Great happy hour price point. Service was great and food was good. Pizza could have been hotter.
We love this place! And you can’t be the happy hour value! Even my kids love it and request we dine there.
Consistent quality and execution of the menu, excellent personalized service. Arguably some of the best pizza in the City, far better than the designated "hot" pizza places.
Amazing as always. Expanded menu looks great. Happy hour was fun.
Grest pizza. Good the dough the ingredients and the cooking. Nice the place with table outside and very good the service
delicious and inventive veggies, great fish and of course wonderful thin crust pizzas.
Great food and service. Must try the pizza's (sausage was spectacular).
Great food that will satisfy almost anyone; restaurant is filled with couples and families of all ages. Does not offer gluten free pasta or pizza but other (limited but good) choices available. A bit loud for serious conversation but expert service and an overall cheery experience make it one of the better choices on the Upper West Side.
Loved it. Great happy hour- though sad to see some of the previous items removed from the menu!
Great vibe. Love the decor and ambiance of this upper west side neighborhood gem. Happy hour has a nice assortment of food and drink and is available in the whole restaurant till 7 pm. We had the lemon ricotta pasta, penne, grilled asparagus and mushroom pizza at our table and everyone was pleased. (Decided not to eat on the happy hour menu, other than the house red wine, as these other dishes looked so good!). We are definitely going to make this a stop on our next trip to NYC.
Meatball and artichoke appetizers were delicious. Great pizza. Recommended.
We’ve been here a number of times and keep returning because of the consistently good food and service
Excellent service! Delicious food! We had the special asparagus appetizer, mini kale salad, meatball parmigiana slider, lemon pasta and pizza. Everything came out hot and delicious! We’ll be back!
The best pizza on the Upper West Side and creative cocktails
Happy hour has excellent value! We enjoyed the pizza and the arancini very much.
Great place, best casual pizza night out in the neighborhood!
Great spot, fun crowd, easy night
Service above and beyond. Appreciated.
Nice place, great atmosphere, excellent service, good food, huge value with Happy Hour prices! Will definitely be back.
They keep on changing their happy hour menu (food wise) and it keep on deteriorating and deteriorating. Food is still good, but value is meh.
Perfect spot for an early dinner with children. Also, a perfect spot for all.
Good classic Italian dishes in a cozy spot that has friendly and wonderful servers. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal! :)
I’m always impressed with their wait staff! Food is amazing too!
great date night spot, we ended up sitting at the bar as it was happy hour. Drinks and Food are perfect. The bartender is one of the nicest people i have ever met, he makes sure your drink is never empty and you get what you asked for. Main reason why we keep coming to Sirenetta
I love this place. I live in PA but every time i come to the city i try to go to eat here. Excellent job!
It was fantastic as usual. There is something for everyone and the food is superb. Especially the chicken!! A better selection of white wines by the glass would be great. But we are frequent diners here and love it
My husband and I had reservations for a Saturday afternoon around 5pm. The staff is super friendly, I have nothing but praise for them. The inside looks very clean and bright. Unfortunately we had a heavy brunch earlier that day and were not able to order as much as I wanted. We love the Mermaid Inn Happy Hour and wanted to try out the Pizzeria Sirenetta Happy Hour as well, which was the reason for this first visit. We had 2 meatball sliders and the tomato/basil/mozzarella pizza from the Happy Hour menu and we enjoyed it. I definitely want us to come back and try out the rest of the Happy Hour menu.
Love this place! Food is excellent, pizzas are authentic, and it’s reasonably priced
Great ambiance, food, and service.
Absolutely a neighborhood gem! From happy hour to full menu, the food is superb. Cocktails and wine selections are great, too. All-in-all, one of my favorite places to eat on the UWS.
Fantastic in every way. Noisy, but fun. Wait staff was terrific.
We went there to meet my cousin from California. I've been to Pizzeria Sirenetta for many times, mostly during happy hour. We had tomato, mozzarella, basil pizza with kale salad and rigatoni bolognese. Like always, food was amazing, but I wished there were bigger portion. The price is not cheap, but what you get is quite small. For taste and quality of food, I would definitely go back though.
I love this place for Happy Hour. Always buzzing, the atmosphere is cheerful, and the food comes fast. Thank you, Sirenetta!
The food is very good. We go for the Happy Hour deals, which really are terrific. Of course, that means it's a little crazy with lots of young children. But it's fun and the food is delicious, and you can eat a really nice meal with wine for about $35 per person. Not so easy in Manhattan these days!
Food is always good!
The pizza was undercooked. Raw dough and the manager defensively explained to me that it is “Neapolitan” pizza. Not sure there are many New Yorkers who haven’t had Neapolitan pizza. I’ve eaten at the restaurant many times and have always loved it. Assuming that the weekend chef is different and maybe they will turn it around.
Its ALWAYS good. We go here several days a week to eat, and being that I am in the food industry; when I say food is GOOD it has to REALLY be good! Nothing here is bad... NOTHING.
One of our favorite neighborhood spots. The food is always great and the staff very friendly.
Went on a Monday night and received excellent service. The food was very good and the staff was very friendly. Great neighborhood restaurant.
I wish they would help me with the stroller when I was struggling to open the front doors...