Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
- Diner temperature check required
- Contact tracing information collected
Val was an amazing waiter and upstairs is an amazing ambiance. Had a dairy allergy and staff was very receptive and made sure I knew what had dairy and what didn’t. Food was amazing!
Was very happy they accommodated my party by changing tables. Originally was seated under a speaker which would prevent normal tone conversations.
A great lunch, very vibrant place, solid food, great quality.
Well managed and good service. If you're a ribeye steak lover, then this is one restaurant that I would place on my short list.
In a word- superb! If you want the most delicious and tender steak or even better, lamb chops you can not do better than Benjamin. They know their meats!
Delicious Steak, Yummy Lobster, Amazing Shrimp.
It was early and there were only two occupied tables inside. Stereotypically, the service was not great.
Still, we certainly enjoyed the food.
Thanks for tasty meal.
As always - a wonderful experience. Can't wait for the next time - and maybe I'll try the key lime pie!
Sean is an excellent host, always makes me and the team feel welcome. Best, Mike Gaffney
The food and service was incredible as always - one of my favorite restaurants to go to.
Always a fantastic "dining" experience at any of the Benjamin Restaurants!
wonderful service and food!! Have never had a bad meal or service here.
Everything was delicious, from the French Onion Soup to the Surf and Turf to the sides. The service was impeccable as well. Highly recommended!
We recommended to this place and it didn’t disappoint!!
A truly great Steakhouse. Terrific food, service, and attitude. Highly recommended
A tired teacher who just finished teaching high school virtually for an entire year, I came to NYC with friends to relax & recharge. This meal was perfection! Great surf & turf, even better service.
Service was accommodating but the food had too much salt. We had the 3 course lunch and nothing was memorable.
As always the same quality and service they are real pros!!!! Great Steak and the bacon is out of this world!!!
Shawn was terrific, as usual, as was the food and ambiance.
We ate outside after a very rainy Memorial weekend! Service and food were excellent!
Great food and service. They are very consistent. One of the best Steakhouses in NYC.
We are totally satisfied with thier food and service.
Excellent as always!
Amazing food and great selection of wine.
The waiters really went out of their way. Offered dishes to share, what goes with what.
The seabass was outstanding, and the sirloin steak was just perfect!
I proposed to my now fiancé and the wait staff was very kind and attentive and the food was amazing and the wine selection was great, this restaurant will now be our sole restaurant for our anniversary and I can’t wait for our next visit.
Another outstanding lunch...can compliment the staff more...from the wait staff to Amanda and hostess to Sean the manager—all top notch which is why I will continue to come back
The steak was chewy and sinewy. NOT what I expected for the price. Will not return.
I've eaten here a number of times, and it's always been very good. I have to say that many restaurants have not been able to keep up with the quality of food during the pandemic, but I think Prime has gotten better in the past year! I've eaten here twice in the past month and everything has been superb. Definitely will return.
Great food and service, very attentive and accommodating to our large group. Highly recommended!
A colleague recommended this restaurant. We are def foodies. My friend and I went today and it was AWESOME. We had the porthouse for two, lobster mac & cheese, and cream spinach.
I’m going back again with other friends. If I was to ever get married I would love to rent out the private room to have my reception :) if it’s allowed . I Love Love the food and the huge windows .
So many people in an very informal attire
Benjamin's Prime was warm, welcoming and helpful from the moment we arrived. We were quickly shown to a comfortable table where our server, Ori, greeted us in a friendly manner and immediately took our beverage requests. Ori remained friendly and attentive throughout the evening providing us with excellent and efficient service. As we were dining on our appetizers we'd struck up a conversation with the people at the next table. He kept an eye on us as we conversed so that the timing of our main courses was perfect and would not interfere with the flow of our conversation. Dinner from start to finish was outstanding and even better than we'd hoped.
Pretty good and went there for birthday, they have a cheese cake w candle which was nice but also charge you for it
The outdoor seating is lovely and the service was generally too-notch, although nobody could explain why my martini had a pinkish hue! (It did taste fine, so at least that.) their steaks are superb. I had the yellowfin tuna and it was solid but not spectacular. Get the steaks when you go - it’s a steakhouse, after all!
Everything was excellent. Can’t wait to return. 😍
Went for lunch. My first eat-in-the-street since COVID. Attractive covered space blocked out view of street. Tables well spaced. Felt safe. Menu basic - it's a steakhouse and I don't eat beef - but the lobster salad was tasty. Plenty of lobster, arugula, citrusy dressing. Glass of wine and calorific but yummy pecan pie completed the meal. Rather overpriced. Service was excellent, attentive and friendly. Negative was rather loud piped music.
Great steackhouse experience..... and seafood is a must!!!
First lunch in town in a while. Amazing to be back and the Benjamin team has not missed a beat...From the warm welcome by Amanda the hostess and Sean the manager to the flawless service by the wait staff. So happy to be back.
You can order delivery directly from Benjamin Steakhouse Prime using the Order Online button. Benjamin Steakhouse Prime also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 338-0818.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is rated 4.8 stars by 1106 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.