Ivy was a wonderful person and gave great service. She gave us good conversation and knowledge of the food. Please, have her be my server every time. Justin food GREAT...drop the mic.😁
A gastronomical experience.
Fantastic food, amazing services and knowledgeable employees.
the atmosphere was awesome and the menu had items and dishes i hadn’t heard of before. madeleine, our server, was so knowledgeable and helpful! great view of the monon and outdoor area right outside the chophouse. looking forward to coming back and trying the bar upstairs!
I was with my wife. We ordered 2 staters and 2 main courses and 2 glasses of wine. First one of the wine Had a cork taste. Starters were so so. we expected better. Main course were horrible. Ordered medium rare meet and we received well done. But the main thing that it was so so so salty! We were not able to finish our plates. Sorry but with this level of price, you cannot serve this level of quality of plates.
So I would not recommend this restaurant
Best restaurant in Northern Indy.
Great ambiance, great service, and great food! Best restaurant in Carmel!!!
Great food and great service. Worth every cent
My wife and I celebrated our anniversary. The steaks were very mediocre for steak house. My wife had to send her steak back three times and they finally took it off the bill. There are so many choices to dine in Carmel area for steaks. This will not be on our list.
Best steak I've ever had. The waiter was incredibly knowledgeable, answered all our questions, and the atmosphere was phenomenal. Great for a high-end date night.
We started at 3up for a drink on a beautiful night. Cocktails were fine, but not great. Service was excellent. The setting was beautiful. Dinner was very good. Overall a great night. Appetizers and wedge were great. My friend's bone-in Ribeye was overcooked. Husband's halibut was overcooked and dry. Overall, a very nice evening out, but not a flawless execution. This price point should result in near flawless.
We had a wonderful dinner at Anthony’s. We were celebrating our anniversary and it was the perfect place. The service was outstanding and the food delicious. We will go back.
Love that Carmel has an upscale restaurant! Our waiter, William was excellent and very knowledgeable about the menu and the cocktails! My only suggestion would be to expand the menu (which I know is very hard to do and you can't please everyone). Maybe add some more vegetarian options!?!? Other than my one suggestion, love this restaurant and the city!!!
I took my fiancé there for our anniversary and they were great! Gave us free champagne right when we sat down and even gave us free desert and to-go sweets for the road. Excellent service. Food was great!
My husband and I had so much fun here for an evening out. Loved it.
Courtney our server, was exceptional and helped make the evening a wonderful experience. The restaurant itself is beautiful, the food was very good and how Courtney made us feel very welcome. We will certainly come again, ask for our special table in Courtney’s section.
Well done Anthonys!
Susan and Pierre Twer
Food was fantastic! Crab cake appetizer was light and flavorful. Wedge was very good with light smoky/bacon flavor. Filet and NY Strip cooked to perfection. Bone marrow butter was a great add-on to the strip. Brussel sprouts added for a great side dish. Bread pudding with light whipped cream was perfectly prepared. Caleb, our server, was one of the best servers we have had at any top-end steakhouse by far. Ambiance was elegant and quiet with low level music as a background. Lighting was perfect. Highly recommend a visit if you have not yet been there. We will be back!
Excellent suggestions by server. Food was very good. Loved the ambiance.
Excellent in every way. While the inside dining area was much more noisy than we like, we went to your outdoor area, where there's a nice view of all the interesting activity around the Moon Trail.
Great service, superb food! Even celebrated a birthday with their bread pudding (for free)!
Awesome, would recommend
The entire experience was top notch! While I have been to Anthony's Chophouse many times, my three friends had not. I was very pleased that they all enjoyed their meals and service so much that they said they want to return with their husbands.
Since I am a cook it takes a lot to impress me. This restaurant absolutely did. The food and service was excellent!!
Really nice looking place but overall not that great. Food was a bit below average for the prices. Highly recommend 3up bar on the rooftop. Wish we would have eaten there instead!
My wife and I had a great date night at Anthony's this weekend. The service was very good, and the food was also very good. We had some of their signature cocktails which were interesting and delicious. The standout food from the evening was the goat cheese appetizer, the NY strip steak and the brussel sprouts. Its great to have this another restaurant of this caliber so close to our home in Carmel.
Way over priced for average at best food.
Great atmosphere and fabulous food!
Very nice evening. Our waiter, Justin was really friendly and professional. Great place, great food. Would recommend.
Outstanding service with a fine dinner. Sarah was a wonderful bartendress and Caleb had the “A” game going too.
We will be back
Overall, this was an excellent evening. The service was especially good (our compliments to our server, Ben). The atmosphere was enjoyable and comfortable. My wife and I commented that this was one of our most pleasant and enjoyable anniversary dinners.
For the quality and taste of the food, it’s very well priced! Best steak and sides I’ve had compared to st Elmo’s and Ruth Chris I would say the chop house is better and lower rates. Service was top notch and second to non. We will def be back
We've been several time and always enjoy it. Keep it up.
We wanted to impress our mother in from Ft Myers and she was wowed by the seafood trio....my flight of beef was out of this world
First time at Anthony’s. Food was delicious. Service was excellent. My husband and I shared the Flight of Beef. Fun way to compare three types of beef.
Aaron was a great server and took great care of us. The food was AMAZING!
Anthony’s was an absolute treat! Our server (Alex) was super attentive but not overbearing, and the entire staff was very welcoming. We were comped 2 glasses of sparkling wine and a dessert for our anniversary, which was a nice touch of hospitality. All of our food was delicious, and we will definitely be back!
Only downside was limited selection of moderately priced wines on the wine bottle list, but cocktails and by the glass were more reasonably priced.
Delicious meal... awesome and professional wait staff, beautiful decor! Lobster bisque is over the top!! Will definitely be returning to dine at Anthony’s Chophouse in the near future!
This place is by far one of the best steakhouses in the Indianapolis area. With a mixture of upscale dining, fantastic customer service, and world class steak offerings I cannot think of a better restaurant on the north side to go to regarding your traditional steak house meal.
We didn't realize it was their 1-year anniversary. We gladly welcomed the champagne and truffles (nice touch.) Bartenders were fast and very helpful. Waiter was on-point. Remembered everyone's name and was there if we needed anything. Even got to meet Tony himself. Great place, great people. We will be back for sure.
Myron was a terrific server. Food was excellent but Myron really made the evening special.