Amazing service. Best Italian food I've ever had! The food was super flavorful. Great place to take a date.
Greeting and wait was slower than expected, especially with having a reservation. Service was kind of slow - had to ask for bread even after our first course had already been brought out. One of our party’s meal had been given to a another table (admittedly by the server) so food overall was a little cold. Most disappointing of all was that gratuity was AUTOMATICALLY added to our party of 4 without being announced by the server and was also calculated on tax (which I think might be illegal?). Super off-putting.
Excellent Italian food in a nice setting. Outstanding service!
Prices have increased a lot since their popularity took off and the portions have decreased. The food is fabulous and some of the servers are great, others not so great. It would be nice if they’d put a space heater at their Murray location as the front tables get very cold. Overall though, I vastly prefer it to all other Italian restaurants, I just hope they don’t lose that Trattoria feel that I always loved.
They were completely over their heads dealing with s moderate Sat evening crowd. Was seated 30 minutes late on a two person reservation at6:15x Service was very uneven as was food. All of the dishes, primi, secondi, all arrived at the same time - secondi entrees were cold and not well executed. Ambience is a retired western steakhouse - pretty depressing.
Overall, the experience was exceptional. I am only giving 2 stars in the value because we ordered 4 mojito’s and the price was $52. That’s $13 a drink, and they weren’t even that tasty. If you’re going to charge that much for a drink, it better be one of the best drinks in town, and these shady are not.
We will be going again, sans drinks.
Delicious food and fun atmosphere. I recommend the carbonara, very yummy!
The man at the door – Paolo-checked us in then ignored us. He said he was waiting for the table to be set up, but it was already set up and he walked away and after 5 minutes we had to ask someone else to seat us. He never acknowledged us and I told him upon exiting after dinner that I would state what poor service he gave us or rather no service. We had a very nice wait person which made our evening successful.
The food was excellent and the service was very good. I would recommend this to any and all. They have gluten free pasta if you call in advance.
One of our favorite place in the Salt Lake Valley to dine. Much better ambiance than the 4500 location, which is too noisy.
Great all around consistently one of the best Italian restaurants in Salt Lake
Lovely experience, lovely staff, we had the best time and the BEST food and can't wait to go back!!
Bruschetta was to die for! Filet Mignon was different than I thought. It was 4 paper thin slices, similar to deli meat. The menu said thinly sliced however I just expected something diff.
Will be back to try the carbonara!
Food was excellent only problem was our server was extra busy so service was kind of lacking. Not his fault because he was running as fast as he could but maybe they could’ve had an extra couple servers scheduled to help the situation.
Antica Sicilia is ALWAYS good! I Definitely recommend!
The restaurant was well decorated, great ambiance! Food was fantastic and a great prices!
Great experience and great food! Would recommend to friends and family!
Busy spot, which is usually a good thing. In this case it was! The restaurant is in a kind of strip mall but don’t let that fool you. The staff tries hard to make sure everything is taken care of. No only will your server check in on your table other servers will make sure you have what you need. The food, Italian and a good selection of dishes. I didn’t notice any specials but that didn’t bother me. We had apps, salad and entrees all were delicious and the presentation was done really well. The deserts were amazing and tasty. If your sitting by the desert display take a look they all looked delicious. I will return to try more of the items on the menu. Yum!!
Elvis our servicer was wonderful! Food was fantastic! Definetly going back!
I love Italian food. My daughter and I make a pretty fine spaghetti a la carbonara, so I was eager to see how AS matched up. It was stupendous, including the preparation in a scooped-out, large round of parmesan. I have never had better. Our starters of fried calamari and shrimp, and our wilted spinach salad were also superb. I regretted that we could not take leftovers back to our hotel. The conclusion to our meal, shared by all, was a velvety smooth panna cotta. My next time in SLC, I will definitely plan a meal at AS.
Sooooo good! Great service. Excellent food. Delicious wine. Cozy atmosphere.
We had a fantastic meal. The carbonara was spectacular.
Another great meal! Love the carbonara prepared tableside!
The food was amazing. Definitely the best italian place in Utah hands down
Was craving Italian and it totally hit the spot. I got the spinach ravioli and it was just what I was craving. Husband got the lasagna. He liked it but i thought it was weird to have shredded beef. The bruschetta could have been crispier with more basil. Caesar salad was delicious.
Great menu of Italian favorites, with a good selection of Italian wines to complement the food. Our server, Jose, was sensitive to our timing, and otherwise attentive. Portions were ample, but not overly generous. Our corner table lacked a view of the ocean, but it was perfect for our birthday celebration. When I made reservations, I noted that it was birthday, and I kind of expected at least a cupcake with one candle, but there was no effort made to celebrate with a complimentary minimal dessert.
Overall, a very enjoyable dining experience.
I have always loved this restaurant but was a little disappointed at the service and seating. We had a reservation and the host seemed surprised and the service seemed off. The food was still very good.
I love the personal touches! Always a great experience here.
It was wonderful!
Love this place! The food is always great, and the service attentive but not intrusive
Wonderful food and our server was excellent!
The Sicilia Mia group of restaurants are all excellent and Antica Sicilia in Millcreek is no different. Excellent food and drink is offered at reasonable prices given the quality. It's one of our go-to places for special occasions and to bring out of town guests.
This is our new favorite Italian place! The food was delicious and we loved the ambiance. Our kids also loved the place. Service was but could have been a bit better. I highly recommend this place. We for sure be coming back often!
We had a great meal and a lot of fun after a long day of meetings. Great food, wonderful waiter, Carlos. My third time here and we’ve loved it every time.
Everything from seafood to spaghetti was excellent.
Always has been good, and we got to know a few more people. Food great, and we look forward to heaters on the patio now that the weather is changing. New patio is fabulous.
We enjoyed our food and service. Food was excellent.
Great food, service and hospitality! Wanted a special place for my sister's birthday and hit it spot on.
Love this restaurant! Had the spaghetti carbonara and it was amazing!
Best Italian food in Utah. Similar menu as their other locations but seems to have more seafood options. Go with the fillet main course and choose a pasta dish for two people to split. Great meal and you will walk away full.