Bruch on the patio. Food delicious. Worth the $23 brunch price which included mimosa, Bloody Mary or beer. Free parking on weekends in municipal lot across the street.

great time with phineas and the lonely leaves outside!

Food is great, always well prepared and very tasty. The garden setting is beautiful as well. My only problem with my last visit was the band, which was so loud it was difficult to talk with my dining companion without shouting. I’ve been to Birdsall many times with no band, my advice would be to go on a night without music.

Delicious food, great service.

Band was loud and horrible! Server was inattentive rude and barely saw her. Check you bills… was charged a credit card fee when I paid cash. Never bothered to ask how we were paying

Birdsall food and drink never disappoints. It was lovely sitting outside; the street noise is a bit much at times, but that’s out of anyone’s control. The French fries are a must!

Wonderful brunch for 7. The food was delicious and plentiful. Our special requests were honored and there was absolutely no rush. We are already talking about returning.

The server was rude & acted like they were doing us a favor by waiting on us. We had a reservation for 6 & sat at a nice table outside. We were from our of town & on an anniversary trip. They were having a drag show that night @ 7:30. & really hurried us through dinner due to the table being booked for the show. There was no advertisement anywhere about the drag show so, we had no idea. We actually would’ve liked to stay for it but when we asked we were treated as if we were idiots & told that the “table fee” would be $30 to stay. We were going to have another round of drinks but were so over the attitude from our server that we just got the check. I was a server & know what good customer service looks like. I can empathize w/ how challenging it can be but we were nothing but friendly & pleasant & looking forward to a fun night out. Disappointing.

Review is based on eating outside where noise is inevitable, and not under control of the restaurant. Very attentive wait staff, food very good.

Great food, music and service! Ashley took great care of us. Very enjoyable experience.

Excellent!!!

Given construction was noisy on patio but once done imagine lovely

This is my favorite local place. Great band last night (Bear Mountain Sound Machine) The food here has been excellent , especially the last several times I’ve been here. The staff is greatl!

Birdsall's old standby, the Beet Burger - never disappoints. Beet lovers can combine with the amazing beet salad!

Outdoor seating area is nice. Live music was good and not too loud. Food was very good.
Calamari Salad , Salmon, Bass, and Haddock were all nicely prepared and presented.
We definitely will return.

Great food on the Main Street in town. Sat in the back courtyard with a pleasant garden area. Service was too notch with the wait staff really hustling to keep each table happy. Very good experience.

Great outdoor seating. Delicious farm to table food.

Frozen pretzel for $9 really was hard to get past

I forget who our waitress was but she and the busy boy truly made our experience amazing! They were so nice!! The food was amazing as well. We will definitely be back!

We loved this place and will definitely be back. It was easy to reserve a table and find parking just around the corner. We wanted to come at 12:45 but made a 1:15pm reservation because the earlier times were booked. The beer was top notch and all the food was delicious - make sure to try the spicy BBQ sauce! I was surprised that the service as so slow as we were sitting near the bar and it took awhile for both our drinks and then our food to be brought to our table. I was happy to have a vegan option at a brewery. My suggestion - come here when you have time to spare and make sure to order a beer.

We sat outside and it was really nice! Ambiance was great! A band started just as we were leaving. Food and beer was also really good.

The service was fantastic. Our server was delightful and another server kept our waters filled which is really important for us. The blackened salmon was the best piece of fish I have ever eaten, no lie. A little light on the fingerling potatoes. My husband's steak frit was burned on the bottom and not as flavorful as we would expect. He did not send it back because he never sends anything back. The wine was wonderful. It was a bit noisy from the bar as we asked to be seated inside, but good-natured, friendly noise is fine by us. I'm just including that if noise is a big deal to others.

Delicious food, great beer selection and live music.

Disappointed in the reduced menu offerings, but understandable in light of covid. Food was as delicious as ever, especially the french fries and home made condiments. Service was slow.

Great food and great outdoor space! Great food options and good kids menu too!

There were 8 of us for a Father's Day late-lunch. It was really hot, so we asked if we could switch from a picnic table in the sun, to 2 put-together tables in the shade. The staff were very accommodating! Food was terrific as was the service. The kids, picky-eaters, loved the burgers and fries.

This was the first time my wife and I had been to Birdsall House. The food was excellent. Great beer selection. It was a beautiful night to sit outside and they have live music from a band. I definitely plan on going back.

Good selection of specials. Great band for entertainment

The lamb sliders and beet salad were delicious. California burger was tasty, but not cooked as we ordered. We sat outside since it was a cool evening and I faced the painted murals on the building which are beautiful. Diverse diners, which I like. Think a few plantings and or flowers would be a nice touch.

We came for lunch to celebrate an anniversary and also to celebrate eating together as a group. Everything was awesome. Sat outside on a beautiful picnic table. Given great recommendations. They make awesome ketchup and mustard.

Good food, friendly staff and excellent beer selection. Prices are fair. The outdoor space is excellent but charmless. Maybe some planters by the metal gate would work to separate the dining space from the street. I would recommend this.

Food was so delicious! Wonderful Sunday brunch. Good service!

Great food and service.

Great outdoor dining...good table distance...pretty set up and ambience. Burgers were great....Calamari salad so good...attentive service!

Fantastic experience! Our first visit but certainly not our last. Staff was courteous and attentive! Looking forward to our next meal here!

Good pub food, beer selection., and customer service.

The food and beer at Birdsall House were excellent as usual.
We were sitting outside in the garden, as we prefer, but the noise level from traffic (big trucks, noisy motocycles) on Peekskill’s Main Street was much greater/worse than usual.
We’ve sat out there before and it was much less noisy.
So this is the noise level and ambience I’m commenting on.

We did outdoor dining, the patio space was spacious, lots of fresh air and live music. The place was busy but the staff did their best to make sure we were tended to. The food was also quite good and reasonably priced . I liked that the brunch was a bit more interesting than the typical eggs and bacon type options.

Overall I would recommend and come back again.

We had a reservation to eat outside but when we arrived no outside tables were available. We waited 15 minutes at the bar. Once seated we were told the kitchen would not take orders for 20 minutes and we could expect to eat in 45 minutes. We asked for water twice and did not receive it.
The food was excellent and the atmosphere great but service needs improvement.

filled every need and request, very attentive service, and very good food.