Brooklyn Cafe is always consistently good in both its food and service. They have great specials as well as a nice variety of items on their regular menu. I love the hickory smoked salmon appetizer, which I usually get as an entree and start with the Asian salad. The salad is nice and light and pairs well with just about anything. The salmon could have used a little more flavoring on this particular night, but was still very good. One of our diners had the fish special, which looked (and she said was) fantastic. It was steelhead trout accompanied by two large shrimp and some lovely tomatoes. Servers are friendly and attentive - all in all a great dining experience!
Although the chops were outstanding, the rice was served cold and tasteless. A disappointment as have frequented this restaurant often.
As always, fabulous!
We visited on a Wednesday night. It was very busy. We had a 20 minute wait even with a reservation. But it was no issue; we enjoyed a glass of wine at the bar. At our table, we shared lobster bisque and fig and walnut salad then each had crab cake salad. It was devine. They are expanding their space which will improve the ambiance and reduce noise level. But I don’t care. Until the new additional space is ready I can easily endure a little noise to get to enjoy their wonderful foods, wine and nice, friendly service.
We have been to Brooklyn Café many times in the past but this time we were so disappointed. We had a 7:30 pm reservation on a Wednesday and we arrived early but had to wait 20 minutes past our reserved time. The food was ok but they never change the menu and my crab cake looked like mush even though it tasted ok. Then they sat us by the rest rooms in a corner and had wait staff and patrons constantly walking past us. It was horrible. We wont go back even though they are expanding their space and will soon be a larger restaurant. I don't see them making any money after the way we were treated.
This is one of our favorite neighborhood restaurants. It never disappoints!
We had a wonderful waiter, delicious wine, yummy fish tacos, and perfect coffee!
Excellent service and delicious lunch choices. We were seated in covered balcony area which at times was very drafty and noisy. Otherwise, very enjoyable.
This is my most favorite place in Atlanta to eat. Food is consistently excellent; service is better than excellent; wine is the best selection in Atlanta; and Jeff Trump, albeit a modest owner, is one of the charitable and generous people I know. He brought me food which I had chemotherapy!!!
We love this place! I suggest a stop every time we are in Sandy Springs. The avocado egg rolls and steak salad are two of my favorites.
Unfortunately the excessive noise canceled our enjoyment of the excellent food. The proximity of the tables tended to void the fine service provided by our waitress. If I had been a food critic I would have given the food and service an A and the ambiance a D.
Our meal was very good. I was slightly disappointed in my steak salad. The last time I had this the filet was thick and juicy. This time, while still tasty, the meat was thin and over cooked.
Great service & Great food.
We have dined at Brooklyn Cafe for several years and it has consistently delivered wonderful service, delicious food and provided a lovely dining experience. We were so happy to see they are in the process of expanding into the space next door. Love Brooklyn Cafe!
The crab cakes here are delish!!! Service is excellent, one of our favorites!
I’ve been here three time and love it more with each visit. The food, drinks, and service were amazing!! It’s definitely a local gem.
Wonderful experience!!!! Our Transylvanian waitress was wonderful!!!
Our food and service were excellent. We chose the porch for a quieter dinner. The steak salad was a big hit!
Brooklyn Cafe is my go to spot to meet people who's office is in Sandy Springs or near GA-400. This place is incredibly good and very consistent. Most people have never heard of it, but it's been there for 20+ years. Great wait staff and owners.
Always a great experience both in food, bar scene and service
Fabulous and reasonable wine list
Our regular Go To place for a great meal
Service less than expected
Food excellent as always. Noise level louder than usual. Very crowded for Friday night.
Great wait staff. Delicious food. Wonderful experience.
Dined during lunch. Seated right away. Service was attentive. Ordered the scallop salad (yum!) and the crab cake salad (the best in town - - no filler) A++
There were 4 of us, we are older and seated near the bar. We could not hear each other so should have asked for another table.
A sure thing. Consistently great!
Waite staff there are great. They all help each other and it makes for such a smooth and easy meat.
Had not been here in many years. Pleasantly surprised!
Will be returning b
It was really great being a part of an atmosphere where they treat you like family. The service was great and the food was amazing! Definitely worth the drive.
The service is always prompt and friendly. Many servers have worked there a long time so we know each other's faces. The grilled lobster and shrimp special is my favorite, but I also love many of the starters and entrees on the regular menu.
My wife and I celebrated Valentine's and had a wonderful time. Good food and better service. Our waitress was fun and helped us make great choices for our dinner. We will go back!!
My new favorite dish in Atlanta. The lamb chops are absolutely amazing but on top of the taste the portion size is unbelievable.....5 chops for $26.00. By far the best I have ever had.
Very long wait even though we had a reservation. About 12 people came in at the same time & it was pretty chaotic - no proper check in process.
Waited 30 minutes & grabbed a glass of wine at the bar
It’s been some time since we ate here - the wait was worth it!!
Amazing food - the special was Ribs & probably the best we’ve ever had
We also had AMAZING lamb chops - switched out the sides for mash & green beans. Cooked to perfection & delicious.
The wine selection is pretty good too & reasonably priced
We will be back
Brooklyn Cafe Is just the best. Food quality always excellent. Staff is just awesome. Our favorite!
As always...great food...great service......cozy spot to dine. Nights can be a little noisy......
Another wonderful birthday lunch at Brooklyn Cafe! Wonderful service from Sam. We thoroughly enjoyed the crab cake salad and grilled artichoke hearts. The only disappointment was with my leftovers. I ate less than half of my meal so I asked the server to box up my meal. I was disappointed to see, when I got home, that maybe 1 tablespoon of the crab cake was there. If you take food home, box it yourself. This is my favorite neighborhood restaurant and I look forward to returning.
I am so glad I chose Brooklyn Cafe for a luncheon with friends. The food and service were wonderful, and their crab cakes are even better than those I have had in Maryland. My friends were all delighted with this restaurant!
I was great to experience the service and the food again ... it was excellent!!!!