Auburn City Steakhouse
Great atmosphere! We had reservations, so we were seated upon arrival. The staff were all incredibly friendly and attentive. My wife and I both had the prime rib and it did not disappoint. Very tender. The crab cakes were some of the best we have tried. The bartender made a mean Bulleit Bourbon Mule. It was definitely worth the two hour drive we made to dine out. Great steak house!
I really don’t have anything nice to say so I’m going to keep quiet
My husband and I celebrated our anniversary here. We were seated upstairs in the library. Great atmosphere. Nice and quiet.
Auburn City Steakhouse is a great place to go for a special night out. The service was great and friendly and respectful of your personal space. The food was so delicious and very filling. The atmosphere is tastefully modern with a nod to the building’s historical past. We love going there and look forward to returning.
Filet was wonderful but the side of mashed potatoes was dehydrated and was a disappointment for such a nice steak house. Hopefully the Chef will correct because the menu items deserve premium accompaniments. Fiance' enjoyed the prime rib with fingerling potatoes which were very well presented and extremely tasty.
We enjoy the lounge area for a good meal. We visit regularly from Angola.
Amazing time at the steak house. We celebrated our 10th anniversary and couldn’t have picked a better place. It was nice and quiet. The service was outstanding and the food was amazing.
Great place to have really good food and pleasant surroundings.
we have been looking forward to getting back in here all quarantine! Stay strong, they will all be back!
Thank you so much for the carry out specials, they have been welcome treats
Amazing food & service!!! We will definitely be back.
First time visiting and was surprised at how mediocre it was. The dining room is very cramped and our date consisted of being sandwiched in the middle of two tables with constant flow on either side plus the table was tiny- not very romantic. Service was slow- took a long time to be greeted, she told us she would tell us the features on her next round but didn’t, and we were brought the wrong food. I ordered rare prime rib and got medium, he got the Oscar filet and it came out as ordered. Mashed potatoes were super dry and crumbly, no flavor. Bread was boring although he really liked the cinnamon butter. Calamari was very salty. French onion soup was also salty but I would expect that for that dish- probably my favorite item of the meal. Prices were fair but combined with everything we probably won’t be back
First they ran out of prime rib. Then without the menus there the waitress says I recommend this one and if course it was the most expensive steak on the menu which we did not know because they took the menus from us. Then they had to make more soup. So we waited 45 minutes just to get soup. And one our steaks came out It was charred so bad it tasted burnt. By the time the replacement came out everyone at our table had finished eating except for one person. So they made that steak to go. Never even thought about offering us a discount for the bad service
It was just ok... and for the price it should have been A LOT better than just ok. Our server wasn’t great and seemed annoyed rather than pleasant. Food was fine, but again for the price I expected a lot more.
Awesome food! Such an amazing atmosphere! Highly recommend
The service and food was great. We had a 5:00 reservation, got in and seated. The waitress
was top notch. We had the prime rib and it was excellent.
Asked if there were specials and all we got was a flat no. But heard the waitress talk about the drink specials to the next table. Ordered 2 glasses of white wine and the glasses weren’t even 1/4 of the way full when we asked about the wine the waitress told us that they did look skimpy and would ask the bartender. Someone was suppose to come talk to us about it but never did. I ordered the Filet Oscar and it was fatty my husband ordered the Wagu and it was the driest looking piece of meet with no flavor. The waitress just came over and took my daughters plate without asking if she was finished. She was still working on it. We have always had an amazing experience when we have dined there but this was the absolute worst. After paying $147.00 for a meal and being that disappointed it will be hard to go back.
Loved the place, yes it is a little pricey but our prime rib and service were outstanding. We will be going back on special occasions that’s for sure. Be sure and try the Carrot Cake!!! Holy Cow, it was so moist and flavorful. Thanks again for a wonderful evening. Billy & Regina Pogue.
Awesome place! Steak was great. Emily is a fabulous server!!
Our server was great. The food was wonderful. It was calm and quiet. Best night out in forever.
My compliments to Christine, Cord, and Nate for an enjoyable evening...great wine, food, and service. See you next Saturday.
