Brooklyn and The Butcher
Online reservations book your table for 2 hours. If you plan to visit with us longer, please contact the restaurant directly to make special arrangements.
Book through Open Table, or call us at (812) 590-2646.
We hope to see you soon!
Brooklyn and the Butcher
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Butcher's Steak Tartare
Pickled spring onion, citrus zest, black truffle vinaigrette
The Butcher's Board
Rotating chef's whim
What a great experience. Food was exceptional and so was the service. Would drive out of my way to enjoy it again.
We love to eat here. The food is delicious and the service is wonderful.
The food was excellent and the service from Emily was divine! Our drinks were perfect! Thanks for having us for brunch.
The food, service, and setting were all amazing! My husband and I will definitely be back!
Great atmosphere and delicious food. I highly recommend.
Excellent food and excellent service. The filet is well over priced compared to the competition (Jeff Ruby’s, Ruth’s Chris). Won’t order it again, but will definitely be back for the salmon, sides and service.
Absolutely as great experience and meal. The atmosphere was over the top and service superb!
Crazy loud, but the best steak I've ever had. Good cocktails.
Great food and great service! Prices are very reasonable.
Wonderful bar and cocktails. Great food but a bit over seasoned/heavy. Excellent cook on steaks. Staff is very friendly/fun and cheerful, a bit inexperienced but doesnt hinder the your dining experience. Great for a night away from the kids, big private tables!
The food was delicious and great friendly staff.
Very nice atmosphere and good service.
The food was very good.
This has been our favorite upscale,local restaurant. The food is always delicious. Our server Amanda went above and beyond to provide excellent service.
Amazing food, Amazing experience! Chef Ming continues to create an experience, not just a meal!
Every time we have been to Brooklyn & the Butcher has been exceptional and this was no exception. Delicious food, beautiful ambiance, fantastic people. Highly recommend!!!
The “filet mignon” had fat running through it and the texture was spongy. Terrible. Bordelaise sauce was liquid salt for $6 or $7.00. The crabmeat dip appetizer had zero crabmeat.
We have eaten here three times now (once dinner and twice brunch) and it has been amazing every time. The bananas foster french toast is a must for brunch and so is the lobster bisque soup! Restaurant is sparking clean and the service is always top notch!!
Food was delicious and the server Jacob was great!!!!
Everything was delicious. We had everything from the burger to filets, all wonderful. The baseball cut steaks were tender and delicious, the lobster bisque was flavorful and full of lobster chunks, the brussels sprouts were so delicious we had to add an extra order.
The mac and cheese wasn't as cheesy as we'd hope but still tasted good.
Our server was great. Will definitely return.
Everything was fantastic and we will definitely be back!
We sat outside and had the most lovely dinner and evening. Love the new updates!
Thank you so much for the visit and kind words! Hope to see you again soon!
Highly recommend! Food was amazing and service was even better.
Great to hear! Will pass along your compliments to the staff! Cheers!
Always a wonderful experience. Food fantastic. Especially if you are a steak eater which I am not but everyone else raved. Brussels wonderful. Quaint bar area. Historical old hotel. Service really good.
Thank you for your review- we love our corner in downtown, historic New Albany! Come back again soon!
Top notch service & food as always. Our server Kristyn was excellent!
Will pass along your sentiment to Kristyn, she will be delighted to hear! Come back again soon!
Food was amazing as always. The muscles are the best I’ve every had. Waiter took great care of us.
We had the best time celebrating our anniversary! Our server Brice was stellar and they even had a nice note congratulating us on our anniversary waiting on the table when we arrived. The food was top notch from start to finish and the drinks were spot on. We will absolutely continue to make the trip from Louisville to dine at Brooklyn & The Butcher. Thank you so much, Nikki & Ian for making our night one to remember!!
Thank you for your kind words - will pass along to Bryce! Cheers!
Have heard good things about your evening meals. Brunch was not good. Have heard that now from others too. Hash browns were terrible, funny taste. Bacon was greasy. Sausage was not good at all.
We did have the crab dip and that was very good.
Great food. Definitely be back
Excellent spot for a wonderful fine dining experience! Worth your visit.
Over priced food and steak was over cooked and asparagus was undercooked. Was not worth $149 for two people.
Everything was on point from service to food. We were celebrating our anniversary and we were allowed to relax and enjoy the evening.
Worth the price! Amazing! Can’t get enough of the butcher!
The food was great, the service was great and the establishment was great.
Definitely will be returning
Food and service was wonderful as usual!!
Food was great! The filet was to die for!! Would come back again, maybe next week
The service and ambiance were great. Food was very good. We will definitely be back.
The ahi tuna tartare is amazing! Our steaks were prepared perfectly medium.
Food was seriously below average for what I expected to be a remarkable experience, very disappointed.
Food was out of this world worth everything we paid
We have been to this restaurant twice and have loved it both times. The lobster bisque, cocktails, steak, pork chops all amazing! Try the cocktail with aquafaba, it is so good! Our only complaint was that our chocolate cake was a little dry. Wait staff was very attentive and friendly!
You can order delivery directly from Brooklyn and The Butcher using the Order Online button. Brooklyn and The Butcher also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (812) 590-2646.
Brooklyn and The Butcher is rated 4.8 stars by 1647 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.