Brooklyn and The Butcher
Book through open table, or call us at (812) 590-2646.
We hope to see you soon!
Brooklyn and the Butcher
Always a great experience, never disappoints. Best oysters, best steak in town! Would put them up against anyone. Keep up the great work. Would recommend to anyone
Food was excellent and the atmosphere was great. I had the filet brussel sprouts and French onion soup. It was all so good.
Great food, great service! Would recommend to anyone looking for something special.
Great food and service steak was awesome my wife got salmon and she really enjoy it the restaurant was right downtown new Albany
Great food in an interesting setting. Would recommend.
This was my second time at the restaurant and my wife's first. The food was amazing. I love the fact that they wait to bring out each course so that it is super fresh when you get it. They pay attention to detail and it shows in both their service and their food. Our waitress (not sure of her name, but she had pink hair) was great. She definitely deserves a raise!!! We will definitely be making the trip back to New Albany to eat at Brooklyn and The Butcher again!!!
We had a very nice dinner experience - good food and service. At our request our server was very nice about relocating us to a quieter table. We will go back.
Always a nice and knowledgeable staff. I love going to the Brooklyn and the butcher
Very good food and service would most definitely recommend
Food was absolutely excellent. Service was very friendly, very attentive, and very knowledgeable about the menu choices. Ambiance was great - very modern with a rustic flair, noise level was low. Yes, it is expensive, but the food served matched the price value. Alcoholic beverages were also on point, with house made sour and finely selected wines.
Will return excellent place for a special night out!
DELISH FOOD, fabulous waitress, wonderful time!!!!!!
Steak was ok. Cooked perfectly but under seasoned. A little salt and pepper were needed. Also toigher than a $50 steak should be. Asparagus was cold and smothered in too much balsamic. My wife thoroughly enjoyed hers so all was not lost. I wouldn't go again unless the wife asked. Also they charged me more for my draft beer than it was listed on their draft menu for but they charged me less for the wine than what it was listed for. It evened out so I didn't complain but made it look to me like they don't have their stuff together very well.
Every single thing we got was absolutely fantastic, from drinks to dessert. The service was also outstanding.
Hair in food. Way too expensive. Seating was too close together. Couldn’t even hear eachother. Bad.
Our server Igor was absolutely top notch. A+
One of the best meals I’ve ever experienced. Certainly will be returning often.
Food and drink was about what I expected. It was nice...an average over priced steakhouse. The service was absolutely outstanding. That's what would make me want to come back !!
I know this place can get crowded and noisy on a weekend or holiday and I did wait quite a long time for a table and food and drinks one busy Saturday. This time we went on a Thursday and it was quieter and much quicker service.
All the food was top notch and had a pleasant time.
Great place! The steak was fantastic! Our server was great!
B&B is the fine dining in New Albany, and has given local businesses a nice venue for a good steak. The hostesses as well as our server, Darrian, were really nice people providing great service. The bartender was very helpful, and everyone there seemed to like their workplace, the culture is good. Thank you!
Steaks were a disappointment. One was so salty it was difficult to eat; the other was terribly overdone. Friends had a seafood tower and it was good.
Server was very friendly but slow to return to table for order and drink refills .
Crab legs were amazing and so was the service!!!
We will definitely be returning soon!
We had our cousin come in from out of town. We had wanted to go to Jeff Ruby's but the NCAA games were that night and we didn't want to fight traffic in downtown Louisville. Had a reservation at 8:15. Walked in and the host said our table wasn't ready but we could order a drink at the bar. Had 2-3 servers at the bar and waited 15 minutes for a drink. Kept getting ignored so we didn't get a drink and ended up walking back to the front to be seated. At 8:35 our table still wasn't ready. They said they could seat us right away in the speakeasy downstairs. Failed to mention that literally no one else was eating down there. It was just the 3 of us in an empty room. Felt like we were forgotten about a few times. Long waits in between courses. Our waiter was nice. Just a super weird experience being the only person in a room and feeling like you're the only people in the entire restaurant. The food was good but for the money and the atmosphere you can't beat Jeff Ruby's. We ended up paying around the same price and the steaks were definitely not the same.
We had been here before and had a great time so maybe this was just an off night. I am sure we will give Brooklyn and the Butcher one more shot.
We've been several times, love the food! This time our servers name was Brian, he was great, very knowledgeable, took good care of us. There are two things I would change, better lighting and a little less noise.
Igor was phenomenal, as usual. We enjoy him so much and he adds to the whole experience! Food was delicious and prepared perfectly. Can’t wait to dine here again.
Very nice place. Excellent setting for date night.
The food was amazing and the service was incredible.
Very impressed by this place and will definitely be back
Great location and nicely appointed with a great staff. Food is solid as is the mixologist. I will be back.
My husband and I love this restaurant for our date nights. This visit our server was very slow. The food was good. We will definitely be back in the future
Amazing atmosphere, delicious food!
This was our first time here. Had heard excellent reviews and the experience did not disappoint. The Steakhouse salad and Wedge salad were nothing short of excellent. The Blue Cheese dressing was outstanding had a touch of spice and complimented the smoked tomatoes. Our steaks were done to our liking and very flavorful.
The house Cabernet was amazing as well.
Great service - our server was very informative and very attentive.
Server was great but steaks mediocre, they were tough considering the price. They were curtious in making the steak right but the wait to receive the amended dinner was not acceptable, rest of party was finished long before they returned with the meal. The staff was very friendly and curtious but the whole experience was very overrated.
I would recommend this as a one time thing. The food was not bad, but there aren't many "normal" options. Definitely not for one on a budget as $9 for a salad (that would come with a meal most anywhere else) is just a bit much. Our waitress was awesome.
The food was amazing, however the service was extremely slow. It appeared as if our server had the entire dining room. When he was able to attend to us he was very courteous and professional. The meal took three hours due to the spacing of the courses. We have been here several times and never experienced this type of delay.
Took her family out for a celebration food was wonderful and Service always impeccable our server was Bradley but all those servers are wonderful I have a great bar wine tasting I am food love this place
We had an 8:30 reservation and was seated promptly. However the food was horrible our steaks had little to no seasoning and was not cooked as ordered after asking for A1 I then waited 30 more minutes for the waiter to bring it which by that time my husband had finished eating and my food was cold. The Lobster Mac N Cheese was dried out and lacking the cheese I expected a lot more since it was $10 extra. We didn’t receive the bread until 45mins after arriving and it was hard. I am so upset becaus this was a $97 dinner that was money wasted which would have only been $40 at Texas Roadhouse and would taste 10x better.
My family and I had a great time at the restaurant—we wanted to have a leisurely meal and that’s what our sever, Lauren, provided for us. Grey place for special occasions😊
This was our first visit. We had been wanting to try it. Awesome!!! Well please with our overall dining experience. Service was top notch. Our meal was amazing.
One of our party is mobility limited and the staff went out of their way to make our visit easy and comfortable.
The restoration of the building is to period, classic and vintage. Well done.