Excellent evening and fresh local seafood
Great overall experience, starting with welcoming, knowledgeable and outstanding service from our waiter Pavel. The steaks were of high quality, but not top tier. Overall a very nice dining experience at a great location in Key West.
Best veal chop I've ever had. Oysters above expectations. And tuna tataki also took my breath away. Exceptional experience, not to mention great service.
16th anniversary! First time dining at Prime... did not disappoint. Previous reviews sited lack of crab in She Crab Soup, it’s there this is not a soup featuring lump crab by design so be fore warned if that’s what you’re looking for go to Hogfish for the lobster bisque. Wanted the anti-pasto but it is no longer on the menu, that was disappointing. Shared “the stack” and it was awesome, they split it for us so it was not difficult to enjoy. Order the porterhouse eat the fillet side and take the strip home. Truffle Mac n cheese is good but not mind blowing. Hubby had fillet and didn’t need the knife. Highly recommend in what can be a wasteland of subpar service, fine dining actually does exist in Key West.
Birthday Great food and service
Excellent setting, staff & food. Felt genuinely welcomed as we arrived even with baby in stroller!
This is the BEST restaurant we have eaten thus far. Kim was very hospitable. Made some good recommendations. The food was superb. The place ambience was excellent. The bar selection and drinks were plentiful. Pricey but worth it completely. Thanks for a great experience.
The food was amazing, came out quick & accurate. The waiter was good but unfortunately the waiter was doing all the tables on the outside terrace and we weren’t really given any attention. It took awhile between courses to order dessert or get the check
Wonderful meal and excellent service. Our server Tony was fantastic. Our favorite Key West restaurant!
Everything was excellent! Great food, atmosphere & service!
Excellent quality food, wine and cocktails plus great service. A classic steak house atmosphere.
Excellent food and service.
We were vacationing in Key West and came to Prime for my birthday dinner. I noted in my Open Table reservation it was my birthday and Prime went above and beyond service wise to help us celebrate. The food was excellent - traditional steakhouse menu (was in need of a non seafood meal at this point in the trip!) Our server was very attentive and very good. Prime Steakhouse is a terrific fine dining steakhouse option in Key West
Had to send my steak back twice. Both times it came out raw. Didn't want to wait for a third try since the others in our party were almost finished with dinner. Manager did what she could to make up for the inconvenience.
Nicole, the manager came down to find us when our taxi driver dropped us at the sign for the restaurant. My spouse is in a wheelchair and all we saw were stairs. When I called Nicole came right to our aid and helped the taxi driver learn where to bring guest. The restaurant, food and staff were beyond amazing. Our server Alex was so nice and attentive. My yellowtail snapper with jumbo lump crab was outstanding. My spouse's filet was delicious! This restaurant is 5 star all the way! The cocktails were also delicious. We were so impressed that we will be telling all of our friends to eat at this restaurant on their next visit to Key West! Thanks everyone for making our evening so special!
The food was good, the staff was accommodating, the no-see-em bugs were a bit bothersome, but the staff was willing to move us inside. The only downside was that they got busy after our dinner was served, so getting any follow-up, even the check was frustratingly slow. A request for coffee seem like an imposition, although the server did brew a delicious fresh pot.
Dinner for 2 on the "patio" at 7pm that overlooked the pool bar next door. Hostess was super friendly. We had 2 servers... The first was so-so and the second was exceptionally friendly/professional/helpful. Not sure why our 1st server disappeared but glad they did. The bone in filet was phenomenal. The yellow tail snapper was great. The green beans with teriyaki sauce was disappointing (the sauce was overwhelming). The view of the pool bar was obnoxious. I'd recommend sitting inside and trying the bone in filet but wouldn't highly recommend trying this place at all... there are other places.
While in Key West for vacation a Local recommended Prime. Food was great, (I had the Ribeye, Wife had Filet and Lobster, special mention regarding sautéed green beans with onion and bacon) service was excellent, good wine menu. Looking for a great meal and want to take the night off from Duval Street, Prime in Key West will not disappoint.
Phenomenal as always!! So spectacular service, food & atmosphere!! Love it here !!!
Great place, food and service was great , highly recommended
Great Staff!! The she crab soup is out of this world!!
Top notch dining. Prime 951 is easily in the top 3 restaurants in Key West. Exquisite menu, food, service, and ambiance. Great wine and cocktail list. I have tried 75% of the menu items and was overly pleased with every dish that left the kitchen.
Good but way too much dressing on Caesar salad. Wish the had a petite filet. Meat portions are quite large. Waiters were very attentive. Not the best steakhouse I have been to but probably the best in KeyWest.
Great service n food. A true cow palace. Best in Key West.
I was looking for a great steak house in fla. I found it in key west. Prime was fabulous. Sides service steak drinks. It was all wonderful. I am from ny and in ny peter lugers is my no 1. Prime is well worth the price.
Steaks were pretty good. Wine list was WAAAAAAAY overpriced.
The ambiance was nice inside but it was very loud. Could not carry on a conversation. Food was average. Our meals were under cooked. Given the price I would have expected better. Service was good. There are better restaurants in the area that you can have a better and less expensive meal.
awesome time! went for a double birthday for friends turning 40. Amazing waitress, amazing food and amazing ambience. All the way around a great experience. They even had special birthday menus made. will go every time we visit now.
Was really disappointed. Since it was so highly rated for romance I thought an outdoor table would be nice. The outdoor dining area had all the romance of eating at a cheap metal table in the parking area of a strip mall (which it very nearly was).
Maybe eating indoors would have been nicer, but there's way too many charming, romantic places to eat in Key West to bother finding out on another trip.
On the plus side the staff were nice.
Food was average at best.
Food was good.
One hour to get my dish ! !
Something wrong in the kitchen !
Great food and great service. Food was a bit pricey.
Sat at bar. Tony was terrific. Hostesses were all very friendly. Food was excellent.
Not our favorite
Just OK. Stone crab was a special and a little fishy. Not Joes in Miami Beach. She crab soup was great. We three had filet mignon wit bone in and all we raw in the center. Ordered medium rare. Went back and charred outside still raw. Creamed spinach was full leaves with a floury cream sauce with raw garlic. Didn’t eat it. Desserts were good. Not what we expected for a 500$ dinner with tip and wine.
First time going there and everything exceeded all expectations.
Wonderful restaurant. Delicious food and great service
Our waiter was great! He had very good knowledge of the items on the menu and so he made excellent recommendations! My beef carpaccio was very good but way too many diced tomatoes. Shrimp cocktails were excellent with great horseradish sauce. Steaks were good. My yellow tuna Oscar style was delicious!
Food was fantastic! A bit pricey but for an occasion it was worth it.
It was my birthday and they were nice enough to seat us in a private room, as well as give us a free key lime pie for my birthday. Amazing service.