Host your next celebration, meeting or private event in style at The Garden City Hotel. Gianna Costa, our Private Dining Specialist, will assist in executing every detail to perfection.View Private Dining Details
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun - Thu 5:30PM - 10:00PM
Fri - Sat 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Eat at Polo Steakhouse and expect a grand experience! Their Sangria is delicious...bet cha can’t have just one, and their food is delectable!! Our Server, Dane, is OUTSTANDING!! We’ll ask for him over and over again. Get yourselves to Polo Steakhouse
We celebrated one our coworker baby-shower. All the waiters were very attentive and nice from the moment you valet your car
Food wise was OK, not worth the price per person
But overall was good, first time and was good to be able to see what the brunch is all about
Absolutely fabulous and on par with the brunch at Peacock Alley at the Waldorf! The service staff was just great...friendly and attentive. They kept the champagne flowing and were unobtrusive in removing plates when we finished each course. The food was diverse from lobster to carved meat, sushi, pasta salad, shrimp...you name it was there. Some things we didn't get a chance to taste so we'll be back! Don't miss the frosted crueller...just yummie!
Great birthday spent at polo steakhouse!
Impeccable service. They greet you at the door by name and welcome you to the restaurant. The wait staff was great and the food matched in quality as well. Definitely will come back again!
Service was extremely slow. Took over 3 hours for dinner. Filet was over cooked.
Thanks for s wonderful night!
Excellent choice for a special occasion. Attentive staff, wonderful food and drinks.
My best friend and I treat each other to brunch for our birthdays each year, and we both look forward to it so much! The food at Polo is always fresh and delicious, and the service is unrivaled. If you're staying at the Garden City Hotel, or just happen to be in the area, it's a must-try!
Amazing Afternoon Tea service
Great, good food delicious drinks
Always exceptional! Great food! Great drinks! Great service!
Interestingly enough even though Open Table took my reservation, the Polo Lounge was closed for dinner. We ended up having our business dinner in the Pub at the Garden City hotel (one of the best burgers I've had in a long time)
The Restaurant was fantastic. Food, ambience & service were impeccable. We were escorted to our table where there was a lovely birthday card (my husband's birthday) signed by the staff. Nice Touch! As far as value, although everything was terrific it is definitely a bit pricey. However, since it was a special occasion & not an everyday occurrence, it was doable. In general the noise level would have been perfect had it not been for some guests who where in the adjoining Polo Lounge with their Ill mannered, loud & obnoxious brewd! One would think that people would excercise the ability to think clearly & realize that you don't bring children that are uncontrollable & rude into this type of establishment. It would behoove them to hire a babysitter!!!! Common Sense!
Having said this, the overall experience was top notch & I would highly recommend it, particularly for special occasions.
always pleased when we dine here, service great as well as food
As usual, my experience there was great!
The food was very salty and unfortunately we never said anything to our server so we did not give them the opportunity to fix the issue and provide us with a meal we would have enjoyed more.
Have been to Polo's several times before, but never for the Restaurant Week Menu. The dinner was SUPER delicious and so well prepared. Both food AND service were OUTSTANDING!!! Our server, Lamar was AMAZING!!!
The service was wonderful. The steak we had was tough and fatty.
Going to the Polo Steakhouse is always a treat. The ambiance is lovely and quite calming
The service is impeccable without being overbearing
Naturally the food is wonderful and well presented
Also, a great place to stop by for a drink in the lovely bar
We visited Polo Grill during Restaurant Week (January 2018) to get together with friends. Their Restaurant Menu was not included on the Restaurant Week website. Knowing the reputation the Garden City Hotel, we thought it was a great opportunity to try it. While the restaurant is nicely appointed, the wait staff was attentive, the menu choice was minimal. We have had much better fare at other restaurants in the area participating in Restaurant Week. Morton's Steak House t had filet and a number of other choices vs. Polo's sliced sirloin, chicken and fish. The two desserts offered were good.
While we had a wonderful evening and a meal that was average I would choose another restaurant next time.
Excellent dinner and service. There was a little too much time between appetizer and dinner but it's better than being rushed. We both had the scallops, which I have to say, is one of the best restaurant dinners I have ever had. The room was a little cold (temperature wise) so I was not that comfortable. I would recommend this for a special occasion as it's pricey, or if you want to impress someone!
Great place Great food Great ambiance nice place to celebrate special occasions
Polo did not disappoint during our restaurant week meal! Great, friendly service, meat cooked perfectly, fine dining and quiet, elegant ambiance.
Outstanding. I’m taking my wife there for our Valentine’s dinner.
I Love polo steak house. The food was amazing. The employees were wonderful.
Lamar our server was outstanding! Food was great!
Asked for our date night table to moved from two larger groups on each side of us to a table across the room that was not being used ( actually 3 tables were unoccupied ) and we were told NO. Suggestion for their staff to have better customer service
Great customer service
The restaurant presented my dessert with a birthday candle and didn’t sing to me thankfully. I would have given an outstanding rating if my cherry clafoutis hadn’t been dry and tough. The rest of our meal was perfect. Excellent service. Relaxed atmosphere.
I took my wife for her birthday after visiting the Red Door Spa located downstairs.
The staff wished my wife a happy birthday upon checking in with the host. They even gave her a birthday card signed by the entire staff and brought out desert singing happy birthday. The food looked and tasted fantatic. The service was Top notch as well.
We will Definitely be back!
Service is impeccable and food is top notch! Highly recommended.
Well decorated restaurant with good foof and attentive service. A nice spot for special occasions.
Good setting and comfortable table and seating. Great food but unfortunately we had two overwhelmingly noisy and boisterous tables next to us. That put a damper on an expensive dinner.
Most All was good . Lacking in managerial over see of Place . No one at from
Host counter and not professional .
This place should be rocking it most nights , most tables empty . It’s got all the makings of a great Restaurant , let’s see it happen !!
The Polo Steakhouse never disappoints! The service was impeccable and Carlos was attentive without being intrusive and was eager to please! The chef really knows what he is doing, the food was delicious and beautifully presented. Overall it was a wonderful experience and look forward to my next visit. Thank you.
10 stars!!! Food is absolutely outstanding, I had the filet mignon. The service was great. I very highly recommend.
Could not have been better. Service: outstanding. Everyone loved their lunch selection from scallops to salmon to grilled chicken to a burger. The serving size is plenty and appropriate, not overdone, so you have room for dessert. Split the chocolate cake with someone. It comes with hot fudge so a half is again plenty. We are planning a return get together and there is no better place than here.
Awesome seasonal drinks, scrumptious meal and impeccable service. The staff goes out of their way to be accommodating. Very well worth dining there. Thank you!
When it comes to service and food, I can't really complain. The staff was kind and courteous. They did take forever with my special request for my husband's bday but they were very apologetic and therefore, I chalk that up to "stuff happens". The restaurant was not busy at that time so perhaps it was forgotten.
The only true criticism I have is maybe the expense is a bit over the top. I understand it is in the Garden City Hotel and Hotel prices especially when fine dining is pricey, however, I think it was more expensive than any high end restaurant I've dined out at in Manhattan or maybe I haven't dined out enough lately. Oh, and the noise level was annoying. It was hard to hear my guests at the table. That is my only complaint. Would definitely go again without hesitation.