American Cut Steakhouse offers a variety of private events spaces perfect for corporate or social private dining occasions. We offer a selection of private event menus curated to best fit you and your guests’ needs.View Private Dining Details
See availability for bonus point tables
Mon - Thu 5:00PM - 6:30PM 8:15PM - 11:00PM
Fri 5:00PM - 6:30PM 8:45PM - 11:00PM
Sat 5:00PM - 6:30PM 9:30PM - 11:00PM
We had a great time here, the service was great and the food was top notch. We started with a wedge salad and 2 orders of bacon (by far one of the best steakhouse bacon’s I’ve had). I split the Tomahawk for 2 with a friend and the steak was cooked perfect with amazing flavor, the flambé it at the table in compound butter with herbs and clarified butter right before serving it to you. We got the spinach Brussels sprouts and French fries as sides with just some espresso after dinner. They never rushed us, we took our time and enjoyed our meal and got to talk and relax without feeling pressure to clear the table. I’m thoroughly impressed.
Excellent food, expensive but expected, waiter hovered until we ordered which not appreciated given we were there to discuss business. Then they misplaced a checked overcoat for twenty minutes. Mistakes happen but feeling rushed is unacceptable.
Decent food, but horrible service. We arrived at 7:55pm for our 8pm reservation, but still had to wait a half our to be seated. The wait staff was inattentive and it took two hours to be served our main course and we were only a party of four people.
Overall the restaurant did an amazing job! The food was superb and the service was top notch! Will definitely be coming back here for special occasions again!
Came here on a date with my boyfriend and everything was outstanding from start to finish. The hostess, staff and our waiter Jared could not have been nicer or more accommodating. They really rolled out the red carpet! Jared went over the top to make it one of the most special and memorable dates we've ever been on. Aside from the service being 5 star, the food was equally as incredible. We ordered everything that Jared recommended, and he hit it out of the park. The tomahawk steak, the chili lobster app and the "tipsy scoop" desserts are must-orders! Such an amazing amazing meal and overall experience. We already can't wait to come back!
American Cut is one of our favorite restaurants for an impromptu date night. The food never disappoints and the service is amazing. Jared is THE BEST server! He gave awesome recommendations for items we had not yet tried.
From the moment we stepped in everyone was friendly& attentive,excllent service,knowledgeable staff,food was amazing,I went to this place with my steak of the month group,6 guys we can be pretty loud but we fit right in comfortably seated,the place is not stuffy or pretentious,excellent ambiance,the sides were some of the best in the city& the steaks were great!! Definitely a place to recomend& return,great dining experience.
We could have made those incredible rolls a meal and left happy. The whole experience was outstanding. Our waiter and the manager were incredibly helpful and always had smiles. We shared the Octopus which was extremely tender and the excellent Raviolini special app. We had two delicious entrees one being the 8oz filet mignon with seared foie gras and the cedar plank salmon. Cauliflower with capers and raisins rounded out the meal. Perfectly cooked beef and moist salmon. Next time we'll share the crackerjack sundae but we were so full we opted for something "lighter" the apple quince cobbler. Our first time here and definitely will not be the last. We recommend both the smoken penecillin and spicy margarita.
I ordered the smoked old fashioned bc I’d raved about it being done table side at the midtown location. They didn’t do that, which was very disappointing and it also was no where near as good. The service really was a bit lacking, I’ll probably stick to midtown. It was ok, but not what it should have been...they didn’t even say anything about the 40th bday we were celebrating that was noted on the rez..
I thoroughly enjoy the experience at American Cut. The staff, the food, the service and the management are first class. Paige, the general manager, is charming and professional. Gabriel, the bartender, is wonderful and my date thought he was extremely handsome. The food is excellent. Hats off and well done!
We had a great evening, the food was good and the waiter very nice and friendly.
The food was a bit too salty for us and the spinach could be made with less fat. Nevertheless it was still very good and tasty.
After a bumpy start (forgotten about and left at the bar for 30 mins) the team really pulled out all stops to impress. Friendly attentive service and delicious food, so much that we couldn’t get close to finishing. Hands down the best shrimp cocktail I’ve had, enough horseradish to start a fire! Steak cooked to perfection and expertly carved and flambéed tableside. Desserts the final nail in the coffin. Don’t hesitate, just book it
This was one of the best meals I have had in a while. The only thing that surpassed the service was the food! If you get there and they have the pork belly app - try it, the glazed carrot and cauliflower sides were exquisite, the steak was perfectly cooked and delicious. And the cracker Jack sundae was to die for. It was expensive but totally worth it!
