Key West New Year's Eve Restaurant Reservations

How are Featured results ranked

The default order for search results reflects a number of factors, including table availability, restaurant location, search criteria, and restaurant reviews and ratings. In addition, payment made by a restaurant to OpenTable is also a factor for the relative ordering of restaurants.

• 

  Red Shoe Island Bistro

  

  Exceptional

  (33) Review - Red Shoe Island Bistro

  American Key West

  Booked 4 times today

  • 6:30 PM Reserve at Red Shoe Island Bistro
  • 6:45 PM Reserve at Red Shoe Island Bistro
  • 7:00 PM Reserve at Red Shoe Island Bistro
  • 7:15 PM Reserve at Red Shoe Island Bistro
  • 7:30 PM Reserve at Red Shoe Island Bistro

  BRING IN THE NEW YEAR AT RED SHOE ISLAND BISTRO, JUST STEPS AWAY FROM THE RED SHOE DROP ON DUVAL. MAKE RESERVATIONS EARLY AND ENJOY YOUR PRE FESTIVITIES DINNER,
• 

  Azur

  

  Exceptional

  (1487) Review - Azur

  Mediterranean Key West

  Booked 25 times today

  • 6:30 PM Reserve at Azur
  • 6:45 PM Reserve at Azur
  • 7:00 PM Reserve at Azur
  • 7:15 PM Reserve at Azur
  • 7:30 PM Reserve at Azur

  AZUR welcomes you and your loved ones to bring in the New Year with us! Offering a special dedicated menu. Cancellation policy does apply due to high demand.
• 

  Martin's

  

  Exceptional

  (741) Review - Martin's

  European Key West

  Booked 6 times today

  • 6:00 PM* Reserve at Martin's Opens a modal dialog
    Seating Options

    Standard

    Outdoor
  • 6:30 PM* Reserve at Martin's Opens a modal dialog
    Seating Options

    Standard

    Outdoor
  • 7:00 PM* Reserve at Martin's Opens a modal dialog
    Seating Options

    Standard

    Outdoor
  • 7:30 PM* Reserve at Martin's Opens a modal dialog
    Seating Options

    Standard

    Outdoor
  • 8:00 PM* Reserve at Martin's Opens a modal dialog
    Seating Options

    Standard

    Outdoor

  Our NYE Dinner is a 4 courses at $145 pp plus tax and gratuity. 1st: amuse-bouche, 2nd: appetizer, 3rd: entree, 4th: dessert. Please note that due to local restrictions, all patrons must be out of the building by 10 PM.
• 

  Antonia's

  

  Exceptional

  (1187) Review - Antonia's

  Italian Key West

  Booked 15 times today

  • 6:30 PM Reserve at Antonia's
  • 6:45 PM Reserve at Antonia's
  • 7:00 PM Reserve at Antonia's
  • 7:15 PM Reserve at Antonia's
  • 7:30 PM Reserve at Antonia's

  Please be aware that on NYE night, we are featuring a special menu. The Regular menu will not be available on this night. We will be offering a Prix Fixe menu that includes four courses. 1st soup or salad, 2nd appetizer, 3rd entree, 4th dessert the cost is $125.00 plus tax and gratuity per person.
• 

  Hard Rock Cafe - Key West

  

  Awesome

  (143) Review - Hard Rock Cafe - Key West

  American Key West

  Booked 2 times today

  • 6:30 PM Reserve at Hard Rock Cafe - Key West
  • 6:45 PM Reserve at Hard Rock Cafe - Key West
  • 7:00 PM Reserve at Hard Rock Cafe - Key West
  • 7:15 PM Reserve at Hard Rock Cafe - Key West
  • 7:30 PM Reserve at Hard Rock Cafe - Key West

  Make plans to be on Duval Street for New Year's Eve and ring in the New Year with us at Hard Rock Cafe!
• 

  Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge

  

  Exceptional

  (495) Review - Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge

  Contemporary French / American Islamorada

  Booked 15 times today

  • 6:30 PM Reserve at Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge
  • 6:45 PM Reserve at Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge
  • 7:00 PM Reserve at Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge
  • 7:15 PM Reserve at Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge
  • 7:30 PM Reserve at Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge

  Pierre’s Restaurant will be serving dinner NYE* A credit card is required to reserve * If you have any questions or would like to reserve, you may contact (305) 664-3225..We look forward to ringing in the New Year with you!
• 

  Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo

  

  Awesome

  (182) Review - Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo

  Creole Key Largo

  Booked 11 times today

  • 6:30 PM Reserve at Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo
  • 6:45 PM Reserve at Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo
  • 7:00 PM Reserve at Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo
  • 7:15 PM Reserve at Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo
  • 7:30 PM Reserve at Calusa at Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo

  Join us and celebrate the New Year at Calusa featuring a prefixed menu paired with Mumm Cordon Rouge Brut Champagne.
• 

  Shor American Seafood Grill at The Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa

  

  Awesome

  (521) Review - Shor American Seafood Grill at The Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa

  American Key West

  Booked 5 times today

  Find next available

  At the moment, there’s no online availability within 2.5 hours of 7:00 PM.

  Ring in the New Year at Shor with a 4-Course Holiday menu for $95 per person. Discounts and specials and are not honored on holidays or special events. The regular dinner menu will not be offered. Please contact the restaurant for more information.

Some restaurants were not shown as they do not have availability matching your search criteria