On vacation with the family and ate at agave. Food was amazing. Service outstanding and drinks on par. Highly recommend.
Make reservations early!
Hostess Amy was great!
Our experience was average. Food was ok. Black Beans were extremely salty to the point where they couldn’t be eaten. Service was slow but that seemed to be the case at most restaurants were visited on the island. I ordered shrimp fajitas which came with 4 tortillas but only 5 shrimp……. Enough for 1and 1/4 shrimp for each fajita. My husband had steak fajitas and had way to much meat for his 4 tortillas. For the most part food was good but stay away from the black beans🙁
Great food, great atmosphere, but pricy! However, weaning is pricy in St. Thomas, so it’s not out of the ordinary.
Slooooooow! 1 hour and 45 minutes into dining, we received our entrees. Really yummy dinner but really long wait. The manager did comp our drinks.
I have never written a poor review before but the place was awful from start to finish. The only positive was the queso was amazing. The manager was a lanky fellow who resembles Gabe from the show the office. He was SO rude and condescending. He seemed annoyed he had to finish his conversation with his friends at another table with our server. so we could get some drinks. My daughter’s Diet Coke tasty funny and she told him that. He rudely said “I don’t know what funny means. Can you be more descriptive?” I told him my child didn’t know the molecular make up of the soda, she knew it just tasted off. He said he checked the line and it was fine, the server told us the syrup was low and that was the issue. Not if my kids barely ate their food because of a weird white sauce on everything that tasted like sour cream with sugar in it. Just disgusting. Do not eat here. Food was not edible and service was awful and the place was loud.
Good food here, no question. Atmosphere more loud 'TGIFridays' style than laid back tropics. Service all smiles and friendly, but here the Island vibe shows through with slow and spotty. I suggest take out!
Agave was amazing and the service was flawless. Lilly was my server and she always made sure that I was never out of drinks and my food was cooked to order but fast. I am a Chef myself and I love good food. Hats off to the back of the house for some great tasting food. The specials was more than worth it. Hats off to the front of the house for a clean restaurant and lovely ambience. I definitely will be going back.
Very good experience, the food was delicious and service was impeccable! Would definitely come back and highly recommend. The guac was a good size, Crunchwrap supreme was really good and steak fajitas were amazing. Prices were also so reasonable.
Hostess was amazing, wish she was our waitress. Service was slow when we were waiting for our bill. It was busy though. Food was very good. Nice ambiance, but a little loud.
Food was fantastic, but service was not the best. My meal was brought out and they only brought out the toppings for my husband’s fajitas. He had to hunt down someone to get the actual steak for the fajitas. This was about 15 minutes after I received my meal.
Food was fairly priced and was excellent quality and delicious.
Long wait for food to come to the table and it was cold. Had to send back to get reheated.
Best Mexican food I've ever had. Really. Flavors delicious
Great meal and ambiance. The bartender Shawn was amazing! He was right there with a delicious cocktail and excellent service he was fast and knowledgeable and courteous and professional. We highly recommend going to agave and sitting in Shawns section! We will specifically ask for Shawn the next time we go there.
Decided to pop in after our car ferry ride back from St John. Very very good. Highly recommend. I had a burrito bowl and it was so so good.
Great drinks great food
Excellant Margarita, good queso, tasty tacos and Rice bowls. Very happy to have good Mexican food in Red Hook!
Great happy hour margaritas and appetizers! Fast, friendly service,
The restaurant was packed and there didn’t seem to be enough waitstaff so the service was slow. We sat outside which probably didn’t help. We ordered the nachos which came out cold. The fajitas were good though and they came out hot. Drinks were good but slow to arrive… This place, at least when we visited, was on island time :-)
Food and service was outstanding! My group and I will come back to Saint Thomas just for Agave. 10/10 would recommend.
No waiter turned up to serve us or even great us at our table. We got our chips and salsa over an hour after ordering it after complaining. The rest of the food took even longer.
Luckily the bartender was saved the day and started helping us
We came here given the good reviews on TripAdvisor and we actually regretted the decision. First we arrived on time for our reservation and they took quite a bit of time to give us a table, we then waited for 15-20 minutes for anybody to approach us for a drink. The waiters were not particularly busy but yet everything we ordered took a very long time even beers. We ordered the ceviche at the recommendation of the waiter and it was mostly vegetables and almost no fish nor flavor, it was tasteless and terrible to the point that we return it. The shrimp tacos were good but each taco only had two shrimps in total which was pitiful. The street corn was OK but the corn seemed really overcooked and the best part of the whole meal where the fried plantains which were excellent. I must admit that the waiter removed the charge for the ceviche. This is really not a good restaurant and I am in awe to read the reviews from previous customers. Don’t waste your time since within walking distance there are multiple other restaurants that are much better.
Service here was horrible. Our drinks and food sat on the counter out of the kitchen for 10+ minutes before the waitress brought it to the table. We ordered Sangrias and also would not recommend that, they were just wine with juices shaken up instead of any real fruits. The food was okay, but generally I wouldn’t go back here
I loved everyone and the food was outstanding and can’t wait to come back there very soon
Great food!. You could tell they were short staffed but our server was great. Drinks were good, tons of options
Another great dining experience at Agave. Best happy hour on the island!
Tasty food with a lot of flavor and the service was excellent. The cucumber magarita and the red sangria were both yummy.
Excellent food. We sat outside which was entertaining as well as exasperating. Go for inside seating. Staff were great if not a bit harried.
Ok, I grew up in So. Cal., so I know a thing or two about Mexican food.....Agave hit it out of the park. Absolutely everything we ordered was outstanding’
I first will say that the food was very good. We had reservations for 6:15. They called me 10 times before then to see if we were coming. When we arrived I told the hostess that we had a 6:15 reservation. She rolled her eyes at me, annoyed that We were there I’m assuming and took us to our table. Our waitress was very nice. We all ordered the Crunchwrap which was excellent. Get the street corn!!! It’s amazing!!!
Food and service was excellent!
Great food!! Had a delicious dinner! Will be back
They were very busy but our waitress Meg was awesome, so was the bartender. Food was good, came out quick and hot.
The salsa and cheese dip are both incredible! Coupled with those amazing chips, I didn’t even need anything else to eat! But, we had the chicken enchiladas as well, and wow. A whole new level of Mexican. Loved everything about the food, the waitress was always attentive and took great care of us, and the atmosphere was amazing. I loved all the details, the vines on the wall, the beautiful leaf chandelier over the bar, the copper sconces throughout. The prices were very reasonable for the quality and freshness. We were sat right away and everything was clean and comfortable.
The host was great , service outstanding and the food was amazing. Highly recommend this place
Very festive restaurant - great food, marvelous margaritas, fun environment, fast service, friendly & accommodating staff. I will definitely visit again! A+
Food was very good. Our waitress was excellent, very friendly and attentive.
However, the hostess wasn’t friendly or helpful at all. She didn’t escort us to our table, she just pointed to our table. Overall dinner was very good. Would recommend and return!
We were late to the restaurant because of a taxi issue but they were able to seat once we arrived. Our server was Maggen who was great.
Get the Crunchwrap Extreme!! AMAZING!!
Love Agave. Our fave on the island.
Agave offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (340) 714-7874 ext. 14.
Agave is rated 4.5 stars by 111 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.