Service here was fantastic. They catered to our occasion (birthday dinner) perfectly. All of the food dishes we had were delicious. I think I was most surprised by the portions of food, which were much larger than I expected! We ended taking some food home because we just couldn't eat any more. We were very happy with our dinner here!
This is the ultimate dining experience especially with Jarod as our waiter. He was not only very professional but very attentive to our needs. His recommendations were right on target. Everything was delicious. It made for a wonderful 65 th birthday dinner!! The sommelier made an excellent pick of wine at a reasonable price!! All in all it was s very pleasurable experience and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this restaurant to anyone!!
Great steaks and side dishes. Friendly and helpful service.
My boyfriend took me to this lovely restaurant for my birthday, and we loved everything about the restaurant. The waiter, Jared was amazing and very informative. The food was absolutely delicious! I would honestly recommend this restaurant everyone.
Back for a second time and this time was better than the last. The service and food were very very good. Seeing as we live in the Nabe will be back soon.
I wanted to love American Cut as I have heard good things about it. Well first I will say, I enjoyed my sides and the bread however the steak left a lot to be desired. The waiter who served us was fantastic but given the lacking steak, I wouldn’t return there again for that.
American Cut Tribeca was an amazing experience. The restaurant is beautiful the food was delicious and the service was on point. I recommend this place for any occasion. Love love love!!!
Restaurant week menu was AMAZING! Large portions of food for a great price. Waited about 20-25minutes to be seated with a reservation, but host was nice enough to offer drinks on the house for the wait. The service while seated was great! Made sure drinks were filled without asking and made the experience that much better. Steak was cooked to perfection and melted in my mouth. Overall had an amazing experience and can’t wait to go back.
Excellent restaurant and outstanding service. The food is superb and the restaurant is beautiful. Definitely as must try!!
The food, wine and service was amazing, except for the hostess in the beginning. But the rest was worthy.
Music was too loud but the ambiance and energy is good.
Best filet in the city. A New York steakhouse with a twist. Service was outstanding.
I went with some family for Restaurant Week. The pork belly appetizer was delicious, though the sauce was a bit overpowering for those of us who had it. One of my cousins had the lobster bisque and really enjoyed it. The steaks were prepared correctly and were tasty. I would not say that this was the best steak we've ever had, and the portion size was just okay. I found no fault with either of the sides (collards, potatoes) in taste or portion. The desserts were tasty but again underwhelming with portion size.
The staff is great! The steak was perfect cooked and their signature Cracker Jack Sunday is awesome!
The food at American Cut was phenomenal, and the ambiance was sophisticated.
Definitely pricey, but a good splurge for a birthday, anniversary or other special occasion.
My party hated the table we were given, a guest in our party had a dairy allergy. We requested non dairy items for her and needed a non dairy steak sauce which we were told would be brought out. They brought au poivre steak sauce...which contained dairy! My steak came out cooked to the incorrect temperature. The manager decided to bring us a complementary dessert which they charged us for on our bill! A dessert that no one even wanted. We just ate a whole meal...where are we putting an extra dessert? Just an overall mediocre experience. This used to be one of my favorite restaurants.
When I said well done , man oh man ...amazing
I had left a note in the online reservation that it was a special occasion (birthday), and confirmed it 3 times leading up to our reservation, but there was no acknowledgement of that. Was excited for a nice birthday dinner, but ended up with a pretty average dinner. Server was friendly, food was decent, ambiance was great, but overall not too satisfied with the experience - nothing really set it apart from other steakhouses I've been to.
Very good food along with fine service. Portions were rather small on the proteins. Room was loud enough to be fun not so loud that you could not talk.
We left the restaurant after receiving our appetizer. The food came out less then 2 min from ordering so there was no time to even make it fresh and it looked and tasted like it had been plated that morning and sitting in a fridge all day.
Wonderful service. Good food selection (restaurant week), amazing ambiance
Loved everything except the Caesar salad — which I thought was way over lemoned. Great atmosphere and roomy tables.
It was AMAAAAAZING!!!
Went for restaurant week. The food was very good and came quickly. However we did have to wait almost an hour after our reservation to be seated, which they were apologetic for.
Everything was phenomenal from the service to the food.. As a chef I must say I really appreciated the experience and am looking forward to returning to this restaurant. Well done Chef Forgione!
Our service was poor. The waiter was nice enough but bringing additional bread took 1/2 hr, bringing the right side dish took until the meal was completed, an order for wine or coffee was never taken. Also, there were so many servers coming over to the table, that we never knew who was really in charge.
The filet mignon was good as were the rolls. The skate was mediocre at best and I would not recommend the thai basel sorbet, I couldn't eat it.
Overall this is an overpriced restaurant that at best has mediocre food and service.