The food and the service were very good. The background music was very loud for relatively expensive dining.
"$32.00 per person- Menu Available at Restaurant" must be by request only.
The reservation process was miserable...unclear whether it originated with OpenTable or Black Hat.
Will only return if can't talk a friend or family member into dining at a more customer-friendly establishment.
Just a nice, unpretentious place to grab a great steak with the family. Not the place for fast or "fancy", but just right for the family on a Saturday night.
Never a disappointment
This is our second time to dine at the Black Hat, and both times have been outstanding.
Our server was lovely and very attentive. She was professional and knew the menu. We were able to talk and even had her turn down the volume on the music a little. food was very good.
The food, atmosphere, and service were all superb, as always!
We have gone to many of the Restaurant Week locations and this is the best by far, not only for what you get for the price, the steaks are wonderful, but what is included in that price!
We tried this restaurant because it was local and had great reviews. We enjoyed every bit of the experience and the food was amazing! Steaks were cooked perfectly to order - a serious bonus in my book! They also had a Tomahawk steak on special... OMG! Not only did I get to enjoy every bite, but my three dogs did as well! They even got to gnaw on that delicious bone for a few hours. I know I won't need a special occasion to make my way back to feast!
We have been eating at Black Hat Cattle for years. We had the best meal that we have ever eaten there or anywhere else in Evergreen on Friday Night. We had the mixed fish combo on the Early Dining 3 course Menu. There are also beef options.
Nice atmosphere, good service, good food although a bit expensive.
We really enjoyed our early dining experience at the Black Hat Cattle Company with our friends. Going before 6pm gives the diner the option of a 3 course menu for $32 (obviously price can vary, so check before you book). The Onion Rings were the best I have had, the dressing on the salad was delicious. Our steaks were cooked to perfection and the dessert was lovely too. Overall fabulous experience with excellent service and we will be going again.
Everything about this place is amazing. Feels like you’re dining in the old west yet somehow you are home.
A mountain steakhouse with delicious steaks and a good wine list. The creamed spinach had a bit too much cream and not enough spinach, but the onion rings were very good. Both the bone-in and regular ribeyes were very good.
The food is never a disappointment. This is a pricey place, but we cannot do without the shrimp cocktail with spicy sauce, or the Caesar salad (best I've ever found), or the quality cuts of beef. We always think of Black Hat first for any special occasion. Only thing we can even hope for improvement in is the side vegetables. Great dinner--always returning.
I am av vegetarian and they made me a great pasta dish. My partner had a great steak. The Black Hat is a fantastic place.
We were impressed by the superb service and delicious menu offerings. We will definitely be back!
Best steak around! Dry aged Kansas City Strip was amazing and you have to get the creamed corn!
We all had deilicious frest steaks and wonderful vegetable medley. Aislynn was our server and totally awesome!
Visited Black Hat with a friend. We had the dry aged bone-in Cowboy ribeye, it was delicious. Our server explained the process to us and said that Black Hat has been dry aging their steaks in-house for over a year. The dry aged steaks are a little more money, but so worth the price.
We enjoyed the old country music, and the Bev Doolittle prints that are all around the restaurant. Highly recommend you visit this restaurant.
Very enjoyable night out. Friendly service and excellent steak.
Ordered my steak well done and said I didn't want ANY red at all, and it came to me fairly rare. Had to send it back for more cooking. Very small portions for the high price. In my opinion it was very pricey for what you get.
We have been here before and will always find a reason to go back -- no special reason required.
I have been there on several occasions and the service is hands-down one of the best. And the food is absolutely what you would expect from a good steakhouse.
We've dined at Black Hat since 2009 and generally have enjoyed our meals. We asked our server the price of the Cowboy Drumstick special and she failed to tell our guest. I later found the special on my receipt at $65. That's a bit ' too pricey' compared to other menu offerings.
We spent New Year's Eve with friends at the Black Hat Cattle Co. This was not our first time there, we enjoy the friendly atmosphere, good food and service. With all the restaurants available to us in Colorado Springs, Castle Rock, Highlands Ranch, Denver, we chose the Black Hat Cattle Company for our special dinning experiences even though we drive all they way from Colorado Springs.
Our dinner was absolutely wonderful. My dinner (Filet medallions w/béarnaise sauce) was extremely tender and flavorful. We were a party of 6 and we could actually have a conversation. It was noted by one of our friends how the noise level was extremely low. .....considering it was New Years Eve and the restaurant was full. Although Black Hat is quite the distance from where we all live....it certainly was worth the ride. Our server Jason was excellent. I loved the fact that my wine glass was in the appropriate glass and filled practically to the top as requested. We will certainly come back and look forward to our next visit.
We celebrated our 26th anniversary there last week. It was our first time but it won't be our last!
We have usually had good experiences but the steaks this time were dreadful. Sides still very good.
We celebrated our anniversary. We wanted an unhurried dining experience and that is what Kelly, our server, provided. Her personable service actually added to the occasion. The steaks and sides were perfectly prepared.
Wonderful food, lovely ambiance, great local restaurant.
Black Hat is a wonderful restaurant for any special occasion. Great steaks and wine. Super service. A little pricey but worth it!
Had dinner with a friend - the steak was delicious. Our server who was very knowledgeable recommended the steak special which was 45 day dry aged Manhattan Medallions . Our server explained the dry aged process to us and how it enhances the steak! We also enjoyed the decor and country music that was played in the background. Highly recommend this restaurant!
This is our annual Thanksgiving treat. It's great to have a relaxed steak dinner instead of the typical turkey fest. Service is always stellar and the food is phenomenal.
Wonderful dinner and the steaks are to die for of course!
Love this restaurant. Food is always on point. Dave and Julie are awesome
This is the best place for steak dinner! We love it!
Always a winner whether you're into one of their aged steaks or fresh fish. A perfect place for a date or get together with friends.
Great place to take visitors to CO. Great western ambiance and good food. Nice staff! Looking forward to returning!
Went to Black Hat on a recommendation, while staying in Evergreen for our honeymoon, and could not have been more impressed. Black Hat holds on to that small-town feel of the area, while offering high quality/great tasting dishes and excellent service. The atmosphere was perfect. It felt comfortable and inviting. We will definitely be making a stop at Black Hat on future trips to the area. Ask for Dona!
This is a warm, cozy steakhouse located in the foothills. They serve steaks that are cooked to perfection, are dry aged, and melt in your mouth. The service was spot on, and their old country music playlist was very enjoyable. The chocolate bourbon pecan pie was out of this world. It was a very enjoyable evening. Would highly recommend this restaurant, it is worth the short drive from the city. You won't be disappointed!