Great local place, pizza hits the spot, and fantastic HH pricing!
We had the fried artichoke, pasta and a couple cocktails. All were very good, large portions. Waiter was very attentive. There were a lot of families there, so it did get pretty loud.
Bring back the free panna cotta!
I love the food here, but I have to say that I don't go as often as I'd like because the noise level is insane -- Not conducive to pleasant dining. Loud music. Hard wall surfaces so that conversation echoes around. You have to talk loud to converse and that's an effort when you're eating. They've also changed the menu. They used to automatically give a small panna cotta at the end of the meal, and not offer any other dessert. it was just right and such a nice touch. Now they offer a dessert menu. Not as personal a touch as before. But my two favorites are still on the menu, so that's good!
Pizza was pretty good, pasta was pretty bad- was like eating a bowl of salt with a bit of pasta unfortunately. If we were to go back, would be to eat pizza definitely not the pasta.
The best - the happy hour can’t be beat.
The food here is SO GOOD and the service was excellent! Will definitely be going back!
The food and service were both excellent! Started with cocktails and appetizers followed by a wood fired pizza and house made pasta. The fried artichokes and the house made linguinette were the two stand outs for me. Will definitely be back! Great upper westside gem.
Great place on the UWS. Casual but always good to have a reservation as it gets crowded. Although if you don’t have one the bar is comfortable and they serve food. When we are in the area it’s always a place we go to
Wonderful experience at Pizzeria Sirenetta! Excellent food and service from the lovely hostesses to the bartender/barback (extremely accommodating and patient bartender - thank you!) and excellent waiter. Thank you for a lovely evening. Can’t wait to return!
The food is saltier and saltier and I like seasoning! I really like this place, but they are really heavy on the salt.
Excellent service and great Happy Hour. Loved all the items on the Happy Hour menu and the Pepperoncini Martini was awesome.
The food never disappoints.
Super cute decor and the food was outstanding! The lemon ricotta pasta was absolutely delicious
The food was excellent and they were very accommodating to my toddler
Sirinetta is one of our favorite neighborhood places. The food is always great and we love the casual lively atmosphere.
Happy hour was excellent. The food was delicious and the drinks were yummy. Great value!
Really great neighborhood restaurant. Good food, good value and a fun busy atmosphere.
Always a great meal.
I'm a regular. Food is always delish and staff are very friendly.
Great happy hour price point. Service was great and food was good. Pizza could have been hotter.
We love this place! And you can’t be the happy hour value! Even my kids love it and request we dine there.
We've been here before but now they have new menu items. The fried artichoke hearts were outstanding along with the Octopus. Sydneyis the hostesss/manager there. She kept asking how we liked the new menu items. A wonderful and memorable evening. Can't wait to return. We are part time NYers
Consistent quality and execution of the menu, excellent personalized service. Arguably some of the best pizza in the City, far better than the designated "hot" pizza places.
Amazing as always. Expanded menu looks great. Happy hour was fun.
Grest pizza. Good the dough the ingredients and the cooking. Nice the place with table outside and very good the service
delicious and inventive veggies, great fish and of course wonderful thin crust pizzas.
Great food and service. Must try the pizza's (sausage was spectacular).
Great food that will satisfy almost anyone; restaurant is filled with couples and families of all ages. Does not offer gluten free pasta or pizza but other (limited but good) choices available. A bit loud for serious conversation but expert service and an overall cheery experience make it one of the better choices on the Upper West Side.
Loved it. Great happy hour- though sad to see some of the previous items removed from the menu!
Great vibe. Love the decor and ambiance of this upper west side neighborhood gem. Happy hour has a nice assortment of food and drink and is available in the whole restaurant till 7 pm. We had the lemon ricotta pasta, penne, grilled asparagus and mushroom pizza at our table and everyone was pleased. (Decided not to eat on the happy hour menu, other than the house red wine, as these other dishes looked so good!). We are definitely going to make this a stop on our next trip to NYC.
Meatball and artichoke appetizers were delicious. Great pizza. Recommended.
We’ve been here a number of times and keep returning because of the consistently good food and service
Excellent service! Delicious food! We had the special asparagus appetizer, mini kale salad, meatball parmigiana slider, lemon pasta and pizza. Everything came out hot and delicious! We’ll be back!
The best pizza on the Upper West Side and creative cocktails
Happy hour has excellent value! We enjoyed the pizza and the arancini very much.
Great place, best casual pizza night out in the neighborhood!
Great spot, fun crowd, easy night
Service above and beyond. Appreciated.