Brendan’s Catch 23 is 5 star on so many levels. From the service to the food to the overall atmosphere. I’ve never had a bad experience or meal. Chef Ray is amazing and his food to absolutely phenomenal. Whether your looking for a night out or visiting from out of town l, I’d recommend Brendan’s wholeheartedly to anyone looking for a recommendation.

First time trying this restaurant. My wife and I attended for our anniversary. Food was some of the best I’ve ever had. The service on the other hand was terrible. Waited for more ice water, server seemed completely uninterested and more focused on bigger party tables (which is understandable to an extent). Once our food got to the table no one came to check in and see if we needed anything. I don’t ask for much when I’m at a restaurant. But if I’m spending $150+ on a meal, I shouldn’t have to hunt someone down for a glass of water. Loved the ambiance and everything else about this establishment. The service really did put a damper on the night.

Truly fantastic experience and amazing food

Birthday celebration

Our experience started off well and then went down hill. Our server had tables all over the restaurant and we felt forgotten about often. After an hour and a half, we still didn’t have our entrees. When the server did come back, she never asked if we wanted another drink. When she finally did, by the time she brought it I was done with my meal. I personally thought the price points were a bit high for the ambiance and quality of food. All in all, not bad but not great.

This place is great! The service manager, Mike, made us feel right at home!

The call Only complaint I had was them not answering the phone. Even after it was open no one answered the phone. We were starting to think it Wasn’t open due to covid. My wife said we should ride by there. When we git there it lioked like it wasclosed because it’s all boarded up. We called again, no answer. I decided to walk up there And it was open. Probably losing a lot of business by not answering the phone.

It was great!

Very welcoming and worth the visit for people out of town! Can’t go wrong with any food options! The server was very good as well!

Our waiter was amazing. Please bring back the smoked salmon spread it was to die for.

Delicious seafood prepared well. Service exceptional. It is on the pricey side, however.

Excellent service and incredible food. Worth the price.

We had excellent service and an excellent meal. Would highly recommend.

Chef's Table and the waitress were fantastic. Service was top notch. Food was absolutely devine. Dessert was delicious too.

Absolutely best meal we have ever had (and we eat WELL). Crab legs were phenomenal, excellent calamari & our server was super attentive & courteous. Place was exceptionally clean & all staff were masked & gloved the entire time. Highly recommend if you're looking for a 5 star experience at a lower price!

Great food and service our host was very professional

Amazing food and very good service from the host to the server. If in the area will be back.

Food was excellent and the service was exceptional. Will be returning again for sure!

Special shout-out to our host/waiter, AJ: thanks for making my wife’s birthday great!

Andrew made our Anniversary dinner extra special. He was very courteous and attentive. I enjoyed the sea bass taste was outstanding. Only reason I gave 4 stars was,I personally did not care for the side that came with it. Although I loved all the ingredients there was a taste I didn't care for. Our other meal was the crab cakes. This entre was amazing Asparagus amazing mashed were flavorful. Cornbread yum! Thanks for a great evening. Will be back.

Impeccable service, selection, and of course food to die for. I had Chilean sea bass and my wife had filet mignon, both of which were perfect. We really enjoyed the cornbread and truffle fries as well. Cocktails are also a real treat. Prepare to spend some money, but if you’re going to pay that much for a meal you seriously might as well do it here. 5 stars.

Awesome service

This is our second time dining at Brandon's and it won't be the last. Everything about our experience was incredible. One of the tops in Louisville!

The food was delicious. The service first class. We would go back again frequently if we lived in Louisville.

The food was very tasty! Our waiter was very knowledgeable and friendly.

Phenomenal experience! Great food and excellent service!!

Highly recommended. Service and food were impeccable.

Disappointed in the food quality as it was not flavorful . Shrmp and grits was greasy and steak needed more season inspite of it being marinated for 36 hours.

Incredible dinner combining bourbon tasting, food and wine. Sonya, our server, was outstanding. It’s our new Louisville favorite!

Fantastic service by AJ. Food was phenomenal, particularly the “arancini”. Drinks were also amazing. Overall experience was better than 10 out of 10.

Our Waiter/Hostess AJ gave superior above and beyond service. When u go ask to sit in AJ section, I guarantee you will not be disappointed. This was our 1st time being there and he made you feel like you were family. Thanks AJ for making us feel very special on our Anniversary. The food was fantastic and they made sure that you were taken care of. My husband steak fell over in fish oil while the chef was cutting it and they made sure to tell us ASAP of what was going on. The manager came to apologize and gave us a drink on the house. In my book that is more than 5 star quality.

One of my favorite restaurants! Always great service.

Wonderful meal and ambiance. Service slowed a bit after apps and drinks were delivered. Overall great!

I have heard and known about Brendon’s Catch 23 for a while but never had the opportunity to go. Everything was amazing! Our server was very patient, attentive, and so sweet. So happy I chose there for my Birthday dinner.

First time here and it did not disappoint! It was amazing!

The crab in a jar is a must-the service is incredible-and all the food is great!

Food was delicious as always along with the drinks. Just miss the stuffed chicken breast and crab corn chowder

This was my first visit. We were given an option on seating which was great. Our server was sweet and knowledgeable. Our food was fine. I personally wasn’t a fan of the ambiance. I ordered the special of the day and it came out cooked perfectly.

Love Love this spot I will always support this business

Tuna was not cooked to liking and wasn't eaten at all and they wouldn't take it off the bill. TOTALLY NOT WORTH THE MONEY, oysters were just okay, have had better at Mitchell's.

Food was good service was nice everything the server recommended was excellent .