Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
- Diner temperature check required
- Contact tracing information collected
Mother's Day Menus & Specials
Make reservations with us this Mother's Day for indoor or outdoor dining and enjoy our three course $89 menu that the whole family will enjoy!
The best steakhouse in midtown. Appreciate their consistent high quality
The power lunch was incredible. Best wedge salad I’ve ever had. The pork belly in the salad was still sizzling🔥🔥
I arrived at 355 for my 4pm reservation I was seated by the steps indoors, the waiter was very nice both the wait staff and manager would check in on me, my order was lobster bisque not enough lobster in my opinion, Caesar Salad with anchovies I didn't know they were in dressing so my salad had extra ones on top very pleasing to my palate next is the bone in rib eye extra char medium rare well cooked as chared as I requested. Home fires and onion rings the potatoes were nothing special but the onion rings were well.done almost like an onion tempura, I had the house steak sauce in my opinion way too sweet the blue cheese dip for the onion rings had no blue cheese flavor, the prime potatoes were under seasoned and a little soggy but steak was good, to end I had the flour less chocolate cake and coffee it was OK the ice cream they server it with was inconsistent some parts had vanilla flavor some do not.
In summary, Caesar Salad good, steak cooked well and good char, old fashion cocktail OK, onion rings good, other items hit or miss
Amazing from start to finish. Can't wait to return.
This was our first time dining here and had a wonderful experience. The ambiance, staff and the food were exceptional! It was expensive but it was for a special occasion so well worth it.
Phenomenal experience great food great ambience service and was perfect
Amazing experience! The food and service was great!
We started going here last summer during the pandemic and the service and people who work there were amazing! We started to go for dinner every week! We look forward to going here for dinner! Perfect for any occasion!
Outstanding restaurant, highly recommend
A very good choice for a business lunch. The outdoor set up is very well done. Attentive service.
First meal in restaurant since COVID lockdowns. Excellent for business lunch.
1 of my favorite restaurants NYC. best food, ambience and service. always delightful and satisfying.
We had the lobster bisque, crab cake, salmon and sea bass and creamed spinach. (So much for eating steak at a steakhouse!) The lobster bisque had chunks of lobster and the crab cake was mostly crab meat. Both were absolutely excellent and delicious. If the appetizers were excellent, the entrees were outstanding. The salmon and sea bass were fresh and cooked and seasoned to perfection. The creamed spinach was perfection (and without cream)! I highly recommend you give Benjamin Prime a try!
Outstanding. A bit pricey but on par with other steakhouses. And you definitely get what you pay for. Great meal, great service, great atmosphere.
My first time back in over a year and Benjamin’s did not disappoint...from being greeted warmly by Amanda, the ever gracious and beautiful hostess to warm welcome backs from Sean and Victor, the floor managers, to another memorable meal and amazing wine paring, it seemed for a moment like life was normal again. The environment created by everyone made me believe that nothing had changed and I certainly felt that way even though we were spaced considerably further apart and one could not hang at the bar and have a drink. Benjamin’s—even if was only for a few hours—transported me to my pre-pandemic life and for that I will be forever grateful. Hope the vaccine takes and I get to enjoy many more meals for a long time to come here.
Eveyone had a wonderful time and enjoyed the sumptuous food served to us. Service is top notch! Our waiter was very pleasant!
My husband and I stay in the city to experience the different restaurants. We loved the look and feel of the restaurant. The staff friendly and professional.
Steak perfectly cooked and the King Crab was amazing!
We go to the city about 6 times a year. We will definitely be back.
Excellent food and service. Steve was great as a server. Good value Prix Fixe at $39 for Power Lunch!
First time. Food and drinks was AMAZING
Amazing, reccomend to anyone. Obviously pricey but 100% get what you pay for and more. Steak was cooked perfectly, could not have asked for a better time or meal. Service was also excellent.
Excellent all the way around. Impeccable service.
Amazing, Awesome, Delicious .. Best Steakhouse in nyc
Excellent service and food. Seated us when we were early, super attentive and did a lovely birthday desert setup with my candles. Extensive high end cognac brandy etc. menu...but did not present a wine list. Cab by the glass was delicious. Mashed potatoes were exceptional.Price point was a bit higher than expected but understandable given recent events.
Food and service was 10/10. So good, it was pricey but the quality was perfect. That sear on the steak, omg.
Another great night at Benjamin Prime! Great service and great food!
It was a great dinner of farewell party for my boss
Quality steak as always. Lunch prix fixe is a good value.
The food was delicious as always. The service was outstanding.
Food was delicious. Enjoyed having a good steak. Sizzling plate and all.
Waiter asked us if we wanted a glass of cab with the steak. Two glasses of wine cost more than the steak... wasn't prepared for that.
Excelente comida, ambiente insuperable pedimos el bacon canadiense y estuvo exquisito, Steak For 3 y eramos 5?quedó todo genial , seguro que volvemos
El camarero atento, pides un trago y llega como lo esperas
Tienen un menú For lunch
Great time. Upscale feeling and superb food. Highly recommend the power lunch.
The best steak I have ever had. The service was amazing and the wine that staff helped me select went great with the meal.
Great time, great food, the Crab salad was the best I ever had. Also the butter crab legs
Overall great experience. Staff was attentive and very nice. Food was outstanding. Everything was just on point. Highly recommend
We had the lobster bisque, wedge salad, porterhouse for two, mashed potatoes, and brussels sprouts. The meal was excellent, but the steak was underseasoned. Other than that, though, we had no complaints whatsoever.
Great food, great environment, music was a little low. Either turn it up or off.
As with every monthly visit, it was a great time! Sean is always a wonderful host. He is doing great job in Mario’s stead. We had the best seats in the house last week! Unfortunately, Johnny wasn’t our server. We love Johnny! See you next month!
The staff, service and especially host Sean are all extremely top shelf. They go out of their way at every turn to help ensure a fun, enjoyable and special dining experience.
Every time I visit NYC I make sure I go to Benjamin’s at least once. The service was excellent and the food was even better. Will definitely be returning.
Everything was perfect. One of those steakhouses I always heard about but never went. Glad I did! Divine!
You can order delivery directly from Benjamin Steakhouse Prime using the Order Online button. Benjamin Steakhouse Prime also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 338-0818.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is rated 4.8 stars by 1058 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.