Fresh mozzarella, bacon, arugula, fresh lemon & asiago cheese
S' More Pizza
Toasted marshmallows, topped with graham cracker & Hershey's® chocolate syrup
Penne noodles tossed in a tomato cream sauce
If you haven't been here, you're missing out on authentic Italian Cuisine! Their pizza is great too!
Benny and all of the other servers are fantastic!
Loved the atmosphere. Surprised the place was so small. Pizza was a hit and we got two one meat and one in the style my wife and her friend likes. The goat cheese app was great. Tiramisu and the lemon raspberry cake was delicious. Only issue was the noise from the front door that door was being replaced at the time. Just made it noisy for awhile, but I understand that couldn't be helped.
Great food! Owner was so nice! Will be back soon😃
Great food and service , cute restaurant. We'll definitely be back
Great little pizza shop! They have a small cute dining area but they have people in out for carry out. Service and food was great as well. Nice options for those with gluten free needs. The GF pizza is a thin crust 12in and it’s very good, not sure their source. I think it’s a little $$$ coming out to about $18.99. Overall, would go back and recommend!
Delicious pizza, pasta and salad! We ordered cannoli togo, as the meals had us too full to have dessert immediately. Those were excellent later that evening.
Its a small place with warm ambience. Our waiter was attentive and nice, and he was right about those cannolu:)
This is a great place to sit back have a glass of wine and enjoy some authenic traditional Italian pizza. I have dinner dates with my adult daughters and we love to go here. It's especially inviting to two of my daughters as Pizza Nostalgia has a GF menu.
As usual our meal was excellent!! We tried a new appetizer-fried goat cheese balls with honey and balsamic. Nice amount of “heat”. Of course the Caesar salad was great-best around!! Pizzas were fabulous as usual.
Good food. Great soups and salads. They have removed many tables to allow for separation. We felt totally comfortable.
Love Pizza Nostalgia!!! Hidden gem. The staff is wonderful and very attentive!
Very casual Italian restaurant with excellent pizza. The sausage and peppers app was very good as well, but some bread would have made it even better. Very good meal for a fair price. We will be back.
great service, cozy atmosphere and awesome food!! definitely going back
Food and service is always very good. Social distancing between tables was perfect!
Great food, good atmosphere...love to support local businesses.
Really enjoyed our “date night” The food and wine were fabulous and so was our server, Jacob ! Will be back for sure!
Pizza is awesome but their pasta dishes are really good too! Very comfortable with social distancing in restaurant.
One of our favorite family restaurants!! Thank you for the great food and service as usual!
This is definitely not an authentic Italian restaurant, food was very blend, tasted like high priced Costco microwaveable food and service was not too good either, restaurant was empty but still took our waiter a while to place our order. I would not recommend eating here.
We love going here, staff is always happy and kind, food is always amazing.
Great service and food was amazing
If you have not been to Pizza Nostalgia you have got to try it..! You will fall in love with this place.. Please eat local and support small business. You will not be disappointed!
Pizza topping were excellent, like brick oven style cooked with thin crust. Liked that could view them throwing the dough, very cozy place to meet and talk without TV's screens distracting us. Can't wait to eat there again!!
We love pizza nostalgia! Great environment, food always yummy and the safe is friendly! Nice place to go on a date night or take the kids along!
Best brick oven pizza I’ve ever had! So glad the Witless political pandering and positioning wasn’t successful at putting them out of business.... yet. Prayers are with you guys!
Thanks AGAIN for the amazing grub!
This place was amazing. Extremely clean, extremely organized and the service was excellent. Our server was Jacob, he made nice recommendations and all the food was delicious. We drove 20 minutes to get here, well worth it. Look forward to our next visit.
Perfect way to end our break from restaurants! Everything was so fresh and delicious. Staff were wonderful and attentive.
One of our favorite local restaurants to dine at. The kids love it as well!
Pizza Nostalgia never disappoints! Tortellini bites have a nice hint of sweet heat with the fried jalapeño’s in the mix and added to the creamy dipping sauce. They easily modified my ‘neighbor’ order to skip the onions and add Italian sausage. The wood fired crust is the perfect balance of crisp, chewy, and sweet. Fresh, quality ingredients bring a flavor packed punch. The staff is very friendly and accommodating.
We love everything about this place. The owners, chefs and wait staff are all very welcoming and hospitable. We have been going since this place opened and the food is always fantastic. The restaurant itself is clean, follows protocols. It’s your favorite neighborhood pizza place that you never want to leave!
Exceptional food and great service. Can't wait to come back!
Very good service. Love their Michigan Salad and Mediterranean Pizza.
One of my favorite’s places for pizza & fresh Italian entrees!
Pizza Nostalgia is hands down one of our favorite little places! Pizza, pasta, and salad never disappoints! The arancini balls are by far the best we have ever had! We love this place and make it a monthly date night for us!
Awesome as always!!!
I took my friend there as a thank you dinner. We had fun, laughs and great food. We both had salads and pizza and had plenty of leftovers. I’ve ordered many times from Pizza Nostalgia and keep returning!
Great pizza and pasta !
Service was slow. The food came out at different times than the rest of the meal. My husband ordered lasagne it was not fresh. He as had it before so he knew the difference. The wine was over priced for ‘house’ wine. It was a 4 oz glass.
Our server was attentive and friendly - food was excellent.
Awesome as usually!! Melinda and Anna were so attentive and accommodating to our dietary restrictions, and gave above and beyond service!!! Our food was brought out in an appropriate amount of time, and the wine selection was wonderful as well! Always have a great experience here!
You can order delivery directly from Pizza Nostalgia using the Order Online button.
Pizza Nostalgia is rated 4.8 stars by 253 OpenTable diners.
Pizza Nostalgia does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.toasttab.com/pizza-nostalgia-wood-fired-oven/giftcards?utm_source=opentablelist&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=opentablelistcampaign.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.