The food is amazing. The atmosphere is perfect and they have an artist playing a Guitar and singing while they prepare your food table side.
The food and presentation was excellent BUT we were rushed through our meal! We live about 45 mins away from the restaurant. We were seated quickly and overwhelmed by the delicious choices.
We decided on an appetizer as well as the entree by the second round with the waitress.
We were enjoying the appetizer while they were setting up our cheese wheel for the carbonara. We were surprised that they were already prepping for the next dish.
They then brought out the entrees right away. (After our waitress mentioned they weren’t anywhere near ready).
We were finished AND paid within 36mins!
Again, it takes 45 mins to get there!
I noticed all the other tables (most of them were there BEFORE we arrived) were relaxing and enjoying their food at a comfortable pace.
The food was delicious but the service was something to be desired.
If you are desiring a nice, relaxing meal to visit with friends and family over a glass of wine, a few appetizers, and then an entree AFTER your appetizer has had a time to settle, I don’t recommend this restaurant.
Possibly try another location and hopefully the service will be what it should be.
Great food!, the service was a bit slow, but so worth the wait.
This was not my first dog n pony show here and won't be my last.
This restaurant did not live up to the recommendations I had been given. Service was slow and honestly our waiter was annoying. The food was not as good as everyone made it out to be. We won’t be going back.
Wonderful dinner. It was my birthday, and we were treated superbly with a wonderful dinner with great service. It was our third time eating here, and we’ll definitely be back.
These guys did a great job yet again. Everything I have ordered here has exceeded our expectations.
Their signature dish - the carbonara - is amazing. Our server kept trying to talk us into getting lots of other things we didn't want. But otherwise it was good!
Place and food are great, but everything being al a carte it is too expensive. I will not be returning unless you ever have a combination meal. I do not want to pay more than $20 for salad, main course and possible dessert. Generally the experience was very good, but Italian food should not cost that much. Thanks
The food was delicious. If this is your first time going make sure you get the spaghetti carbonara. It’s a really fun experience. Also make sure you get dessert the cannolis are to die for.
I love Antica Sicillia and it is currently my favorite Italian Restaurant. I introduced three people that had never been and they loved everything about it. The people and food are amazing and I feel like I’m a part of a large Italian family. Keep up the good work!!
We had a marvelous time. The food was wonderful and the staff exceptional.
We are so glad to have dined there
Very good food and Service. I highly recommend this place.
This is our new favorite restaurant! We want to try everything on the menu and crave the Spaghetti alla Carbonara. Even friends from out of town ask to go back when they come to town. We’ve been to the Millcreek and Cottonwood Heights restaurants and both had excellent food and such a welcoming atmosphere, just ask our little granddaughter! We can’t wait to bring our oldest son for his birthday next week.
It was great but they got one of our orders wrong and gave him a substitute meal.
Excellent food, great serving staff. There was a very large group (looked like a family reunion) with lots of conversation going on, but the noise level stayed low enough we could have our own conversation without needing to raise our voices. Overall a great experience.
Great food and the actual server was great. The support staff handling getting you to a table left a bit to be desired with getting distracted and not getting things done. However, server and food were amazing and will be eating here again.
It was great!
Since I first experienced Sicilia Mia in Holladay a couple of years ago, the Sicilia restaurants have become my "go to" place to dine out. They offer a wonderful variety, the food is delicious and the service is outstanding. I love the feel I have when there, of dining at a local family restaurant in Italia! My friends, to whom I have introduced Sicilia, have also loved it, without exception. A bonus they have opened in other locations, so I don't have to drive so far, and I am more likely to find one when I am out and about in SL Valley. Such a wonderful addition to SLC!
We loved everything thing we had from appys to desserts. The staff was perfect!
Great service, provided poignant suggestions that enhanced the overall experience. The food was great and they went out of their way to accommodate my five year old’s picky palate. Overall a great evening.
Took my husband there for his 60th birthday and he really enjoyed the food and atmosphere. Our server, Carlo, was fantastic!
My parents and I had dinner on a Monday and thoroughly enjoyed the entire evening. The atmosphere was warm and relaxing, the food was delicious, and the service great! They happily divided one entree three ways (since we all had small appetites) and made each portion look beautiful!
Another beautiful evening as usual, thank you for the consistent excellence.
Great Italian food and service. Would definitely recommend and return
As always, they do a wonderful job with the whole dining experience! And the carabonara and mushroom ravioli were superb!
We were pressed for time but our service and the kitchen got on through on schedule. Great food and a delicious glass of wine at a reasonable price.
Friendly service but slow.
This was an outstanding evening. The ambiance was perfect for the group I brought and they service was outstanding. We spent almost three hours in your restaurant and it seemed like 30 minutes because it was so enjoyable. My guests were from out of town and your restaurant is now in there top ten ever. Thank you to all of your excellent staff and food.
We went for our anniversary and it was great. It had a wonderful feeling and the food was really good we split an appetizer and the main course and they were really good about doing so. Plus there was live music with a gentleman coming to our table and playing a song for us.
This was a great experience. Food was outstanding, very tasty, and presented very well. I highly recommend the pasta carbonara. It is mixed in a cheese wheel! There was a huge party going on so service was a bit slow but the server went out of their way to let us know the status of our meal. Highly recommended.
This restaurant does not disappoint!!! I will continue to go back and recommend to everyone.
I ordered the Tagliatelle al Nero di Seppia and it was really salty and I only could have a couple of bites. I also ordered a Tiramisu and it had a lot of creams. Was it home made? I went to several places in Italy but I have never had these flavor before. It was different. The Calamari e Gamberi was a good.
We've been to Sicilia Mia several times but this was our first visit to Antica and it was excellent. Seated on time, promptly served and great food. All the portions are quite large, so we split a salad and a dessert. Both of our main courses were also large and resulted in a take home box for both of us. Very nice surroundings and nice atmosphere. We'll certainly be back.
Great service, food wasn’t the best we’ve had, but was still very delicious.
Everything was good and the foo was delicious!
Great service and ambiance. They were not serving pizza that night which was disappointing but other than that we had a wonderful experience!
My favorite Italian place in Utah. Delicious, authentic food. Spaghetti carbonara is to die for.