Best authentic Italian around no
Doubt! They best
Great as always!!!
Our go to restaurant for pizza. Always good food and nice cozy atmosphere.
Best place around for great brick oven pizza and entrees! We’ve been going there since they opened! Service is excellent and personable and Mario and Jake always make it a point to come to the table to say hi and make sure everything is perfect! It always is! Prices are comparable to restaurants offering fresh and delisious food! Highly recommend Pizza Nostalgia!!! Sherry M
As usually Mario does a great job with his food, service and great staff
Everything on the menu from appetizers to salads, pizza to pasta to dessert is excellent. The only problem is deciding on what to order and knowing when to stop eating. The food and service is fantastic. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Excellent service, even better, food and atmosphere. Highly recommend.
Brought my cousin who is from out of town here for the first time, and needless to say she LOVED it! She has MANY allergies to food, which makes it hard for her to find something she enjoys, and Pizza Nostalgia is the place for her to enjoy any dish on the menu. We got the garlic cheese bread, which is absolutely amazing and two small pizzas. Everything was cooked perfectly and our server Alec was awesome! Overall, great experience as always and we will certainly be back for more!
Food and service excellent as always. Have never had a bad experience in multiple visits
We have eaten here a few times and each time we have had great service and the food is always very tasty. Pleasant waitstaff and clean environment. Would definitely dine here again.
Everything was great except for the Cannoli was very hard, like break a tooth hard. Mentioned it to the waitress about it being so hard, she said "I know" lol. Next time we will try something else. lol All's good
Great family atmosphere. A lot a choices on the menu. Great special valentines day menu. Staff was wonderful. Chef Owner actually came out a sat with us for a few.
We LOVE this place! Best pizza, by far, in the area. Family place where the ervice is always friendly. Good wines. Leave room for the smores pizza!
Fabulous pizza and great salads. Will return. Desserts looked great but were too full to try.
it was very busy made reservations so didn't wait long for our table the food & service was very good was glad they had gutlen free menu I will differently go back
Pizza Nostalgia is consistently great. Pizza is great. Salads are great. Top quality ingredients. This isn't fast-food pizza. It is where you go when you want pizza and it has to be worth eating.
It had a really nice ambiance where you could see pizzas being made and put into the stone oven. We ordered an antipasta salad which was delicious. Pumpkin spice cannolis were amazing.
Great service , always polite and never disappointed
Amazing food and great atmosphere!!!! We really enjoyed our pizza, and the staff/waitress was nice and friendly. We will be back.
Food was excellent as always. Seated us before our reservation time. We're "pizza spoiled", can't go anywhere else.
Definitely will be back!
Great pizza!!! Get carryout from here at least once a month! First time eating in and it was just as amazing!
Delicious pizza and good drinks! Somewhat loud environment. Overall, a great time!
We truly enjoyed the pizza. The restaurant is small and quaint and I loved watching the chefs toss the dough and cook the pizza in the brick oven :)
Courteous. Sweet young server. Took time to answer questions about their menu. The pizza, arancinni balls and gnocchi were fantastic!! The restaurant looks like the ones I used to go to in the late 50's. All in all a great experience. I can't wait to go back.
First time visit and can't wait to go back. Caprese was so good!
Love this place, great food, attentive staff. A neighborhood jewel well worth the trip.
Awesome food and staff...always friendly and great service
Love this quaint small restaurant. Their food is always good and the wait staff is very pleasant. Your food comes out to your table fairly quickly as well.
Had a wonderful meal there this past weekend. Since we had made reservations, they gave us the best table in the restaurant! Very impressed with how nice everyone was to us. Our waitress was extremely helpful and gave us the history of Pizza Nostalgia. The house salad was superb! My husband and I couldn't decide on 1 pizza so we each ordered our own personal pizzas and they were wonderful! We will definitely be back and are so excited that we live so close to this restaurant!
Always great food
Awesome staff and great food!! Very accomodating and did I mention the amazing food?
Pizza Nostalgia was an excellent choice for us. We had 10 people for Mother's Day, fairly short notice, and were pleasantly surprised by this restaurant. It doesn't look very big from the outside, but there is just enough room inside. Our table was set and waiting for us when we arrived, and we were greeted immediately. The chef and waitress were very busy, but managed to be exceptionally attentive with refills, timely food, perfectly timed breaks in between salad, pasta, pizza, and dessert. The taste of the food was fantastic, and we were able to order family style. For 10 people we ordered a family style italian salad, two family style pastas (fettuccine and pomodoro), three pizzas (two pepperoni, and one hawaiian), and it was the perfect amount. We did not have any food leftover, but everyone was full. 6 of the 10 ordered cannolis and they were lovely on the plate. Even the coffee is good. I would strongly recommend this restaurant, although I love that they haven't become excessively busy yet.
This is the best authentic wood fire pizza around. The pizzas are delicious. We had the Margarita and a pepperoni. Both were cooked perfectly with that "char" on the bottom that makes it taste wonderful. We also had the house salad. It's a simple Italian salad you'd get at Grandmas. Not fussy with the right balance of oil and vinegar. Dessert ended with a mini cannoli (only bc we were already stuffed)! Plus the leftovers are awesome the next day for a quick bite. Highly recommend!!
Always a good meal.
The food here is awesome. The service is amazing. My family and I eat here once Week.
Restaurant was 85degrees! The A/C was either broken or couldn't keep up. Food was good, waitress was just ok. Our pizza was wrong but we decided to just pick off what we didn't want rather than have it remade. I've been here before and never had it like this.