                                                28. C

                                                                                                  Citydiner

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  33 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  33 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on January 19, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Loved the gluten free menu, service was friendly and helpful and out gluten free guest commented that it was one of the best restaurants he’s been to!

                                                                                                29. R

                                                                                                  Rosebud

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  3.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on January 12, 2020

                                                                                                  overall3food5service5ambience3

                                                                                                  Very safe for gluten free dining and great food. Very noisy but there was a huge kids party going on.

                                                                                                30. OT

                                                                                                  OpenTable Diner

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  7 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  7 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on January 12, 2020

                                                                                                  overall5food5service3ambience5

                                                                                                  Being that I have to eat gluten free because of me having celiac disease Cafe formaggio is my go to place and it never fails me.

                                                                                                31. VL

                                                                                                  VincentL

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  4.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on January 5, 2020

                                                                                                  overall4food5service3ambience5

                                                                                                  The appetizers were really good and the veal oso buco was very good. Everyone enjoyed the food and they do not rush you.

                                                                                                32. DW

                                                                                                  DonW

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  32 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  4.0

                                                                                                  32 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on January 5, 2020

                                                                                                  overall4food4service3ambience3

                                                                                                  Good menu, the evening we went the street were much delayed for no apparent reason. Food was good when received. Service was very good.

                                                                                                33. f

                                                                                                  funtimes

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  24 reviews

                                                                                                  4.0

                                                                                                  24 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on January 5, 2020

                                                                                                  overall4food4service4ambience4

                                                                                                  The service and food was excellent. The gluten free menu was also excellent! Highly recommended:)

                                                                                                34. P

                                                                                                  Pamela

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on December 31, 2019

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  New Year’s Eve

                                                                                                35. j

                                                                                                  jeannef

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  2 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  2 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on December 31, 2019

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  New Years Eve. Delicious but extra pricey compared to a regular night.

                                                                                                36. l

                                                                                                  love2eat

                                                                                                  Orlando

                                                                                                  10 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  10 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on December 31, 2019

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  New Year’s Eve

                                                                                                37. T

                                                                                                  Tom1959

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on December 28, 2019

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience4

                                                                                                  Excellent food and Service. I really enjoy this place. (The wine could be better for the price per bottle)

                                                                                                38. LL

                                                                                                  LoriL

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  1 review

                                                                                                  Dined on December 22, 2019

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Pasta Fagioli was the best I've had since my Italian mother-in-law passed away. Tried it at many other restaurants and none has come close to hers until I tried it here.

                                                                                                39. OT

                                                                                                  OpenTable Diner

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  2 reviews

                                                                                                  vip
                                                                                                  1.0

                                                                                                  2 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on December 22, 2019

                                                                                                  overall1food1service4ambience3

                                                                                                  Don't go here if you are a vegetarian. There is chicken broth in all the sauces except for the garlic and oil. They finally agreed to make a plain sauce, which I had to plead for... But first they said no, despite me sharing this was done for me previously.... After a lot back and forth they agreed and bright something but it was nasty. My boyfriend ate while I watched. I left starving. Not a good night.

                                                                                                40. S

                                                                                                  Simicro77

                                                                                                  New York Area

                                                                                                  19 reviews

                                                                                                  5.0

                                                                                                  19 reviews

                                                                                                  Dined on December 21, 2019

                                                                                                  overall5food5service5ambience5

                                                                                                  Food was great! Especially the spicy calamari, mussels, and salmon cavatelli - will return soon!

                                                                                                FAQs

                                                                                                Cafe Formaggio is rated 4.3 stars by 112 OpenTable diners

                                                                                                Permanently Closed

                                                                                                This restaurant is permanently closed.

                                                                                                Become an Insider

                                                                                                Gain access to exclusive offers, best-of lists, local events & more (you can unsubscribe any time).

                                                                                                • Privacy Policy
                                                                                                • Terms of Use
                                                                                                • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
                                                                                                • Do Not Sell My Info (California)
                                                                                                Copyright © 2021 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
                                                                                                OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
                                                                                                Booking LogoPriceline LogoKAYAK LogoAgoda LogoRentalcars LogoOpenTable Logo