My wife and I went on a Saturday night, the service was great and we loved the atmosphere. However the food was not what I expected, my meal was barely warm and the Delmonico didn't have much flavor. My wife loved her 6oz filet and the crab cakes were fantastic. We will give them a second chance.
First, we eat at Auburn City Steak often and enjoy the food. However, on Valentines night I would have rather dined at Wendy’s. The rice was undercooked, vegetables were undercooked, swordfish was cold, appetizer came out after the meal, and we had to repeatedly ask for service. This was the worst dining experience we have had in years. We had appetizers at Mad Anthony’s before our reservation at ACS. We should have stayed there!!
Food and ambiance were great as always. Requesting that management monitor wait staff’s presentation of professional appearance. Our server had extremely long finger nails that touched our salad plates while carrying out - this was not pleasant. Also she had trouble opening our expensive bottle of wine and splashed it all over the table once it popped open. It wasn’t until I checked myself for wine on my clothing that she apologized. We love the steakhouse and will continue to be customers as the food is always great , but not great service during this one experience.
The food was excellent but the service was SLOW! We (4 of us) arrived at 8:15 for our 8:30 reservation, were seated at 8:35 then waited for 10 minutes to even get our water. Ordered 15 minutes later, didn't receive our dinners until 10:00pm! Other patrons were seated after us and received their dinners and left before we even received ours. We were the last to leave and it wasn't because we were talking. Our waitress was just not as fast as the others. Very disappointing.
The food and service were absolutely fantastic. They sat us quickly and we received our food in a reasonable time. The only feedback I have is that an older gentleman, with gray hair and glasses was hovering over all the tables waiting for people to leave so he could quickly seat other guests. He was incredibly rude to the other staff as well. It made me feel very rushed like I couldn’t enjoy my dinner. Perhaps allow your patrons time to enjoy their time and take your internal spats with staff to the back.
Food was mediocre at best, given the price. Sat at a table for 25 minutes before a waitress asked if anyone had helped us. Why we told her “no” the waitress then sighed and said “I guess I can help you then.” After ordering drinks, and our entire order (as we had plenty of time to look at the menu) we waited another 20 minutes before our drinks and appetizers arrived. Once we received our food, we were never checked on again. For the prices you pay, and the feeling that this is “the steakhouse” of Auburn, we were left severely disappointed.
Oh... I might add this was on Valentine’s Day, with reservations made well in advance.
Our meal was great! We both had prime rib and it may have been the best I have ever had!! We will be back!!!
The Chicago style beef sandwich was very good. Two of us ordered it. A third person had the Kobe burger which looked great, and was enjoyed. Fries need to be served hotter, and not dark brown from too old deep fryer oil.
Food was ok. Nothing as special as prices indicated. Nice ambiance and good menu choices. I don’t see why the mashed potatoes with bacon and green onions were $5 more than regular mashed potatoes. Very little on appetizers that interested me. Desserts were pretty boring. Really bummed it wasn’t as good as we hoped. Our waiter was great though.
Great service and food. This place is very cool. We had a large party of 11. They were quick and very attentive.
Beautiful setting and atmosphere. Our waitress was very knowledgeable and kind. Great evening out.
Had an amazing night and that was an fantastic server! Highly recommend this restaurant
Food was good...however service was slow and did not like the seating
Food was good, nice portions for the money.Service from our waitress not so great! But thanks to another server for checking on us.
Great place off the beaten path. Fantastic food and great preparation. Relaxed atmosphere and all of the personnel were friendly and attentive. It was on a not so busy evening so it seemed like a private occasion. We have put this place on our ‘to return’ list. Kind of expensive, but well worth it for that special occasion. There were more economical meals on the menu but it’s tough to beat their premier selections. My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed ourselves.
Great tasting food and excellent service. Staff went out of their way to accommodate my wife with her broken ankle.
Best food/meal we have had in a long time and in the last 30 days have eaten at Wu's, Baker Street and Club Soda all of which paled in comparison to the food and service at Auburn City Steakhouse.
Jaime our server was awesome!
Amazing food and great atmosphere. The shrimp cocktail and house salad were so delicious.
Absolutely the best Filet I've ever had! Beautiful private table upstairs with great service.
Auburn City Steakhouse offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (260) 333-7337.
Auburn City Steakhouse is rated 4.4 stars by 305 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.