Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
Dinner: Monday-Saturday 4-11pm
Benjamin Prime prides itself on providing perfectly choreographed events for groups of all sizes in our new classic yet modern environment.View Private Dining Details
Weekday Happy Hour
Enjoy $1.50 oysters & 1/2 OFF champagne by the glass!
Terms and Conditions:
Valid For: 1 - 20 people
Starts: October 12, 2018
Ends: October 13, 2117
Availability: Mon-Fri 4:00PM-7:00PM
Thanksgiving Dinner Special Menus & Offers
Enjoy a feast around our table! Join us for a $69 per person 3-course Prix Fixe Thanksgiving menu!
Thursday, November 22, 2018
Christmas Day Special Menus & Offers
Let us make your Christmas dinner a memorable one. Join us for a $79 per person 3-course Prix Fixe Christmas Dinner menu! Happy Holidays
Tuesday, December 25, 2018
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
Ring in 2019 with our sister property right around the corner, Benjamin Steakhouse 41st St.! Join us for a $295 per person Four-course Prix Fixe New Years Eve menu! Full Open Bar | Live Music | Party Favors | Midnight Toast
Monday, December 31, 2018
Dinner was as anticipated - excellent. Service prompt and yet not rushed. Lovely desserts to completed a taste bud odyssey. Would recommend highly for a special occasion, or simply to pamper the epicure within.
Food and wine list were both excellent and the service was notable and exceptional. Great experience for our client.
I went to New York for an event and I heard about this please I called and made a reservation we went there with my wife for a dinner we do each outside a lot everywhere this one it was the best experience the food was outstanding the service it was excellent mr. Victor keep doing the good work highly recommended I will fly to New York just to have a good dinner add Benjamin prime
There are a lot of steak restaurants in NY; this one is good but not top of my list. We were greeted nicely and our table was fine. Drink service could have been better.
The steak knives are beautiful wood and metal; but they are not sharpened well enough for their larger steaks. I would recommend the filet, perfectly prepared. They also had veal chops and rack of lamb options as well as fish and seafood.
Food, atmosphere and most of all service was top notch and probably the best I’ve had from any please I’ve been. We had a 10:45 reservation and actually was running late and they still provided amazing food and service without seeming irritated at all by the late arrival (kitchen closes at 11). I will definitely make it a dinner stop every time I visit NYC.
Hands down the best steak I have ever had the pleasure of eating. My daughter and I came here while on a girls weekend in NYC and everything from apps to dessert was pure perfection. It is pricey but totally worth it.
My new favourite steak house in New York - it was that good!
My seafood starter was a very generous size, very fresh and great flavour. The New York cut sirloin was perfectly cooked, tender and a great taste.
Service was excellent including a couple of complimentary ports.
For wine lovers they do have a BYO corkage policy at $45/bottle.
The whole night was wonderful.
Sean is a terrific host
Great place to visit if you are in New York. Love their steak.
Staff is really friendly and they know how to treat a customer
the only down side was that the space between the tables are quite close
so sometimes the servers bump into table or chair. Its a fancy crowded
restaurant so I could take it into consideration
Fantastic service and food - one of the best steaks we had. Everything was on point.
Our meal was good but nothing spectacular for the money, but the servers didn’t know who was doing what and it was a little loud.
Delicious, amazing service, great ambiance
Enjoyed the Filet and the Brussel Sprouts were the best I’ve had anywhere. The Ribeye had almost too much fat in it, but was still good.
A little disappointed in that this was a birthday celebration, yet the restaurant did nothing to acknowledge it.
It was our first time at Benjamin Steakhouse.
Everything was perfekt.
Had to be the best steak dinner of my life! Cozy dining room, wait staff anticipates every need.
Had the Porterhouse for two, tender, prepared perfectly and oh so delicious. My wife ordered lobster mac and cheese as a side and it too was to die for!
Service was top notch and the food cooked to perfection!
Went for a friend's birthday, outstanding food. Excellent service. You absolutely must get the tickets cut bacon as an appetizer. Pricy, but that's to be expected at a premium steakhouse.
At least two things are needed for a great steakhouse restaurant; great food and perfect service. Benjamin has both along with a wonderful atmosphere, an amazing bonus!
My wife and I make sure we visit Benjamin Steakhouse monthly if not more often.
Great service and excellent food! The welcome at the front door was fantastic. The servers are excellent and offer solid recommendations.
Reservation worked fine and I could choose a table or bar area. Very good steak - really quick from order to receipt, all medium as it should be. Great choice of wines. Very attentive and friendly staff.
Overall a great evening dinner.
La atención fue espectacular
the Best Porterhouse in the city. great sides-creamless cream spinach, mashed potatoes, brussel sprouts . warm rolls. love the service. appreciate I asked for a quiet table and I got it. thank you.
Top quality food with great service make this a winner. Great steaks, great fish and great sides. Service to match. My new go to steakhouse in NYC.
Great service...very knowledgeable servers/waiters. Terrific wine list
Amazing: service, food, ambiance - the entire experience!
Snooty and condescending staff ... steak not outstanding given the high price
Excellent service from Sean & Team!!!
We already have our next reservation!
Romantic and quiet
Good food and prepared exactly how ordered
A bit disappointed overall. Ate one other time at the Benjamin for New Years a few years ago and had very fond memories of the night, everything was great. Was looking forward to trying the Benjamin Prime with some friends and came away saying it was just ok, not good enough in the competitive world of NY streak houses charging top dollar. The bone in rib eye was over salted, hiding the potential flavor of the aged beef. It was also not seared quite enough and the cut seemed too thin, certainly not the 22oz cut I expected. Not bad but not the wow factor I was looking for. Most at the table thought the cocktails weren’t great, mine needed more vodka, seemed a measured pour, not what I expect at a top steak restaurant, expect strong well crafted drinks. The service was good, the room nice, the caeser salad good, good fries, pathetic loaded potato. That’s it! Regards. Ned.
Staff was attentive and we lacked for nothing! We will be back- visiting from Texas
The BEST porterhouse steak in Manhattan!!! Incredible service. Victor, the manager, is super helpful, professional, and courteous. Benjamin is doing superb job
This place and their steak never disappoints me. Am a big fan..
Food was great and the service was excellent - both the bartender and our waiter were fantastic!
I went first time. But everybody's kindness,friendly. Naturally the steak was the best ! Thank you‼️
As a repeated customer, for some reason, can’t place my finger on it, the overall taste of the food was not as expected. Definitely had better from there before. Maybe an off day but will be back.
My wife and I now are regulars at Benjamin Prime! We are treated as family as all patrons are treated. Service was again simply awesome, and the food was perfect, we had rib eye steak. Couldn't finish it all, so again we took home a :doggy bag,”
Sean, the manger treats all new comers and regulars as dear friends – really a good feeling. He insures that details matter.
Food Super, Service Adequate, restaurant noisy, bar drinks very skimpy at $16 for a short shot
It was perfect everything. It was very delicious steak for my son. We will go again.
We were seated promptly by a friendly host. We were given our choice of table. The waiter and wait staff were attentive and friendly. However I ordered a filet cooked medium and it was rare, red in the middle. I would expect better from a steak house of this caliber. The mashed potatoes were excellent, but my husband ordered hash brown potatoes that had an odd seasoning and they were unappealing. It is best not to mess with hash browns by getting too creative. Hash brown potatoes are fine as they are and do not need new seasonings. Our wines were very good and so was the cheesecake dessert. We would go back as it was a pleasant dining experience, but I would stress that my steak be cooked to my request. I don't like to send steak back as what usually happens is that they recook the same steak and then it is dried out.