Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore
The Butera’s kitchen, since it’s inception in Massapequa 1991 to present day Bay Shore , has and still does offer traditional rustic Italian cuisine with a modern flair alongside unique specials showcasing authentic ingredients and locally sourced products.
The Butera’s family relishes the opportunity to begin a new chapter in Bay Shore, and wants nothing more than to serve and delight the community for years to come.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
WAITERS AND WAITRESSES WERE MOST CODIAL AND MADE SURE WE HAD WHAT WE NEEDED!
Love this restaurant! We were celebrating my son’s birthday! The Thai calamari appetizer special was awesome as was the butternut squash salad with arugula and prosciutto. There were 4 in our party and we each thoroughly enjoyed our entrees. I had the chicken meatball scarpariello was outstanding with sausage potatoes and peppers. The fettuccine with lobster reduction and shrimp was creamy and delicious and not over powering. What was especially nice was that the chef owner came by our table a few times to check in and make suggestions as well as answer questions. This is our new go to place!!!
Really good meal and I can't wait to eat the leftovers!
We love this restaurant! From the big welcome at the front desk right through dessert this place is a class act. Matt makes us feel so welcome. Service is always good and the food is wonderful. Tonight we ordered the Tuna, Rigatoni with short rib ragu and the eggplant entree. All were delicious and perfectly cooked. Our waitress Stephanie checked on us frequently and the owner even came over to make sure we were happy. The tables are spaced well so even though they were busy we were happy with the distance between us and the nearest people. We had a great experience and will be back soon.
Food was amazing! Had the ricotta appetizer which was off the charts! Will definitely be back!
The food is always delicious with enough to bring home and enjoy the next day!
Sam our waitress was excellent. The meal and deserts were very well prepared
We enjoyed our meals. It was very loud where we wretched seated
Good food with great choices on the menu.
My husband ordered the steak and said it was tough. He didn’t like the clams either because they had too much bread. The unfortunate thing about this experience is that the waitress dropped sauce from my pasta dish on my husband’s jeans. She apologized but that was it. My husband didn’t eat another bite. Very upsetting that no one came over and acknowledged what happened.
Always a delicious meal with attention to detail when combining assorted flavors. The vegetables taste garden fresh. I will be back soon!
Great food and service from the appetizers to the entrees. Can’t wait to go back.
Nice atmosphere. Crowded for a Thursday night ‘ale reservations
Food was great, had the delicious fresh ricotta app which is a favorite as well as the fried mozzarella and baked clams all prepared perfectly.
There were six of us and every entree was great. I had the veal and it was delicious. Martin, the owner/chef came to our table twice to check on us which was very nice.
Always a good meal when I eat there!
Had a hard time finding a parking space. It was very loud almost unbearable in the dining room. Food, service, value were excellent!!
The best Italian restaurant on Long Island. Great food, friendly service, and very clean.
Service was very good food was tasty nice atmosphere
We've eaten at Butera's in Oakdale before; this was our first time in Bayshore. Somewhat different atmosphere, but same quality of service, friendliness and quality of food. Our meal was excellent, price reasonable and large portion enabled use to take food home.
Food was fabulous enjoyed the meal waitress wasn’t very friendly could have have come to the table a little bit more I felt she favored other tables more.
I'm not from the area and was looking for a great place to eat. When looking at the restaurants rated 4.5 and above I found that most had disappointing reviews. When I reached Butera's , all were good, so we selected it..... We were not disappointed the server was friendly and knowledgeable, she knew all the dishes and had tasted them all. My partner asked if they could modify the alfredo and add shrimp, the quick answer was of course how many shrimp would you like. I had the chicken picatta style and it was the best I've had. Apple crisp desert was amazing. If you are in Bay Shore make sure that you visit this restaurant you won't be disappointed.
James server outstanding!!
The Veal dishes are to die for 😋
Pork chops are AMAZING!
Awesome spot for a date night. Ambiance outside is amazing!
Dana is the best waitstaff we have ever had serve us! All the staff is attentive and the food is expertly prepared and absolutely delicious!
Great food great service never disappoints! Highy recommend!!
Been here before. Food is great, staff friendly and the place is clean. If your looking for a great dining experience go to Buteras.
Good atmosphere, delicious food and great service! Our waiter was very attentive and timed our meal from drinks to appetizers, meals and coffee perfectly. The chef brought out our meal which was a nice touch and the food was absolutely delicious. Coming back!!
We went to dinner both to congratulate my mother on a promotion and my brother's bon voyage before he moved abroad. It was the perfect last family meal all together. It was a beautiful experience from start to finish. The food was the BEST. Fresh and cooked perfectly. The owner came out and introduced himself and talked to us for a bit which was lovely. Seating was quick, the table was beautiful. Service was amazing. We got water and bread as soon as we sat down. Waitress was wonderful, attentive, friendly and knowledgeable. Busser's were even great. Everything was perfect. I recommend for every occasion and no occasion.
Always dependable. Love eating at Butera's. The lunch is especially good value.
Great, going back soon. Food was delicious, service was great.
Great birthday dinner! Excellent service, deliciously different Italian food!
Wonderful meal! Exceptional service and a great night out. Second time we've eaten at Buteras in Bayshore and we'll be back again.
Great food and great service! Atmosphere is great! Can’t wait till we go back!
Our Daughters Birthday. Service and the food were excellent!
Noice level exceeded comfort - very difficult to have a normal conversation during the dinner
The service was very nice and the waiting for food was on time.
The service and food were excellent. The entire experience was great.
Great food, nice ambience and staff. Highly recommend!
It was great- excellent main courses, the Sunday salad and the tortufo was perfect. We will be back.
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 328-4948.
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is rated 4.8 stars by 325 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.