Food is always good!
The pizza was undercooked. Raw dough and the manager defensively explained to me that it is “Neapolitan” pizza. Not sure there are many New Yorkers who haven’t had Neapolitan pizza. I’ve eaten at the restaurant many times and have always loved it. Assuming that the weekend chef is different and maybe they will turn it around.
Its ALWAYS good. We go here several days a week to eat, and being that I am in the food industry; when I say food is GOOD it has to REALLY be good! Nothing here is bad... NOTHING.
One of our favorite neighborhood spots. The food is always great and the staff very friendly.
Went on a Monday night and received excellent service. The food was very good and the staff was very friendly. Great neighborhood restaurant.
I wish they would help me with the stroller when I was struggling to open the front doors...
the food is always delicious !! never disappointed.
Excellent service! Pizzas were delightful. :) Definitely a good, casual place to meet with friends in the local area.
Food was good - love the olives. The broccoli rabe and pizza were a little too cold when they arrived (lukewarm), but besides that, food was tasty!
Great food and service! Could use a dessert menu.
I love this place. It has reliable food, charming, cordial service, fair prices, nice wines. If we are a group of 4, I usually share one pizza as an appetizer ( they are wonderful) , then two pastas to share, glasses of wine, a kale salad and brussel sprouts on the side. Vegetables and salads are delicious. The cacio e pepe was excellent one time and a bit bland the next. The rigatoni was light and flavorful with lots of herbs and just a little meat. They bring an on the house panna cotta for dessert. A nice touch.
We were there for a casual dinner on a Saturday night. Never had a bad experience here. Place is fun, service and food are excellent for the cost. Bottom line a restaurant that punches above its weight. Highly recommend.
Overall, I would definitely go back. Great space. Good options. Good food. Nice Staff.
This is a solid local place- The menu in VERY limited . Also be aware that it's a very family friendly restaurant hence lots of kids and strollers etc. Not s great vibe for date night. Also they do have happy hour from 4-7pm but very limited to what you can order. They select the drinks
We come every week and love it! Consistently amazing
Great happy hour and food. Service was also great. Accommodating for families.
We eat here now 2 to 4 times a week! It's our new go to spot. The food is some of the best I have EVER had and I have been ALL over this world. The only thing is they are big about " the kitchen closes in 5 mins" so make sure you're able to give yourself some time to review the menu, order appetizers , before they close off the kitchen.
Great ambiance and amazing service! Food was on the smaller side but delicious.
The food & service was outstanding—and always is (go there a lot). They do these tiny things that make the whole experience special. Just one example: lookup the reservation before you sit, and use your name through the meal. I feel like those simple things are too often missing today. That (and the food, of course) is how they rise above the other NYC restaurant noise and clutter!
Went during happy hour, which was the right choice. Any other time, would not have felt like a good value. Solid neighborhood spot, average service.
Went for my birthday on the recommendation of the risotto balls. The server told us they weren’t available since happy hour ended 15 minutes prior. I told him it was my birthday and why we came and he just said sorry. Food was good and service otherwise fine but disappointing in a world of endless dining choices they don’t choose to differentiate on service.
Blind date, she was a disaster.
The food and drinks were great!
Very busy on a Friday night. My wife loved the Lasagna, the fra diavolo seafood pasta was good, but they put cheese on it prior to serving (a big gaffe in Italy!). Service was slow at first but they were jammed after all. After initial delay it was quite prompt and friendly. But the noise in the back room was a bit much. It was not as bad as The Smith on Broadway or Tacombi on 24th (both of which nearly made my ears bleed), but don’t expect to have an intimate conversation. We’ll definitely return as the food is always good and frankly is a very good value.
Mermaid inn restaurants never miss. Happy hour is the best!!!!!
I love this place. I go there all the time. It never, ever disappoints!
Your cash register crashed, Inconvenient to use cash. No concession was made for the inconvenience at the bar.
Good place, very cozy atmosphere, waitresses very gentle
Love the food at PS. It’s our go to neighborhood place.
Love this place! Service is good, staff is personable, ambiance is great and price is right!
Excellent food. Great pizza
Loved dining here! Had such an amazing time with my husband. Would’ve hoped the server hadn’t dropped the check while we were still eating, making us feel rushed out but it was good over all.
We have been to this restaurant many times. Reliably wonderful. We started with a pizza as an appetizer (for two adults and two children). Then ordered brussel sprouts ( delicious) and cauliflower sides ( skipped the kale salad but it looked nice) to have with cacio e pepe...2 orders split 4 ways was ample. They bring a free panne cotta for everyone dessert. Service was prompt and friendly. This is one of my "good to" spots. Fair prices and good Italian food. Kid-friendly.Lots of couples and families...all ages...a nice vibe. The UWS at its best.
Consistently really good.
Nice staff, fantastic pizzas. Their vegetable dishes show creativity, and pastas are tasty. I'm definitely coming back soon.
Too expensive for the quality of food it offers. Pizzas are lower than average and pasta selection is very limited.
We were very disappointed that you discontinued your complimentary panna cotta. We always look forward to it. We are neighborhood regulars.
Delicious food with seasonal vegetables imaginatively prepared and great service.
Flatbread, pizza and pastas were all delicious. Service was solid.
Lovely server, friendly atmosphere, and great food!
My grandchildren adored it. Food and service was great! I missed the complementary flan at the end of the meal