- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
Ring in the New Year with friends & family at Anthony's. Join us for New Year’s Eve with a full Dinner Menu. Please call if your plans change, due to high demand we have a $25/person cancellation fee if within 24 hours. We appreciate your support and understanding.
Everything was exceptional for our night out. I will definitely be dinning here again!
Was best filet I have had and corn side is a must try. Service was great and would go again.
Food was sub-par for the cost. Not at all impressed.
Our server was amazing. She was very knowledgeable and full of energy. Filet was delicious (meted in my mouth) but made it Oscar style and for $17 extra, it wasn’t worth it. Hardly any lobster and tiny asparagus. We enjoyed the bread pudding for dessert and it was so good. Take the time to enjoy dessert
We booked on open table and i called to see if they received my notes to sit outside, the gentleman who answered was very rude. I had called multiple times and no one would pick up the phone. He acted like I was bothering him with my question.
Overall, highly recommend Anthony’s.
Experience was pleasant. Would go back
Fair value side dishes poor Waiter too touchy and pushy
Jake our server was phenomenal! 10/10 Would highly recommend. Great service and excellent dishes and wine.
Went for my anniversary.
Waitress Audrey was very kind and explained the menu to us very well.
Girlfriend and I were thinking that the Broiled Goat Cheese sounded unappetizing until Audrey talked to us about it. 10/10 food and service was amazing. Definitely coming back for the girlfriend’s birthday.
Our first visit, my birthday, Halloween, was fantastic. Can't wait to return. Service, food, drinks all top notch. Hard to believe we had never been there before.
We went to Anthony’s with the intention of wearing our Halloween costumes, having a great meal and a lot of fun. We did all of those things. The wait staff seemed to be having fun right along with us which made the night that much better. We will definitely do this again.
Second visit, first for dinner. We were seated upstairs which felt a little more cozy. Excellent service. Our server, Evan, was prompt, efficient, attentive and just the right amount of personable without lingering too long to chat. We ordered the meatball appetizer, lobster bisque soup, salmon, scallops and a filet, along with the mac/cheese and broccolini sides. All were superb. The only item that was just very good, and not memorable, was the complimentary bread pudding dessert offered to us for a birthday in our party. Highly recommend for any special occasion. Anthony's Chophouse is a beautiful restaurant where everything is done just right.
Loved the ambience, absolutely beautiful. Service was really good, attentive, helpful with suggestions. Honestly, the food was just not great. Spending >$60 on a steak, you expect it to be one of the best you've ever experienced and none of the four of us felt it was. Steaks were prepared fine, but the taste was just not great. Very ordinary. The sides were the same.
Would have loved to write a better review because the staff, facility and location are unmatched.
This meal was in my top ten of all time. Every single thing was perfect I kid you not. The appetizers. The salad. The drinks. The steak. All incredible. Audrey our server was fantastic. The interior is beautiful. It’s the perfect place that makes you feel like you left Indiana and went to a restaurant in another state known for great food.
As a lifelong foodie, I enjoy a nice meal. Our experience at Anthony’s Chophouse tonight was, hands down, the finest dining experience I have ever had. Start to finish it was excellent! From the hostess stand all the way through to our exit and everything in between, it was an amazing experience. We will absolutely be back and we will tell our friends.
Everything was absolutely perfect- deliciously prepared, beautifully served, and the serving staff — top notch!
Very nice, looking forward to coming back! I felt like the menu was a little pricy. I don't mind pricy if the food is delicious and the service is on point - very happy with the service and food.
We go to a different place every Wednesday night for dinner. This was week 22 for us and by far exceeded our expectations. Will definitely return. We had the seafood tower appetizer and split it and it was amazing, our server was fantastic. I believe his name was Craig.
Anthony’s Chophouse continues excellence in service and cuisine. The service from the hostess to the manger is impeccable. Sonja our server was so welcoming and nothing short of perfection. The chef is amazing and took amazing care of our special anniversary dinner. Would highly recommend for any occasion or even just a casual night out for dinner.
The service was great! The food is always good everytime I’m there, never had a complaint!
Our server Jeff was fantastic and we will be asking for him again! This is our favorite go to date night. We can get dressed up and have great drinks and food. If you’re on the fence just go, we love the ambience super sexy and sophisticated but still fun. Enjoy!
Fantastic place... great service, Caitlin was a fantastic server. Excellent place to celebrate an anniversary or birthday.
We had a drink prior to dinner in the rooftop lounge, which was a nice way to start out the evening. Waiter was personable and attentive; however, we were never offered more water, even thought we'd finished the first one. Two dinners arrived quickly, while the third was delayed a few moments, with no reason given. Food was very good -- the filet is a recommendation, but the meal was quite pricey. Noise level is quite high -- we were sat at a table, and there were many times a companion said "huh?" due to the noise level. We went upstairs to see the bar, and it was even more noisy up there, and too crowded around the bar; was surprised to see so many sitting/standing around the bar, as I thought there was a state guideline against it due to Covid. It's not so easy to figure out how to get to the restaurant from the parking garage, and would suggest more signage. Also, $7 for a valet (which would easily become $10 with tip) is insane.
great service and spacing between tables. A treat of a night out.
Celebrating our 21st Anniversary was wonderful
Had a great time with our server, meal and drinks were good.
Phenomenal experience. We went for my wife’s birthday and the food was amazing and hospitality was up there with it. They even gave a us a surprise bread pudding for dessert and some take home house made truffles!! Our waitress, Madeline was so helpful for us seeing as we don’t eat at upscale steakhouses often. Will definitely return!
It’s pricey but it was so good. If you’re willing to spend the money it’s probably the best place to dine in the Indianapolis area. Love that it is family owned too.
Great food and great service !!!
First time here and it great. Fantastic! Food was excellent atmosphere of the restaurant was very cool and the service was the best , our waiter was very knowledgeable, professional, funny and just a pure pleasure. We look forward to returning. Just a wonderful night and meal.
I thought the service while Good was not up to the level that this restaurant should be. The food while Good was not exceptional.
Great dining experience!!!! Justin was an incredible server.
Took my 11 year old and he loved everything there...from the Mussels to the NY strip steak to the Key Lime Cheesecake! My asparagus was outstanding!
The staff at Anthony's make any night out feel like a special occasion. The staff is knowledgeable of the menu and make great recommendations. Aubrey is our favorite waitress!
Food and service was great. Bartender upstairs was our server and was fantastic had great recommendations for food and drinks. Made a few drinks that were his specialty and all were great. Will definitely be going back.
Amazing experience all around! Service was fabulous and good was spot on!
Excellent food and service. Our Experience made our anniversary dinner very special.
Superb service from Sonya
Jeff was fantastic, as always!
Extremely helpful with the menu and the wine selections. Looking forward to next time
House red wine is not good nor was the salmon. Stick with the beef which was very good.
Wonderful service, wonderful food! Jeff was very attentive to all of our needs and had great input for each dish.
Anthony's Chophouse is rated 4.7 stars by 1100 OpenTable diners.
Anthony's Chophouse does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.toasttab.com/anthonys-chophouse/giftcards.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.