- Waitstaff wear masks
Truffled Prime Rib Eye
grilled baguette, 90-day beef garum, creamed wild mushrooms, black truffle, chives
Jumbo Diver Scallops
Py 'Wedge' Salad
our bacon lardons, fresh + dried tomato, soft egg, crispy shallot, buttermilk-blue cheese dressing
Thanksgiving Dinner Special Menus & Offers
3 Course Dinner for $75, Call for reservations. 3 PM-8PM
We arrived 20 minutes for our 6:30pm reservation and they wouldn't sit us. They said they had to sit the reservations that were made for 6:15pm first, but there were plenty of open tables in the restaurant. It took almost a half hour to get the bottle of wine we ordered. The manager had the bottle in front of her and was staring at us but stated she didn't know what table it was going to. The waiter had a helper, but only to bring bread and clear off the table. The helper should had been used for additional tasks, letting bring drinks and checking on us to make sure our meal was fine. We ordered drinks and 20 minutes later the waiter stopped by to say the drinks were on their way. What took 20 minutes to make 2 drinks? We could see the bar from our table and it wasn't busy. It seemed like the waiter was casually doing his job.
Couldn’t have asked for a better experience anywhere, so glad we chose to celebrate our anniversary here! Food, drinks and service were all exceptional, we will be back
My wife and i were celebrating an important anniversary and decided to eat at PY's. It had been 2-3 Yrs since we had been there and thought we've give it another chance.
Service was good, we ordered onion rings as a appetizer and they were cold. The rings are prepared and kept refrigerated and there out of the 9 onion rings were ice cold with raw dough.
We ordered drinks and drinks were okay.
I ordered the scallops and my wife ordered the asparagus and cauliflower for dinner. The first scallop I cut into was raw and not cooked. The other scallops were done and i showed the waiter and had them send them back.
And that was our beautiful dinner!!!!!
The manager never came over to appologize or make it right. Waiter took it off the ticket.
So I guess we won't be back for a long while.
Too bad.......looks like they'd have some good food. Just need better cooks and head chief to over see the meals coming out.
The $48 ribeyes were terrible, fatty and super chewy….portions of everything were huge, so we didn’t finish anything; mushroom risotto was over cooked and gluey; service was not great…overall, overpriced mediocre food, wouldn’t recommend..
First time there... for a business dinner and it was perfect! Great service and food - perfect steaks and good reasonable wine list! :-)
We always try to go there for their Prime Rib special and special priced wine whenever we can. Blanchie is our favorite server - she is super friendly, very attentive, and we love having her as our server. The food as always was delicious as was the wine.
Good, hot bread to start, herbed butter. Baked oysters kind of shriveled up. Prime rib was tough, more like a choice cut, not a prime cut. Expected much better.
Thanks for outstanding service! Our daughter just received her first official job offer and when I added that note to my reservation I didn’t expect to be noted, however, our server greeted us with a “congratulations on your first job opportunity”. That set the tone for an amazing evening. Thanks again
Great for our anniversary celebration. Nice touch with a complimentary desert decorated for the occasion. Service at the table was perfect. Waitress friendly and helpful. Food was excellent. There seemed to be some confusion when seated. We were a little early and waited (prob 5-7 minutes) past our reservation time while three Hostesses (?) were trying to ready a table for 2.
Food was OK. Great food presentation but waiter was not familiar with dishes. For the price we paid ($240) I was expecting a memorable dinner experience which did not happen.
3 of us got 7oz Filet Mingon, all 3 were overcooked and dry.
Nice place to celebrate special occasions! Would recommend PY to friends. We will be back!
The service was great. The salad, potatoes and bread great. However, the prime rib was chewy . It was medium rare as requested.
Started with grilled then chilled shrimp cocktail which were amazing ,also ordered the onion rings which were cooked almost perfect in clean oil you could just tell had new york strip cooked perfectly so no complaints needed no sauce, service was awesome no complaints there either real small area so not to big
I was disappointed by the timing and quality of the food and service especially for the star rating. Several things were not to specifications or expectations. Requested steak “done-ness”, potato temp and service after asking for a warm up amounted to forgetfulness and not addressing the issues quickly. The server tried to make amends, but it just could not make up for the disappointment. So sorry to say.
