Annie Bailey’s also hosts private events for up to 80 guests in the Conway Room.
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, American cheese, marinara sauce, chipotle ranch
Daiya vegan cheese, bibb lettuce, red onion, tomato, pickle, vegan/gluten-free roll
Steak & Chips
Chef's choice cut, asparagus Guinness herb butter, chips
Service was great! Every food choice was excellent. Be sure to go! You will not be disappointed!
Delicious food and drinks. Prompt service, with friendly waiter and hostess.
Just moved to Willow Valley from FLA and saw what looked like a good pub for a night out after 6 weeks of moving, unpacking etc. The food was good (although the apps overpriced, imho. Limited menu, prices high for what you got, service was slow on Friday night. I will give it another try after the PA dictator (aka gov) allows businesses to either open safely the public will make them fail.
Great meals, friendly servers, nice atmosphere, and a great time had by everyone in our party.
Sunday brunch! All you need to know is Shrimp and Grits. Outstanding!
Love the outdoor dining options here! The screening actually made out experience more pleasant!
Best Irish Pub in town! Hands down (it’s authentic and our go to place). More Irish dishes would make it even better yet.
Since this was first outing to restaurant since March, I chose Annie Bailey’s as the food I had fish & chips.
This was our first time there. The outside area is beautiful and Ashley our server was outstanding. I highly recommend.
Met family in town for wedding
Annie Baileys is amazingly consistent in it's sevice, food quality, ambiance, etc. Rarely ever a hiccup...
We booked and asked for a table on the patio, but we were seated indoors, no ambiance:(
Our normal delicious meals were spoiled due to The mashed potatoes being ice cold! Besides that, Seth our server was great!
Arrived at 3pm outdoor dining was quiet, burgers were very tasty, pleasant waitress, restaurant was clean, we enjoyed everything. Thank you
Great brunch option on the deck. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal!
Fresh food, large portions served by friendly staff. Went for lunch and it was perfect. Also of all restaurants I have visited this place is amazingly clean with not only distance between tables but very nice separators. Felt very comfortable eating there.
They have done a great job taking the necessary precautions in response to the pandemic. The service is always friendly and the food is great.
Awesome food! Great service! Fair prices!
Very limited menu. Food served on dirty metal trays. Fish was inedible and waiter was incompetent. Go somewhere else.
The restaurant does a great job in practicing social distancing. The patio seating was separates by hanging “windows” and the distance was great. For inside dining, they placed clear, tall plastic separators between tables. As for the food, the lamb shepherds pie had a smooth and tasty potato topping, and the lamb and veggies were good. With the fish and chips, the fish tasted fresh and had a good crust. We will definitely return to try other food on the menu.
Great food and service! Very compliant with covid guidelines so feel very safe to eat there.
I went with my parents and it was a good time. The food was excellent and the service was amazing. Our waiter was very kind and brought our food out within 15 minutes. I loved the atmosphere and the outdoor dining was very pretty.
Server was great!! Came for a birthday dinner and food was delicious.
Decor was nice, server did not deduct my dining points, drinks took a while, food was meh.
Everything about Annie Baileys is amazing. I am never disappointed when I go there. It’s my roommate and mine favorite place to get food, drinks, and catch up.
Outdoor seating was pleasant, shady. Waitress was knowledgeable about the beer selection and very accommodating to our requests.
Annie Baileys is a consistently good choice - their service is always just right, it’s bar food, but thoughtfully so, creative cocktails, and we love the patio! And Despite being downtown, we can always find a parking spot no more than a block or two away. We will keep coming back!
Fast & friendly service. Food was very delicious.
Great food. It was clean and although COVID has caused some changes, my experience was not hindered which I appreciated. It felt like an "normal" evening out with friends.
Great food! Great service! Make a reservation & eat on the deck. We had a super time!
Great food and great service even with the virus restrictions in place. And must-eat in Lancaster!!
Service was extremely slow. We were seated for 1/2 hour before our drinks arrived. Throughout dinner we had to ask someone (Manager who was helping seat people) to send our waitress over twice. The ladies room, which has dual TP holders was empty. Makes me think they are not taking the enhanced and additional cleaning seriously. Food was fair.
Dinner with my granddaughter. A very pleasant evening.
Felt very comfortable eating there during the pandemic. Outdoor seating was perfect, staff were all masked. Food was delicious!
The wait staff were awesome and very accommodating, we started with the Irish bread basket and my wife asked for it to be warmed. They toasted the slices on the griddle - amazing. Also we shared the cheese steak egg rolls, they were unbelievably delicious and packed with meat. Finally we shared the Sheppard's Pie and it was very good, the blend of lamb and beef was excellent. Highly recommend this place.
Great service and food. Handling current protocols very well!
Went for brunch. Not really a brunch menu and no list of the traditional brunch drinks . The waiter did his job but no real personal interaction he was as good as if we just had the computerized waiters. Food was decent but the menu was very simple. We do brunch reviews and this is not one we will be returning to but not a bad place for a quick meal. Think it is more of a bar but with the change of rules they are trying to become more restaurant.
We always have a great time at Annie Bailey's! Definitely one of my favorite places to have dinner and drinks in Lancaster. I love the food, the summer drinks on tap and the atmosphere. Each server we have, always helps make our experience so great! Ashley is one of our favorite servers.
Annie Bailey's does offer delivery in partnership with Toast. Annie Bailey's also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (717) 393-4000.
Annie Bailey's is rated 4.7 stars by 756 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.