Food was mediocre at best for a seafood place they completely overcooked the fish. Staff seemed like they were all hired yesterday and were all running around like a bunch of headless chicken. By 9 pm lights went off music went up. Very odd experience.
Had a great experience. Everyone was so kind and helpful and we can’t wait to return.
Everything was wonderful. The server and all of the wait staff was excellent. The one thing I will say is the one manager/ Maitre D was awful and unpleasant to his staff within earshot of people dining and his lack of discretion was the only thing that took away from an overall lovely experience. Whatever he was reprimanding his staff for should have been done away from the patrons. It made me and my guests quite uncomfortable.
Perfect place for dinner , the outdoor space is especially comfortable
Did not enjoy it! Everything was very disappointing!
Place was hot and humid. No AC. Service was terribly slow and food was not good
Relaxed dining experience with a cool vibe and exceptional food and service!
We recommend Blu Mar highly.
The food seemed very low quality, especially the pizza appetizer. After my entire table had taken one bite we were in agreement it tasted frozen. As you can see in the picture, it looks similar to a pizza you’d find in the frozen section of a food store. The pasta entrees were nothing special at all, but were better when compared to the appetizer. They were also very small portions and I left hungry. The best thing we ordered was the burger which isn’t saying much. Overall very disappointed and will certainly not be returning
Actually the worst meal i have ever had in my life. The food was vile and definitely not made by anyone with any cooking experience. I would have rather gone to olive garden.
1st time was good
Went back & it was not a good experience , food was’t good & a beer is $18
Everything was bad about this place except for the patio.
Ambiance, you ask? Noise, you ask?
The rainstorm backed up tables inside, so we were seated in the nightclub at the back. This would’ve been fine if they made any attempt to make the room NON night clubish. But alas, no matter how many times I asked, the nauseating blue light stayed on, the overhead lights stayed off, and the music stayed loud. The lighting was so bad that all our food looked fluorescent - the tomato sauce looked neon orange, and the tuna tartare looked brown. Never in my life have I appreciated presentation (or lack thereof) so much. I spent the whole meal eating with my fork in one hand and my phone flashlight in the other to make the food look palatable enough to eat.
The cherry on top? As we were leaving, they seated a party that was celebrating the GRANDMA’S BIRTHDAY. IN A NIGHTCLUB. Poor grandma :(
The other cherry on top, you ask? They charged us $25 for something that we cancelled because they didn’t have it in stock, and then when I asked them to take it off the bill, they made sure to let us know that they “took off a bit extra” wink wink. The “extra” they took off was a whopping EIGHT (8) DOLLARS.
TLDR Blu Mar has no concept of what fine dining means if they treat their patrons to a smelly nauseating nightclub experience, and servers didn’t even try to rectify the situation.
Awful service, but good food once you get it. Arrived on time for reservation and was told to get a drink at the bar, bartender said we had to wait for drinks because he was too busy. Seated 20 mins after reservation, then sat at table for 30 mins without drinks or water and had to ask for a waiter to come over to be served. Witnessed manager yell at waitress in front of outdoor dining room.
David the manager is "Fantastic"
Waited at the table for over 30 minutes, without anyone stopping by. Had to ask the manager to send a server and get waters, and he was very bothered by the request. Drink and food order took over 45 mins to get to table. Decent food, but would not recommend going to this place.
Very accommodating staff—allowed us to add a person to our reservation at the last minute on a holiday weekend !
Food was excellent , albeit a little pricey. But it’s the Hamptons so not unexpected
Excellent food and fantastic service.
Great ambiance but extremely overpriced for what is offered.
Bill for four people with no drinks exceeded $200. It took one hour for our entrees to arrive with an empty restaurant after 7PM on a Tuesday. Most of the seafood was overcooked for a restaurant that advertises itself as mediterranean seafood restaurant. This alone would be enough to not come back here. The service was exceedling poor. Food runners did not know who ordered which menu item and had no idea how to set or serve a table. At one point an inexperienced waiter completely spilled a drink on us. The manager made no offer to rectify the situation. Finally, the staff completely forgot to bring us dessert menus. After we asked for them, they forgot to take our orders. I understand its difficult to hire experienced staff right now, but 2 hours of on the job training and reasonable organization would solve almost all of these problems.
Great place! Very attentive staff, good choices for food and drinks!
Lovely dinner. The wait staff was outstanding. Very busy but did not feel like it since staff very attentive. Food was good. No complaints!
Always outstanding. Service has come up to speed to handle the season. Our favorite spot in SH
Food very good. Menu expanded since I was last there. Nice crowd
Good food but spotty service - it was good but not great, and in this location and price point, I expected more.
Very loud concert in back for private party. Horrible service. Was sitting at bar beforehand and watched as they rinsed out and used a dirty glass because they ran out.
Oh my god. This was the worst experience.
The manager had two wait staff and seemingly no one else to make drinks or cook food.
The pizza was not as described and my first reaction was ‘Digiorno’ because it was frozen pizza. The chicken soup was either canned or powdered. The fried foods soggy and lathered with terrible sweet sauce.
Several other tables also did not get their orders in and were neglected for over an hour as they struggled to deliver. Not staff’s fault but management’s.
We went for dinner. 20 minutes in, the doors to the club opened into the restaurant. We were told if we wanted to stay for dinner, we would have to purchase a bottle. We gave the waiter a credit card to open a tab. Took over an hour to order our first round of drinks and when we did, the waiter said there was no credit card on file. Every 10 minutes $50 purchases were being added to my credit card bill, but "there was no card on file". They said that they lost my credit card, and in exchange, they would give each of us ONE free espresso martini. After hours of arguing with the manager, he said to just cancel the card as it's not his problem. Will never go to this place again and I suggest you don't too. They steal your money and the people at the "club" don't look a day over 18
Great meal and nice ambiance!
Service was horrendous. They took forever, were out of several items and gave no notice until the food (and substitute food) was on the table. Very few accommodations made and staff was very unfriendly
An absolutely amazing place. The drinks are good the food is great and the service was even better. My group of 8 girls went to celebrate my birthday and the server and staff went above and beyond to make sure we had the best night! I highly recommend for any occasion.
We had great time here, food was great, amazing portions service was good too. Tables are very safely all tables far each other
Outside seating is one of best in the area.
Well decorated place.
Food was excellent beyond our aspectative. the ambiance is fantastic, the only think we were not very satisfied was the service at the table.
Waitress was fantastic!
Dinner was good, however their sushi is overpriced. Unfortunately they were unable to serve any liquor...
Their outside area is very nice for dining...
I had an amazing experience from the hostess station to the dining. The staff was so friendly and great to me and my company. The food was beyond my standards and so was the dessert. I will recommend this restaurant to everyone.
Cute little place
Really bad food
Service was horrible. Waitstaff was inattentive, slow and a bit rude.
We were not informed the restaurant had lost their liquor license when making the reservation.
The food and service was good. They momentarily lost their liquor license so getting wine or cocktail couldn’t happen. I would have liked to know. Resy should have known. $180 for three people is also expensive for pasta.
It was our anniversary and not a single person cared or made an effort to even say congratulations. They called me 10 min before my reservation to tell me they weren’t serving any alcohol but I had already driven 35 min to get there so I didn’t see the message until we sat down. We were in and out in less than an hour. Food was good but we had much better elsewhere for half the price.
Blu Mar offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 488-4570.
Blu Mar is rated 4 stars by 117 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.