I was looking for a great steak house in fla. I found it in key west. Prime was fabulous. Sides service steak drinks. It was all wonderful. I am from ny and in ny peter lugers is my no 1. Prime is well worth the price.
Steaks were pretty good. Wine list was WAAAAAAAY overpriced.
The ambiance was nice inside but it was very loud. Could not carry on a conversation. Food was average. Our meals were under cooked. Given the price I would have expected better. Service was good. There are better restaurants in the area that you can have a better and less expensive meal.
awesome time! went for a double birthday for friends turning 40. Amazing waitress, amazing food and amazing ambience. All the way around a great experience. They even had special birthday menus made. will go every time we visit now.
Was really disappointed. Since it was so highly rated for romance I thought an outdoor table would be nice. The outdoor dining area had all the romance of eating at a cheap metal table in the parking area of a strip mall (which it very nearly was).
Maybe eating indoors would have been nicer, but there's way too many charming, romantic places to eat in Key West to bother finding out on another trip.
On the plus side the staff were nice.
Food was average at best.
Food was good.
One hour to get my dish ! !
Something wrong in the kitchen !
Great food and great service. Food was a bit pricey.
Sat at bar. Tony was terrific. Hostesses were all very friendly. Food was excellent.
Not our favorite
Just OK. Stone crab was a special and a little fishy. Not Joes in Miami Beach. She crab soup was great. We three had filet mignon wit bone in and all we raw in the center. Ordered medium rare. Went back and charred outside still raw. Creamed spinach was full leaves with a floury cream sauce with raw garlic. Didn’t eat it. Desserts were good. Not what we expected for a 500$ dinner with tip and wine.
First time going there and everything exceeded all expectations.
Wonderful restaurant. Delicious food and great service
Our waiter was great! He had very good knowledge of the items on the menu and so he made excellent recommendations! My beef carpaccio was very good but way too many diced tomatoes. Shrimp cocktails were excellent with great horseradish sauce. Steaks were good. My yellow tuna Oscar style was delicious!
Food was fantastic! A bit pricey but for an occasion it was worth it.
It was my birthday and they were nice enough to seat us in a private room, as well as give us a free key lime pie for my birthday. Amazing service.
We sat at the bar where Tony took excellent care of us. Overall, the food was very good but maybe the best steak in Key West just doesn’t measure up.
One of best meals ive ever had
Great food. The server's were very attentive. We really enjoyed the dining experience.
Service & food are some of the best we have had , the place is very well decorated and cleanI would highly recomend
Wait staff and management are awesome! So accommodating. Food delicious. Served at a wonderful pace.
The food was very tasty, the ambience and staff were great. We were not rushed. They paid attention to detail. Didn’t have to wait long for service, seating, food or drinks. A must when you visit the Keys
The Food and Service was Outstanding AAA+++ , I would definitely recommend this to Everyone that could afford the pricing, there are some moderate priced items but most are relatively pricey but well worth the money.
Everything was perfect!
I get the steakhouse model...great but very expensive steaks, ala carte. And I'm completely cool with that. But for me, if I'm going to spend $50-$60 for a steak, it better be memorable and this simply wasn't. Don't get me wrong, the food was very good. The service was impeccable. The ambiance was nice. For me it simply wasn't worth the money.
Pavel, our server, made our steak and lobster dinner and our last night in Key West, very memorable. thank you!
Great service and food as always! Never rushed and very polite service.
We arrived late due to rain and Denise was so kind to seat us exactly where we wanted to be, in spite of having to reassign other diners. Palu was a great waiter and the custom drinks were made to perfection. Make life easy and get the items at the top of the menu. Shrimp cocktail—-huge. Filet, even rare, done to perfection. And the banana bread pudding led the dessert list. It is a real go-back experience.
Pablo was a terrific server, steaks were wonderful, great patio!
Great steak..beautiful outside seating overlooking the water.
Went to Prime Steakhouse for the first time and we were VERY impressed. Food and service were top notch. If we ever get back to Key West, we'll be back to Prime Steakhouse.
The service was impeccable! The food was good but the prices were very high so I was pretty shocked. We went for a birthday celebration and they did do a nice sparkly dessert which made the night!
We had the NY Strip which was cooked perfect and our server was amazing. However, the prices here are high with the ambiance being unremarkable.
Excellent food. My filet was perfectly cooked medium rare and a delicious lobster tail. I also ordered a side of asparagus which was more than enough for 2 people. While the prices are steep, I don’t think you’ll ever be disappointed. Also ordered the coconut cheesecake and it was incredibly good and I’m not a cheesecake fan. Will definitely be back again.
Second time dining here in a month. Great service, great food.
Very nice evening always a great place!
One of our favorite places in Key West! Superb fine dining! Best steaks on the island! Cooked perfection… Escargot is a MUST. The Staff make you feel like family!
One of our favorite places in Key West! Superb fine dining! Best steaks on the island! Cooked perfection. The Staff make you feel like family! BUT WAY OVER PRICED
Anyone who says steaks are amazing is clueless Or lying. Steaks overpriced and below average. Save your money. Do not recommend.
Large wedding was a little distracting.
Highly recommend Prime!!! Excellent food and atmosphere!!! Great service!💕