Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay
blackened seared tuna on wonton crisps, pickled ginger, seaweed salad, wasabi cream and thai garlic
Duck Island Tea
smirnoff orange vodka, conch republic white rum, gordon's gin, rio grande tequila, sweet and sour, orange juice, sprite
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi pasta, Florida lobster, smoked gouda, parmesan bread crumbs
Our server was great but my food was inedible. I didn’t let the server know so that’s on me. I just couldn’t eat it.
We return again and again to Angler and Ale for the delicious food, great service and beautiful view! The hook and cook is wonderful too!
Our Server, Erich was great and it turned out he was the bartender and made AMAZING drinks! Will be back.
Delicious Fish! The Grouper and Hog Fish were delicious.
Good ambience and friendly staff. Food was good. Fish tasted fresh.
Very generous portions nice service
Ask for Patruca as your server. She is great! Helped made our anniversary dinner even more special!
Great place to stop in if you are staying or passing through. We enjoyed the lobster Mac and cheese and the jumbo crab cakes. Wow! Delicious. We also enjoyed our waitress Caitlin who wa a helpful in recommending a few spots I. Key west since we were headed that way. Great food and we are thinking of stopping on the way back through for the tuna tacos.
Our meal at Angler and Ale was excellent. The draft beers were perfect and the food was delicious.
Food wasn’t great. Service was awful. Place is half full and we felt rushed the whole time. Waiter tried giving me someone else’s order thinking I wouldn’t realize. With so many great restaurants in the area really no point in dining here
The food and service are consistently good here !!!!
We enjoyed our dinner at Anglers very much! The food is very fresh with beautiful presentation. Good choice of vegetarian as well. Loved the mocktails! We loved it so much, we went again. Dwayne and Eric took great care if us! Very professional and kind.
Nice setting. Friendly service. Good food! Perfect for a night out with the family. Will definitely return!
Food was terrific. The tuna nachos, coconut shrimp, yellowtail snapper and crab cakes were all suggestions from our server. Our server Caitlin was very knowledgeable about the menu and the beer choices. We were very happy with her suggestions. We had such a good time and were so happy with the food we are going back
We we’re staying at Hawks Cay and made reservations months in adamce for Christmas Eve dinner. We are arrived and didn’t have the option to sit outside which was disappointing and we felt others had option over resort company. We did the Catch your own Fish for dinner which was great but ended up being a more expensive option for a large group.
Excellent food and service. My kids have asked for it every day since we went there.
We caught some yellow tail fishing and the restaurant cooked it. It was delicious. Kim is a dynamite waitress, pleasant, smiling with a great can do attitude.
Will definitely be back!
Food was a little pricey but worth it and it was large portions. Drinks needed more alcohol...sever was excellent
Very nice restaurant with view of the water. Service was excellent
Had dinner out with family while on vacation in the Keys. Waitress very nice, service great and food delicious.
Kisha was a delightful server. The food was outstanding! We will definitely be back.
Disaster struck as the machine went down and they had to hand enter the items... we waited over an hour repeatedly asking for our server to come and take our order unfortunately she was under the impression we had been told about the issue.. anyways it was really disappointing .. and NO APOLOGIES...from anyone...
We absolutely loved our meal at Angler very relaxed. We especially loved our server Basil!
Great! Nope not gonna do it
There is a lot of kid traffic which is to be expected because it's a resort, but the restaurant is REALLY noisy, and they give the kids frisbees. It's difficult to stomach spending $300 on dinner when you have to avoid flying frisbees.
We dined there for an early dinner on a Saturday. The service was great, my skirt steak was amazing and my son loved his pesto chicken, but my husband’s pork chop was flavorless and dry. Now, aside from all that, the entertainment singer was atrocious. I’m not exaggerating. He couldn’t sing, and it was so loud on the outdoor deck we couldn’t hear each other. And I cannot emphasize enough that he couldn’t sing. It made me sad and even two glasses of wine didn’t make it bearable. I beg of you Angler and Ale, please spare other diners the pain.
Outdoor patio is lovely and the view is beautiful!
I felt the restaurant had a unique opportunity to sponsor a true Super Bowl party, but they did not. No discounts or fun football food. Very disappointed. Maybe another year there will be a Super Bowl in Miami and they will embrace it with specials.
The food and service were good but we were seated in a separate room that was very quiet and only a few tables with no atmosphere.
The food was excellent! Our server was busy but went out of his way to be very attentive. We went back for lunch the next day!
Delicious, good service and breathtaking views ! We booked a table outside so could watch the pelicans catching pray and people doing the paddle boards... We really enjoyed !
Great food and a fun and casual place
We had a terrible experience with the host stand. Despite having the same reservations as another party and arriving before them, our reservation was skipped over and they were seated before us. When I asked the host, she said it was “because they had kids”. We also had 3 kids in our party (3, 5 & 7).
Another complaint is that they seem to be out of a lot of their wine & beer selections. We experienced the same thing when visiting the year before.
Food is excellent, but very pricey.. Took close to 1 1/2 hours to get our food. Realize it was their busy season, but maybe that’s when they need to add more chefs. Our waitress was great and we made sure we didn’t complain, because it wasn’t her fault.
Food and atmosphere were wonderful! Our favorite place to eat while on vacation. Our waitress, Kareen, was so attentive and kind. Thank you for such a fun evening and delicious meal!
Good overall food appetizers were just ok! Didn’t care for the crackers with Brie cheese!
Thought it was going to be a bit more upmarket as the food was quite pricey.
My food was tepid had lobster .
Felt a bit canteen like plastic chairs etc
Food was fair atmosphere was loud in a cafeteria kind of way decor was spartan with a few nautical themed accessories thrown in for good measure but it was the service that was so horrendous! Sat there for close to an hour and a half waiting for our food. This in and of itself would not have been too bad if someone would have at least come to check on us. We couldn’t even order additional cocktails while we waited! First bad experience I’ve every had at a restaurant in the Keys.
The shrimp and scallops scampi over linguine was really good. I even ate it the next day for lunch. I would recommend this restaurant.
Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (305) 209-9991.
Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay is rated 4.4 stars by 302 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.