Love the food at PS. It’s our go to neighborhood place.
Love this place! Service is good, staff is personable, ambiance is great and price is right!
Excellent food. Great pizza
We have been to this restaurant many times. Reliably wonderful. We started with a pizza as an appetizer (for two adults and two children). Then ordered brussel sprouts ( delicious) and cauliflower sides ( skipped the kale salad but it looked nice) to have with cacio e pepe...2 orders split 4 ways was ample. They bring a free panne cotta for everyone dessert. Service was prompt and friendly. This is one of my "good to" spots. Fair prices and good Italian food. Kid-friendly.Lots of couples and families...all ages...a nice vibe. The UWS at its best.
Consistently really good.
Nice staff, fantastic pizzas. Their vegetable dishes show creativity, and pastas are tasty. I'm definitely coming back soon.
Too expensive for the quality of food it offers. Pizzas are lower than average and pasta selection is very limited.
We were very disappointed that you discontinued your complimentary panna cotta. We always look forward to it. We are neighborhood regulars.
Delicious food with seasonal vegetables imaginatively prepared and great service.
Flatbread, pizza and pastas were all delicious. Service was solid.
Lovely server, friendly atmosphere, and great food!
My grandchildren adored it. Food and service was great! I missed the complementary flan at the end of the meal
Great easy dinner after a movie with our adult son. Wonderful wines and delicious pizza!
We had dinner at the restaurant on Christmas Eve! The food was absolutely amazing! My mouth waters just thinking about it!!!
I’m sorry to report that the food has gone downhill. Used to be a favorite neighborhood place for a bite - no longer.
Clam pizza was slimy, kale salad was not what it used to be and fritto midtown was a tiny portion.
Always a great time! Love their happy hour - best around! The service is always excellent and very family friendly. Perfect neighborhood spot!
There was something for everyone including the guest who does not eat pasta or pizza. The crayons and kid sized portion was wonderful for the 5 year old guest who DOES eat pizza!
The food is much too salty. It’s the dominant flavor in all the dishes.
The people who manage this restaurant do not respect or treat customers well. There is a sense of arrogance. We will not go back!
Our dinners were uniformly good. Wish that gluten free pizza was on the menu.
Went for the happy hour menu. The fennel sausage pizza was wonderful. The risotto balls were quite tasty as well. We tried to go back a second night but we couldn’t get a reservation. Very sad.
everything is great and I try to try new things but frequently go back to the pizza!
We ate here after a long afternoon of travel. Everything was great, from a nice table to good cocktail and great food.
Expensive but delicious
Food was fine not great, service was functional at best
Excellent food, just very loud but worth it a very good meal. Service was also very good.
Camille’s food is amazing! Jamie our server was really solid and professional.
Pizzas are so good! Friendly service. A great spot.
Always a local favorite although it feels like portion sizes are getting smaller and the non-pizza and pasta options have disappeared. Salads and appetizers are all still great, as are the pizzas.
The noise level is a major problem; even the crowding would be more tolerable but for the noise. The food is good, and the service a non-issue in this tight space.
Loved the fabulous food!! Attentive wait staff but it’s all about the food.. AMAZING!!
Pizzeria Sirenetta is a neighborhood favorite that my family and friends visit often.
The other evening, instead of the usual excellent pizzas, my friends and I opted for two pizzas for 4 of us as well as a variety of delicious and creative appetizers. We each received a complementary panna cotta the end of our meal, a very nice touch.
I'm not the only one who loves Pizzeria Sirenetta - reservations are a must!
Used to be way better. Gone down considerably. Soggy sliders. Appetizers and entree served together. Could do much better.
The broccoli appetizer was AMAZING - truly tasty and served as my meal. i also enjoyed my arugula salad, my daughter enjoyed her pizza, customized for her, and our server recommended a lovely Sauvignon Blanc from Chile when I described the wine I usually enjoy.
Despite the fact that the place was totally booked, I called to say that we were running late, and the woman on the phone said, “No worry, don’t rush, it will be fine.” It was so much better than that. Fresh original food, requests quickly honored, friendly banter with the server, helpful advice, a total neighborhood feeling — a great night!
I'm a regular and it never fails to please. Great pizza, pasta and veggies. Very nice staff.
One of the very best restaurants on the UWS. Wonderful food and friendly, competent staff!
I have eaten there twice in the last two weeks. The waitstaff is superb: helpful, but not hovering, friendly, but not intrusive. The roasted brussels sprouts are fabulous, and the cauliflower appetizer is delicious. We loved the pasta with ricotta and meyer lemon. Don't forget to ask for your complimentary dessert--an espresso-sized cup of lovely vanilla pannacotta. This has become my local go-to restaurant.
I feel like I'm a regular. It is consistently very good.
We went based on good online reviews and were not disappointed. Octopus appetizer was very tasty. The pizza had good flavor, but we would have liked a crispier crust (next time I'll try to remember to ask them to keep it in the oven a bit longer). We were there during happy hour (until 7, which is unusual), and the $5 glass of wine was a delicious bargain. Definitely a reason to return!