The prime rib is delicious! Friendly & fast service. Beautiful restaurant.
Excellent attentive service, prime rib was perfect and the price was right. Love the mashed potatoes as well.
I’ve dined at PY many times and I have never been disappointed!
Food and service are always OUTSTANDING! I highly recommend it.
The food and service was great, nice experience.
The staff is extremely professional and very attentive. Presentation of the food is very appealing. The food itself was fantastic - probably the best filet I have ever had!
Wonderful 3-course dinner, all of which was excellently prepared, and delivered. The food was very good and the wine pairings were right on!
My husband made reservations for our 20th Wedding Anniversary. It was wonderful from start to finish! Highly Recommend!!
I have ordered the Cippino a few times, the fish was over cooked and the octopus was missing. When I asked the food runner “Isn’t there supposed to be octopus in this?” He told me “no”.
Non mi piace!
What an outstanding place! The food, drinks, and service was spectacular!
I ordered a glass of wine from the menu and it wasn't available. I ordered the scallops but they were so overcooked they were inedible. I was with two other guests and the waiter did not return to our table until they had completed their meal so I did not ask for a replacement meal just for me. I looked forward to this night as a birthday dinner. So disappointed.
Best prime rib in town for the price and everything is top shelf .
Wonderful evening, the staff was great along with the food…..
The food and service is excellent. The seafood tower is amazing and the creme brûlée dessert was delicious. You won’t be disappointed.
My husband and I try to go at least once a month to the steakhouse. We always have outstanding service and wanted to share the experience with our daughter and her husband for her 32nd birthday.
Sadly it wasn’t the great experience we always are custom to. The service was slow and the presentation of each entree was not what we are accustomed to. They never brought our salts to the table. Our waiter was inattentive he seemed to be new. My margarita which was supposed to be with Patron had no liquor in it at all. Overall the meal itself was slightly cold but delicious.
Always an excellent experience. Food is always great as is the service.
Everything was good can not think of anything to complain about thanks for the good food and service
Had overcooked , dry shrimp for appetizer and cold baked potato as a side and for dessert a chocolate layer cake that had several thick layers of icing a few very thin layers of cake.
I don’t know what has happened to PY, it was our place to go for all of our special occasions but not anymore.
It was FANTASTIC! The food, the drinks, everything!
However, one minor detail that was disappointing to me. I asked for the Birthday plate with the dessert and got a plain plate. Nothing major but to me that was to be the highlight. Other than that, EVERYTHING WAS FANTASTIC!
Overall the food was very good for the value other than the appetizer we ordered. It was a corn dish which was to say the least VERY OVER PRICED. It was $14 for a TEENY portion of corn with a sauce. Honestly I would not have paid $5.00 for it, as it was so minuscule.
The prime rib meal was very good and the service very good.
Everything was superb. Pricing a little high but food was fantastic. Little extras made the experience very special. Will go back for special,occasions. Ordered filet medium and was probably closer to rare but very good.
Very nice atmosphere for a fancy, celebratory dinner. Our servers were excellent! We loved the bread basket, the drink tasters, and the Chef's complimentary sample, the details were thoughtful and especially tasty. We enjoyed the Prime Rib plate on Wednesday evening; make your reservations early for this specialty night. Expect your plates to be a little pricey but worth the extra dollars for our special occasion. The scallops and the filet mignon were also wonderful choices - and my mom is super picky! She loved her dinner and sorbet dessert. We'll definitely be back.
Decent menu and quality ingredients, but the execution is lacking.
We had reservations at 8...showed up at 7.45...dining room virtually empty..had to stand outside until 8...found that extremely odd and rude. This incident marred the whole evening
This is the second time where there were Flys around our table. Otherwise everything was great.
PY Steakhouse is rated 4.4 stars by 1822 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.