Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes
No fillers and gluten free! With whole grain mustard sauce and green beans
Crab Cake Salad
jumbo lump crab cake, with whole grain mustard sauce, tomato and greens
Boneless Braised Short Ribs
Very tender! With amazing carrots and mashed potatoes
As to be expected, amazing service and delicious food!
We always enjoyed BC in the past. but was a bit disappointed on our last visit.
Always an outstanding experience. Try the smoked trout dip - I rarely see / hear others ordering this appetizer. It’s really good. I always get the Awesome Fish sandwich for lunch. I’ve had it dozens of times - awesome every time.
The food is excellent, if you can find a parking place to get inside. The parking is extremely limited.
Ate on outside patio...lovely! Great service and delicious food!
This has always been my favorite getaway for a nice quiet dinner and drink. I travel an hour each way just to dine here at least twice a month.
Love this restaurant!
Their crab cake salad is outstanding! Be sure to make a reservation
Same ole menu with boring sides. Think BC needs to update the menu. They do have a good selection of wines!
Brooklyn Cafe has always been a favorite - it never wavers, always interesting choices, a couple of specials each time I have been. The service, whether it is during lunch or dinner, is top-notch. Our server Monday night was so personable, timed his stops at the table perfectly and we never felt rushed. We had two over the top delicious appetizers and split the crab cake dinner. I have been fortunate to have traveled often and widely...by far the best crab cakes ever - and GF which I am~ that means, no fillers!
If you have never been, I recommend it highly! OH, their bottles of wine are priced fairly.
Wonderful ladies luncheon outside on a beautiful sunny day!
I get the crab cake salad every single time I go and I’ve never been disappointed!
Best crab cake anywhere!
Solid, but not outstanding, dining experience. I've been coming here for many years and it's a Sandy Springs institution and deservedly so, but this was not their best night. It started with the worst table in the house in the hall back by the server's area, but it was a last minute reservation so maybe they get a pass on that one - at least it was quiet. Fried green tomato app was not as good as most. Smoke salmon was tasty. Short ribs were pretty good. My son's "medium rare" filet was undercooked and still mooing, but he ate it all anyway and said it was good. The reuben got a good review from my other son. Desserts were average. Decent enough meal, but not deserving of the 5 stars the place seems to usually get,
Usually my favorite restaurant. This time I ordered the trout which wasn't to my liking. Probably my fault since I don't usually like blackened fish
Always excellent. Great neighborhood restaurant.
I had the Lobster enchiladas. They were so delicious. My husband had trout. This was an extremely good dinner for both of us!
We come here frequently. It is one of our go to places in the neighborhood.
Almost never disappoints!
We were seated in a very bad place...next to area where waiters pick up the food. After 10 minutes, no waiter came to our table. We finally had to stop the hostess to get someone to pay attention to us. After awhile, someone did come over though he said he wasn’t `our waiter. Very frustrating! Though the food was good, it will be a long time before we return. We saw other people being served...not us.
Always love Brooklyn Cafe but have been twice recently and they don't come around at the end to refill coffee. IF they did that would make it 5*
This place is consistently great. Their menu is limited, but the burgers and fish are perfectly prepared. The waitstaff are friendly and helpful. Don’t be turned off because of the parking situation as there is additional free parking across the street.
Consistent quality and service .. great value
Excellent food- crab cakes are all crab no filler and a great sauce on top! The special was Haddock and it was also excellent and cooked to perfection. Excellent meal and the starter was trout dip that was outstanding!!
Great crab cakes and outstanding service by Brittany
Excellent service. Lobster salad was phenomenal.
Always a great meal - great to see all of the returning customers!!!
Our family has been enjoying Brooklyn Cafe through their additions, now Covid and their
signature specials and quality menu have never wavered in flavor or presentation. The staff are attentive. The menu is varied so there should be some offering that would
please most diners.
We were on the patio but it was closed and person at table next to us was on their speaker phone for about 5-7 minutes. Definitely a bit annoying but certainly not Brooklyn Cafe's fault. Do wish an employee or manager would have asked them to put their phone away.
Wonderful as always...Brooklyn Cafe is one of our favorites 👍
We enjoyed a delicious dinner at Brooklyn Cafe including a nice bottle of Pinot Noir with great service and a really good value in a safe environment.
I was interested to try this restaurant as I’ve heard good things about it and it has quite a following. I was told the crab cakes were their specialty. I ordered the crab cake platter and was quite disappointed. There were two cakes...ok but one was served broken in half on a plate together with a dozen or so overcooked string beans. The combo of a white plate, essentially pale crab cakes and a few beans made the presentation a big meh. For $34, it should at least have included a starch or some slaw.
I really wanted to like the Brooklyn Cafe but I was sorely disappointed.
Our first visit here. Menu was awesome. Our waiter, Kevin, was very helpful in describing menu, offering suggestions. Loved all 3 dishes out table had! Creole chicken was delicious. Look forward to our next visit.
Excellent, as always. Was able to dine in the most recently expanded seating area. Very nice.
Always Delicious food and great service
Love Brooklyn Cafe every time!
My weekly trip to my favorite local eatery. The staff is always so friendly and attentive . And the food is just wonderful. So happy they have made it through these tuff times with covid and will be with us for years to come.
Please bring back the ribs, both beef and pork!
This is one of my go to spots to take friends because I know the food and service will excellent. This time was no exception. This was my forts time sitting outside. And every though we sat right by the entrance/exit. It was not uncomfortable with people passing by.
I love having lunch with my daughter here. We always enjoy the delicious food and great service!
Service was very slow
We had a reservation for over a week but they were slammed meaning busy so could not seat us. We added a person as well! They were very gracious and offered us a complimentary appetizer which was so nice!!! Excellent service ! Food was delicious !! Very pleased!Excellent!!
Amazing food. Lauren and Keith were wonderful.
Brooklyn Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (404) 843-8377.
Brooklyn Cafe is rated 4.8 stars by 2694 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.