Went to Plumsteadville Inn for Valentine's Day. Overall, it was very good, but the meal was slow to come out. We have been there before in the past, and never had any issues (nor did it appear others did), so we believe it to be an isolated occurrence.
We would (and will) go there in the future. Very good pub food and comfort food.
Great place to go for Valentines Day dinner!
The food and service was excellent even though the restaurant was very crowded.
Incredible time. My fiance and I went for Valentine's dinner. They did an unbelievable job with extra little perks and free dessert and champagne. Only been here a few times, but never have a bad time.
Courteous and friendly service. Varied menu with reasonable prices. Great food.
Birthday it was perfect!
Food and cocktails were great. Children running the reception was frustrating. We were sat 30 mins after or reservation time even though we arrived 10 mins early.
We went to the Plumsteadville Inn after not having been there for many years. We were so impressed with our meal and our service. My scallops were tender and tasty and my husband's steak was excellent. We were in the room behind the bar and could not hear a sound, although it was full of people. The decor is beautiful and all in all, a wonderful evening was had by us and our friends.
Delicious brunch with a great variety of food and desserts!
Excellent spot. Food is always decent and the atmosphere is local and great!
Disappointed. Server friendly but inattentive. As soon as meal was served she came by and asked how was our meal. Had not taken first bite. Discovered that our potatoes were cold, butter did not even begin to melt. Asparagus barely warm. My wife's prime rib appered to be cooked as ordered but not warm. My filet and daughters scallops were hot and very good. Waitress never came back, we tried several times to get her attention. Asked hostess to sent server over when she seated a party near us. She never followed up. Finally my wife left the table in search of our server and encountered a manager. He took our potatoes and wife's prime rib back to kitchen and apparently spoke to server
Medium cooled prome rib came hot, but on the well done side. Potatoes returned hot, but slightly dry. Appreciate that manager did not charge us for one dinner but very disappointed with the overall experience. Server and folks in food prep area really dropped the ball.
Food was great tonight and our waiter was really nice and attentive!
So, this was New Year's Eve. They overbooked, we were seated almost one hour after the reservation. Ok, it's New Year's Eve... got it. However once seated we were greeted by our server almost immediately. It went downhill from there. Bar service was VERY slow. Food was not up to par either and slow to come. My "medium" filet was way past well done, tough and barely warm. My wife had the Prime Rib that looked good. The live music was very good but the food and service (not our server, but the service in general) was very poor. They really bit off more than they could chew for New Year's Eve. We expect it will be better on a "normal" weekend or weekday. I would stay away on these special nights.
Went for New Years Eve. Very disappointing. After waitress took our drink order, we asked for bread. Had to ask twice. Took 25 minutes to get. She was not very attentive. My wife ordered filet. It was not well done as requested. Sat by a window. Drafty and chilly. It appears they overbooked.
The food and service was excellent. There was a large New Year’s Eve crowd, but the food and service remained consistent. I recommend this restaurant for any occasion.