Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Brie cheese, onion marmalade, ciabatta bread
black truffle crème fraîche, truffle shavings
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
Our heated outdoor patio will be open and will put everyone in the holiday spirit!
Great food and service as always. Will definitely be back
Excellent service, the wait staff was very attentive. Steak was delicious as well.
Best Ribeye I've had in years. Service was excellent. Blackened at my request, and server also brought a Cajun sauce - perfect combo.
My companion had an excellent sea bass. Clams Oreganata was excellent also.
Highly recommended! Prices pretty good (for a NYC Steakhouse)... only one arm, not an arm and a leg.
The people that took care of my guest and I were phenomenal.
Fabulous as always. Great to be back!!
It’s difficult to rate ambience and noise level because I was dining at an outside table. The food and service was excellent and I didn’t feel rushed, although I lingered at the table for a long time. There were a few empty tables so I didn’t feel I needed to leave. The waiter actually came by to refill our water glasses after we paid our bill and he assured us we didn’t have to rush.
Service was intermittently slow. Also took a while for the entrees to come. Additionally we had asked for the coffee first but that didn’t happen. The steak is always perfect at Benjamin’s! We dined outside and their outdoor seating area is superb!
The food was excellent. Service was excellent. Only issue was I reserved an outside table and they did not have an outside table ready. I had to switch to indoor. Everyone was very accomodating and mistakes happen. Not a game changer and everyone was great about it but I did prefer outside seating.
Totally awesome!! Rack of lamb is a must…
Great time on a very rainy night.
Call waiter was very respectful man over and on point this restaurant is nice and cozy and the food is excellent
Excellent bone-in ribeyes, done perfectly. We got some sides but be careful. There is way too much food—but it all tastes great. Service was next to none.
Fantastic service! Food was amazing!!! Overall wonderful experience.
Excellent food, friendly, efficient service. Let us est at our pace.
Main dish from Menu became smaller
Really great staff. Food was surprisingly poor and that was disappointing because everything else was great about the place.
Restaurant Week Dinner was delicious
Ari was the absolute best! Food was fantastic and the restaurant week menu was a great deal; will be back to try the regular menu as well.
the steaks were bad, we got the restaurant week menu, tried both sirloin and fillet mignon, both cold, low quality, and just boring, no sauce or anything, season was simple, service was good, just not satisfied with the food
From the moment we entered, the service was excellent. Our server Milot was PHENOMENAL!! The food was very well prepared, fresh and hot. One adjustment needed to be made to a plate and the issue was reconciled promptly and with a smile. We had the Caesar salad, sizzling canadian bacon, soy glazed salmon, petite filet mignon, crispy brussel sprouts w/ almonds, chocolate mousse cake and NY cheesecake. We had to have the desserts to go because we were beyond satisfied with the appetizers, entrees and that BLOOD & SAND!! That drink is TO DIE FOR!! Expectations were exceeded and we will return again.
A lovely meal. Was a nice surprise to be there for restaurant week. So happy to be back dining.
I wanted to take advantage of the last week of Restaurant Week which is a great bargain — however when restaurant week ends, they have a fabulous business lunch on weekdays. I’ll certainly return for the great food and service at bargain prices.
Amazing food, service and ambience! Highly recommend!
Food was good steak was fair. Did not taste like a prime steak.
Food was good
The service was excellent, my Sirloin was cooked to my expectations, Well done!
Great Restaurant Week Menu! So good I’d go back again.
Went for NYC restaurant week. What a deal for $39....appetizer, entrée, and desert! My picky kids absolutely loved the Canadian Bacon appetizers that they chose. Other family members went insane over the Burrata appetizers that they chose. I really enjoyed the grilled calamari appetizer. Entrée steaks were excellent. We tried the prime sirloin and petit filets....all were excellent. Deserts were a hit as well. Cheesecake and chocolate mousse options that we chose were excellent.
Very good restaurant week menu
Everything we ordered was very good. Especially liked the burrata appetizer & the cheesecake dessert. Both the junior sirloin & petite filet mignon were good.
Was there for the first time tried the restaurant week promotion! Food was wonderful, only down side is, was rush to leave, the waiter just give us check without we asked for it, and keep coming back to grab the check, not that pleasant experience~
The appetizers were all delicious; scallops, crab meat cocktail, and lobster bisque (although a few pieces of lobster would have been a nice touch). This is the fifth time I’ve eaten here and the porterhouse wasn’t very good quality the last two times. The service was terrible though. We both had empty glasses on the table for most of the meal. The delivery of food was not good. Little things, like wine by the glass being poured into a glass across the table so you had to get up to grab the glass - shouldn’t happen when you’re paying over $400 for 2. The manager seemed preoccupied with entertaining the larger tables. Quite a different experience than the one we had in May. I understand that help is very difficult to find right now but the restaurant wasn’t packed and there was adequate staff to provide better service if they were properly managed. Not a great experience for the price.
Great service and the food was excellent.
Service wasn’t what we are accustomed to from Benjamins. They ignored that it was a 45 wedding anniversary celebration. Disappointed by the disinterested care overall we received.
I would like to praise the staffs for being very friendly and providing exceptional service to us (group of 6 people) The food was excellent. The ambiance is nice. Highly recommended.
Our waiter was very informative and accommodating. Needless to say, the service was excellent.
The way they treated us was amazing. The waiter, the place, everything was perfect. Team dinner was a success
We were a party of 3 women and 2 men, got a bottle of wine for the table, waiter came and only gave the two men at our table a tasting of the wine even though I (woman) was the one who ordered the wine. ?????? Are we women not capable of tasting the wine?????
Very good lunch meal at a reasonable price ($39 during Restaurant Week)
Terrific value for outstand food and service in a casual but elegant atmosphere. Staff is friendly and attentive. Ambiance more upscale than most steakhouses but as good if not better than most. Delicious porterhouse for 3, perfectly medium rare and so tender it melted in your mouth. Sides were equally exceptional. Can't wait to go back!
We ordered from the Restaurant Week menu, which offered a nice variety of choices -- more than many restaurants offer. We enjoyed the food very much, and the service was excellent: friendly, attentive but not overbearing, accommodating.
You can order delivery directly from Benjamin Steakhouse Prime using the Order Online button. Benjamin Steakhouse Prime also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 338-0818.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is rated 4.7 stars by 1206 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.